Is there any documented criticism of the brutality of the Colosseum from citizens at the time?
score:34
The most notable non-Christian Roman critic of gladiatorial games was likely the Stoic philosopher Seneca. Of course Christians like Tertullian had good reason to speak out against bloody spectacles in general, and some of the conquered peoples living under Rome took less joy in the games than did the Romans. But for the most part, even enlightened Romans whom we might expect to criticize the games kept quiet, including Stoics like Epictetus and the Emperor Marcus Aurelius. Tacitus mildly disapproved of the games, writing:
"There are the peculiar and characteristic vices of this metropolis of ours, taken on, it seems to me, almost in the mother's womb--the passion for play actors and the mania for gladiatorial shows and horse-racing."
But this is a pretty mild condemnation--he doesn't single out gladiatorial fighting as any worse than plays or horse races.
I see Seneca's name most often associated with criticisms of gladiatorial fights, but he comes off like a lone voice in the wilderness. He thought the games desensitized viewers, and because of them:
Man, an object of reverence in the eyes of men, is now slaughtered for jest and sport ... and it is a satisfying spectacle to see a man made a corpse.
As mentioned, early Christians were obviously critical of entertainments that not only had pagan religious origins but which sometimes featured the grisly deaths of fellow Christians. But interestingly, critics like Tertullian didn't object solely to the human slaughter, but to the spirit of all spectacles. Using some Yoda-esque logic, he writes:
There is no public spectacle without violence to the spirit. For where there is pleasure, there is eagerness, which gives pleasure its flavor. Where there is eagerness, there is rivalry, which gives its flavor to eagerness. Yes, and then, where there is rivalry, there also are madness, bile, anger, pain, and all the things that follow from them and (like them) are incompatible with moral discipline.
In other words, gladiatorial fights epitomized what was corrupt about all circuses, games, plays, shows, and so on. Later Christian writers may have exaggerated the extent of anti-Christian brutality, but there is at least one passion text that purports to be an eyewitness account of Christians being exposed to gladiators and wild beasts in the early 200s.
Finally, gladiatorial shows were less popular outside of Italy, Roman colonies, and Roman military encampments. In some provinces, there was even overt criticism of the games:
When King Herod wished to offer spectacles in an amphitheater he had constructed near Jerusalem, "the Jews found such a cruel pleasure to be impious and an abandonment of their ancestral customs."
Source: Sisella Bok on "The Paradox of Entertainment Violence"
Upvote:-2
Don't know the source of the quote but found it used in this video @3:24:46 content: https://youtu.be/o2zcieLqkHQ
Upvote:4
I don't have the book in my hand, so I can't quote directly, but Will Durant's "Caesar and Christ" a history of the Roman Empire, mentions at one point that Christian ministers in general opposed gladiatorial battles (but had difficulty stopping their congregations from attending because of the general popularity). As for his source, I don't know.
Ignatius of Antioch's epistle to the Romans comes about as close to the spectacle as anyone could - in it he intimated that he himself was condemned to be fed to wild beasts:
I write to the Churches, and impress on them all, that I shall willingly die for God, unless ye hinder me. I beseech of you not to show an unseasonable good-will towards me. Suffer me to become food for the wild beasts, through whose instrumentality it will be granted me to attain to God. I am the wheat of God, and let me be ground by the teeth of the wild beasts, that I may be found the pure bread of Christ. Rather entice the wild beasts, that they may become my tomb, and may leave nothing of my body; so that when I have fallen asleep, I may be no trouble to any one. Then shall I truly be a disciple of Christ, when the world shall not see so much as my body. Entreat Christ for me, that by these instruments I may be found a sacrifice. I do not, as Peter and Paul, issue commandments unto you. They were apostles; I am but a condemned man: they were free, while I am, even until now, a servant. But when I suffer, I shall be the freed-man of Jesus, and shall rise again emancipated in Him. And now, being a prisoner, I learn not to desire anything worldly or vain.
When he wrote this, Ignatius was on his way to Rome for execution. That he went to the Colosseum is not an unreasonable assumption. Ironically, even his quote doesn't seem to condemn the spectacle does it?!
Upvote:6
Augustine's Confessions criticizes gladiatorial shows several places in Book 6. One example is below (emphasis added):
For being utterly averse to and detesting spectacles, he was one day by chance met by divers of his acquaintance and fellow-students coming from dinner, and they with a familiar violence haled him, vehemently refusing and resisting, into the Amphitheatre, during these cruel and deadly shows, he thus protesting: "Though you hale my body to that place, and there set me, can you force me also to turn my mind or my eyes to those shows? I shall then be absent while present, and so shall overcome both you and them."
(From http://www.gutenberg.org/files/3296/3296-h/3296-h.htm#link2H_4_0006)
Upvote:9
Seneca's letter to a friend:
There is nothing so ruinous to good character as to idle away one's time at some spectacle. Vices have a way of creeping in because of the feeling of pleasure that it brings. Why do you think that I say that I personally return from shows greedier, more ambitious and more given to luxury, and I might add, with thoughts of greater cruelty and less humanity, simply because I have been among humans?
The other day, I chanced to drop in at the midday games, expecting sport and wit and some relaxation to rest men's eyes from the sight of human blood. Just the opposite was the case. Any fighting before that was as nothing; all trifles were now put aside - it was plain butchery.
The men had nothing with which to protect themselves, for their whole bodies were open to the thrust, and every thrust told. The common people prefer this to matches on level terms or request performances. Of course they do. The blade is not parried by helmet or shield, and what use is skill or defense? All these merely postpone death.
In the morning men are thrown to bears or lions, at midday to those who were previously watching them. The crowd cries for the killers to be paired with those who will kill them, and reserves the victor for yet another death. This is the only release the gladiators have. The whole business needs fire and steel to urge men on to fight. There was no escape for them. The slayer was kept fighting until he could be slain.
'Kill him! Flog him! Burn him alive!' (the spectators roared) 'Why is he such a coward? Why won't he rush on the steel? Why does he fall so meekly? Why won't he die willingly? "
Unhappy as I am, how have I deserved that I must look on such a scene as this? Do not, my Lucilius, attend the games, I pray you. Either you will be corrupted by the multitude, or, if you show disgust, be hated by them. So stay away.
Upvote:9
Small point. Though the spectacles were bloody, as Seneca notes, they were rationalized on the assumption that those who were killed had been condemned for a crime, thus, it was a sort of capital punishment, and tolerated, by those who did not enjoy it, on that basis. From the Roman point of view, no "innocent" victims were being murdered, but rather, condemned criminals were being executed. Given Seneca's report, it seems that the crowd did not make this distinction, and did not particularly care, being motivated by blood lust, but in legal terms, it did have a shadow of justification.
More post
- 📝 Did JFK really say "Hitler is one of the greatest men…one of the most significant figures that ever lived"?
- 📝 Did imperialist Japan ever want to annex Hawaii because of the Japanese minority living here?
- 📝 Why were Soviet losses consistently so high?
- 📝 What happened to Japanese employees after Pearl Harbor?
- 📝 How did Churchill and Stalin intend to translate the percentages in the "Percentages agreement"?
- 📝 Is this anecdote about Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill true?
- 📝 What does it mean that the early supreme court "gave themselves" the power of judicial review?
- 📝 When did the acceptance of diversity become such an important social goal in Western countries?
- 📝 Weird weapons in medieval times
- 📝 What was the purpose of Nazi extermination camps?
- 📝 Was there a battle were Russians forces rallied around a religious icon to achieve victory?
- 📝 What happened to prisoners in IS occupied territory?
- 📝 What was the output of a Bessemer Converter?
- 📝 Have the officials/leaders of the winning country ever been punished for war crimes?
- 📝 How did Greeks view tall people, and was there a social premium placed on height?
- 📝 Why does Spain have enclaves in Morocco?
- 📝 America vs. Australia as a "Penal Colony"
- 📝 How did people die in Nazi extermination camps?
- 📝 The diminishing role of the "family name" throughout the Byzantine Empire
- 📝 Which country can be called the successor of the Roman Empire, after 476?
- 📝 Was there ever any co-existence solution to peace with Israel that the Arab Palestinian side proposed or said would accept?
- 📝 Has any music act ever topped the Beatles in sales?
- 📝 Did the Romans melt down looted golden objects or did they keep them intact?
- 📝 Has NATO ever started a war?
- 📝 Why is the city of Armenia in Colombia so named?
- 📝 Vigenere vs. Bellaso
- 📝 Difference between legions at the end of the Roman empire and around the beginning of the Roman Empire
- 📝 How tall was Brutus?
- 📝 Is it true that Newton ordered the hanging of counterfeiters?
- 📝 How did Yugoslavia economically survive the Cold War
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Is there any documented criticism of the brutality of the Colosseum from citizens at the time?
- 📝 Are there any documented examples of wooden ships which were in active service for 100 years or more? If not, what is the longest?
- 📝 Are there any existing foreign language teaching texts from the Ancient Near East?
- 📝 Are there any historians who believe that the crusades were not motivated as a distraction from internal conflicts?
- 📝 Are there any antisemitic caricatures from France during the interwar period?
- 📝 Apart from the White Ship in 1120, have there been any other maritime disasters in which an heir to a throne and/or many notable people died?
- 📝 Are there any surviving maps from the Delhi Sultanate?
- 📝 Are there any Midas portraits from the ancient era?
- 📝 Are there any documented cases from ancient or medieval times of someone escaping captivity by cross-dressing?
- 📝 Was there any official affirmation from the US government that they would win the Vietnam War?
- 📝 Are there any reliable documented records of members or operations of the French Resistance during World War 2?
- 📝 Are there any surviving military textbooks from the Napoleonic era?
- 📝 Apart from Veer Savarkar and S.A. Dange, were there any Indian revolutionaries who filed mercy petitions to the British?
- 📝 Is there any book depicting British rule in India from the eyes of British?
- 📝 Are there any books on the recruitment of scientists from the Third Reich (Operation "Paperclip" and others)?
- 📝 Are there any documented cases where a society was capable of large scale selflessness for the benefit of future generations?
- 📝 Is there any evidence to support the claim that the United States was "suckered into WW1" by Zionists, made by Benjamin Freedman in his 1961 speech?
- 📝 Identify the era or any other clues from this soldier's picture?
- 📝 Are there any accounts of everyday life during the Black Death?
- 📝 In the "Christmas truce" of 1914 were there any football (soccer) matches between British and German troops?
- 📝 Is there any evidence of armies enrolling women in fighting roles in significant number in antiquity or the middle ages?
- 📝 Were there any drunk driving laws before the automobile?
- 📝 Has there ever been a major migration from the New World to the Old World? If not, why?
- 📝 Has there been any "invasive plants warfare" in the past?
- 📝 Is there any evidence that Cleopatra and Caesarion considered fleeing to India to escape the Romans?
- 📝 Were there any travel restrictions during the Black Death pandemic?
- 📝 Were there any Germans in Japan after the surrender of Germany in May, 1945 and if so, what happened to them?
- 📝 Were there any high-ranking female soldiers during the Middle ages?
- 📝 Was there a tax in the fifties for British citizens traveling abroad?
- 📝 Has there ever been a true kidnapped princess from anywhere in the world?