Was there a plan from the USSR to invade Germany before Barbarossa?
score:3
There were many intelligence reports indicating that the Germans will invade Soviet Union in summer 1941. However the information was ambiguous, and Soviet government did not believe these reports. Neither they knew the date of the invasion with certainty. Nowadays, after the events, we can tell that some of these reports were exact. But there was no way to tell correct reports from incorrect ones before the invasion happened.
The plans of invasion of Germany in 1941 existed. There is a wide discussion of these plans in the Russian literature. However many documents of that time are still not available, they are still classified, so this discussion is not conclusive.
There are historians who argue that an invasion was planned on July 1941 (Victor Suvorov, Mark Solonin and others), and other historians who object this, and claim that no invasion was planned on summer 1941. There is no unambiguous evidence. There is no document ordering an invasion on a specified date.
But there seems to be a consensus that EVENTUALLY (perhaps in 1942) Stalin planned to join the war. In fact he and other Soviet government officials are on record saying this openly. None of them stated the date, of course.
EDIT. This discussion started with publication of Suvorov's book Icebreaker in 1987. Suvorov was a Soviet spy who defected to the West and was sentenced to death in absentia. He could use only openly published evidence in his book. His main argument was based on the configuration of Soviet troops in early summer 1941, which can be interpreted in two ways: a) planned invasion, or b) extreme stupidity. Since then, a lot of such secondary evidence has been collected, and some documents were published supporting his point of view, however there is no document which states a date of a planned invasion.
EDIT 2. Suvorov and Solonin are not professional historians. (Suvorov has military education, Solonin is an airspace engineer). Of Russian professional historians who generally share their point of view I can name Mikhail Meltyukhov. When we say "professional historian" we mean someone who has an academic degree in history. However it is difficult in Russia to obtain a degree if you agree with Suvorov in anything.
Speaking on Western historians, they prefer just not to discuss the subject. (At least I have never seen any serious discussion of this question by a non-Russian professional historian). And this also has a simple explanation. If your views strongly contradict the Russian official view on the subject which is considered "sacred" in Russia, you will be denied travel to Russia, access to archives etc. This would certainly be a very serious handicap for your career as a professional historian. So Western academic historians prefer to ignore the subject.
Myself, I am not claiming that Suvorov, Solonin and Meltyukhov are right. I am not a professional historian. And I would like very much some impartial Western historian write a book on the subject.
For comparison: how many Western (non Polish) historians dared to analyse the story of Katyn massacres, before the Russian government officially recognized it? How many Western historians dared to write about Gulag before this kind of literature was permitted in Soviet union? How much did Western media write about Holocaust when it was happening?
Upvote:4
Regarding knowledge of the German invasion:
There was intelligence that an invasion would happen. There was also intelligence that an invasion would not happen. A heavily politicized intelligence apparatus failed to draw the right conclusions and to present them to the political leadership (i.e. Stalin).
Hindsight like the 2006 files makes it easy to highlight all the correct clues, and to dismiss those which pointed to an earlier date (when an invasion failed to materialize) or to no invasion.
Regarding intentions:
Militaries have all sorts of war plans on file. Guess in which year the US considered war against the UK before you click this link.
So the relevant question becomes did Stalin have concrete intentions to invade in the early 1940s? The answer to that is probably not as the geopolitcs stood in 1941, but the Soviet Union was laying the groundwork to exploit opportunities in the future, e.g. by organizing German exiles.
More post
- 📝 When in history did people start seeing a girl's breasts as being inherently sexual?
- 📝 Has there ever been a non-rectangular banknote?
- 📝 When did medieval monarchs start being depicted with ermine fur garments?
- 📝 Did either Chinese government (Beijing or Taipei) operate an administrative structure in the Kowloon Walled City at any time between 1898 and 1994?
- 📝 Did WW1 produce a "Baby Boom" like demographic effect in USA or elsewhere?
- 📝 What did typical mid-18th century housing look like in English villages?
- 📝 Did Mao want to convert written Chinese into a phonetic system?
- 📝 Where did Vasco Núñez de Balboa first see the South Ocean?
- 📝 What do subjects in Hellenistic and Renaissance art suggest about the average human physique throughout history?
- 📝 Has a criminal organisation ever become a formal government?
- 📝 Who really fired on Ft. Sumter - the South or Local Charleston, SC militia?
- 📝 In England in 1700, would defending property with lethal force be illegal at all?
- 📝 Why did civilisation/city states never take root in Australia and North America?
- 📝 What did Kennedy know about Soviet missiles during the Cuban missile crisis?
- 📝 What's the history of bus hijacking & burning during the Troubles?
- 📝 Why didn't the Greeks or Romans have an Industrial Revolution?
- 📝 Specialist for dates?
- 📝 How did public debt financing through annuities work in the States General of the Netherlands?
- 📝 Did the French Resistance kill civilians?
- 📝 Did Vladimir Lenin have a cat?
- 📝 Anti-Semitism and Edmund Burke
- 📝 Did Stalin give special treatment for his home country?
- 📝 How did Austrian paramilitary organisations amass weapons during the interwar period?
- 📝 What kind of slang terms were used in Massachusetts in 1947?
- 📝 What was the reason the Maronites lobbied for a state of Greater Lebanon?
- 📝 Has scurvy occurred on land outside the Russian Far East?
- 📝 How did commoner children address commoner adults in the middle ages?
- 📝 Pennsylvania is not a state, it is a Commonwealth. Why?
- 📝 Did the British somehow imitate the Greek colonizers in India?
- 📝 What options were available to MacArthur to prepare for Chinese intervention in the Korean War?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Was there a plan from the USSR to invade Germany before Barbarossa?
- 📝 Was there a pre-determined arrangement for the division of Germany in case it surrendered before any Soviet forces entered its territory?
- 📝 From 1936-45 what was the prescribed punishment in Nazi Germany for failing to join or participate in the Hitler Youth?
- 📝 Before entering WW II, why was the US so against Japanese aggression in China but did nothing about Germany in Europe?
- 📝 Is it true that slavery was banned from discussion on the Senate and/or House floor before the American Civil War?
- 📝 Are there any ideas as to what the English landscape was like before the arrival of the Angles?
- 📝 Was there a Spanish plan to retake Malta, had the siege of 1565 been succesful?
- 📝 Why did antique guns and swords from the Franco-Prussian War make part of the demilitarization program to which Germany was subjected?
- 📝 Was there a time when a Senator was wheeled in from the hospital to cast a deciding vote not to do something?
- 📝 Is there any evidence that the book of Isaiah was written before Cyrus?
- 📝 What proportion of the Arab population of Palestine pre-1948 came from families that lived there before 1880?
- 📝 Was there a plan "B" for the D-Day?
- 📝 Was there relative peace in the Middle East before the end of the Great War?
- 📝 Why was there a sharp decline in the number of municipalities in West Germany in the 1970s?
- 📝 Was there any official affirmation from the US government that they would win the Vietnam War?
- 📝 Did Turkey invade Cyprus to keep the USSR out? Is there really CIA files that prove this for real?
- 📝 Was there a stated reason for the evacuation of Israeli settlers from the Gaza strip?
- 📝 Was there a continuity in architecture from the Minoan civilisation to classical Greece?
- 📝 Is there a painting from before the colonization of the Americas depicting travelers from far away visiting European nobles?
- 📝 What was the image of Jhwh before it was almost erased from history?
- 📝 Why was Poland spared from the Black Death?
- 📝 Why didn't France and the UK invade Germany in September 1939?
- 📝 Is there any evidence to support the claim that the United States was "suckered into WW1" by Zionists, made by Benjamin Freedman in his 1961 speech?
- 📝 Was there ever a treaty between 2 entities with significantly different translations to the detriment of one party?
- 📝 Was there a contingency plan in place if Little Boy failed to detonate?
- 📝 What led some people to (correctly) believe that there was no land under the ice cap at the North Pole?
- 📝 What was the religion of the Arabic people before conversion to Islam?
- 📝 Is there any documented criticism of the brutality of the Colosseum from citizens at the time?
- 📝 Was there a plan to use nuclear weapons for terrain modification in North America?
- 📝 What was the reason for Soviet troops to withdraw from Yugoslavia in World War II?