Why does the Buddha always answer a question if asked three times?
score:8
It's fairly clear that three times was a social convention for crossing some sort of line; either that or just a convention of the Buddha. See also DN 3:
‘Reverend Gotama, there are four castes: the Khattiyas, the Brahmins, the merchants and the artisans. And of these four castes three — the Khattiyas, the merchants and the artisans — are entirely subservient to the Brahmins. With regard to this, it is not proper that they should not pay homage to the Brahmins.’ This was the third time Ambattha accused the Sakyans of being menials.
Then the Lord thought: ‘This young man goes too far in abusing the Sakyans."
and
Again Ambattha remained silent, and the Lord said: ‘Answer me now, Ambattha, this is not a time for silence. Whoever, Ambattha, does not answer a fundamental question put to him by a Tathāgata by the third asking has his head split into seven pieces.’
Walshe, the translator of the above, gives as a note for the second passage, "A curious threat that (as RD observes) never comes to anything, and is of course pre-Buddhist."
Not sure if the "third time" is also pre-Buddhist, but again, it appears to be some sort of line in the sand for the Buddha at least.
Upvote:3
I always assumed it was a skillful means of getting the person to go away as soon as possible. Not relenting after two rebukes, at that point, the Buddha assuming this person was not getting the hint, did what was necessary to return to seclusion.
Although I don't believe I have ever seen any mention of this in the Pali Canon, so this is only conjecture. Conjecture based on the Buddha's teaching of right speech and on the virtue of seclusion.
He avoids idle chatter and abstains from it. He speaks at the right time, in accordance with facts, speaks what is useful, speaks of the Dhamma and the discipline; his speech is like a treasure, uttered at the right moment, accompanied by reason, moderate and full of sense. – AN 10:176
In this way, one can see that the Buddha was purposeful in the manner in which he spoke, and as such would not be doing so simply as a cultural norm.
More post
- 📝 Is the Pali Canon the final authority in the Theravada tradition?
- 📝 Is 'be thankful to your parents, for they brought you life' incongruent with Buddhist thought?
- 📝 Different realms,Different beings,Different times - How do they understand what we are saying?
- 📝 Are Charnel Grounds still a thing?
- 📝 Buddhism texts which have least amount of disinformation
- 📝 Can a Buddhist use antibacterial soap?
- 📝 Suffering more in order to feel less suffering? Living with suffering?
- 📝 what's the emptiness, 空, in 3rd jhana of STED 4 jhana formula in agamas?
- 📝 What does the one taste of the dharmadhatu really mean?
- 📝 What are "Supernatural mental abilities" in relation to Buddhism?
- 📝 Are Bodhisattvas real human beings we can encounter?
- 📝 Why does Mahasi Method have the points on the Body to attend to?
- 📝 Where did the Buddha say: "What a person considers and reflects upon for a long time, to that his mind will bend and incline."?
- 📝 How to stay mindful of the gap in the breath
- 📝 What is actually Nirvana -- what are some Tripitaka sources?
- 📝 Breach of precept term
- 📝 Is there a defined counting system in Pali?
- 📝 In the Tibetan book of the dead, Chapter 2, what is the significance of NOT renouncing the 3 poisons
- 📝 Not wanting to meditate = bad karma?
- 📝 What was the motivation for the prohibition on eating onions and garlic?
- 📝 Can being a vegetarian actually be a temporary hindrance for some?
- 📝 Why is there so little emphasis on "mundane" mindfulness?
- 📝 Present moment awareness
- 📝 nirodha vs nibbana?
- 📝 Where does utilitarianism sit with Buddhism and vice versa?
- 📝 Original reference for 'The essence of all religions is love, compassion and tolerance' by the HH the Dalai Lama
- 📝 Would a stream enterer no longer need the "I am the owner and heir of my karma" reflection?
- 📝 What teachings do all schools of Buddhism share?
- 📝 How does one effectively understand & navigate through the suicide cases found in the canon?
- 📝 Is Buddhist insight non-conceptual?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Why does the Buddha always answer a question if asked three times?
- 📝 Why does the Buddha call himself the Tathāgata?
- 📝 Why does the mind always want to 'do something' and how to cultivate 'non-doing'?
- 📝 Why does the Buddha appear androgynous in some depictions?
- 📝 Why does the Buddha blame Ananda asking him to remain living forever?
- 📝 Why did the Buddha not answer Vacchagotta (SN 44.10), but did answer the monks (MN 140)?
- 📝 Where does it say in the Three Baskets that Buddha used to be a prince?
- 📝 Why did the Buddha suffer before he died?
- 📝 Attachment is a poison. Why is attachment to the Buddha and to Buddhist philosophy not a problem?
- 📝 Why the Buddha didn't originally allow ordination of women
- 📝 Why is the Buddha described as trackless?
- 📝 If there is no soul or self, why did the Buddha speak of his past lives?
- 📝 Why do Buddhists believe that the Buddha was enlightened, despite that he claimed it himself?
- 📝 If a Buddhist believes lay life is not ideal for the practice, why does he or she continue?
- 📝 Why did the Buddha touch the earth at his enlightenment?
- 📝 Why did physical representations of the Buddha only start to appear a few centuries after his death?
- 📝 Why does Mara, the Evil One one comes looking for consciousness at death?
- 📝 Does the Buddha like dogs?
- 📝 What Gautam Buddha said about "self", in Chapter Three of the Mahayana Mahaparinirvana Sutra?
- 📝 Why does the Buddha, in the Pali Canon, periodically engage in harsh speech?
- 📝 Why do some English-language texts refer to the Buddha as "Lord"?
- 📝 Does Pure Land Buddhism ever have a Buddha other than Amitābha as the object of devotion?
- 📝 If the Buddha praised Samatha, why is it losing importance?
- 📝 Why Buddha didn't want him to be called 'friend' by the monks?
- 📝 Iconography in Buddhism - from the Greeks? And why isn't the Buddha bald?
- 📝 What does the Buddha mean by this quote? "There is no punishment for anger. It is the anger which will punish you."
- 📝 Why would the Buddha refrain from instructing?
- 📝 Does Mahayana Buddhism discourage attaining enlightenment under the Gautama Buddha Sasana?
- 📝 Anesthesia, being knocked out, unconsciousness...what does the Buddha have to say about it?
- 📝 There is a text where Buddha says that the Dharma he teaches is not a secret doctrine so why are there sects which maintain secrecy?