What were the historical antecedents of Russia BTG-based military organization?
score:4
The Red Army dealt a lot with low-level and small-unit tactics during its long war in Afghanistan, as indicated in the preface to The Bear Went Over the Mountain[1]:
[...], the Soviets formulated new concepts for waging war in a non-linear fashion, suited to operating on battlefields dominated by more lethal high-precision weapons. This new non-linear battlefield required the abandonment of traditional operation and tactical formations, a redefinition of traditional echelonment concepts, and a wholesale reorganization of formations and units to emphasize combat flexibility and, hence, survivability.
Even the Frunze Academy said as much:
Combat experience disclosed that the principal types of combat included: company, battalion and regimental raids;...
Summarizing this source, the basic point is that the Soviets were constrained by supply, availability and terrain into small-unit operations. All arms had to be condensed to a smaller package with the command as far forward as possible, if one wanted to have any chance of success in a highly dynamic and constrained battlefield.
The question then is whether it was this experience that led to the latest BTG TO&E. It can't really be confirmed without direct input from the Russian side. However, Russian Army actions since Afghanistan haven't necessarily negated these learnings.
Reading the Ft Benning article that the OP linked, some conclusions may be erroneous. A BTG as described in Ukraine from 2013-2022 appears to me to be simply a deployment unit in a "military option other than war" theater. For Ukraine and Syria, this small-unit bonegruppa/BTG approach is probably sufficient, given the similarity to the Afghanistan experience: there's a lot of tail and a number of small sharp ends, because they do the specialist work and their size is appropriate to the task. Even the American experience in Iraq and Afghanistan suggests this reality: there were lots of troops that moved boxes, some troops that walked around outside the wire, and a few that did the high-maneuver rapid-response work. During my own deployment to Afghanistan, I saw first hand how a stateside unit's TO&E was not appropriate to the nature of the conflict, and thus the deployment was selective to the task at hand.
The author, CPT Fiore, seems to gloss over that Russian units tend to have more units per commander, a precedent from WW2 times[2]. In other words, they are like fingers on a hand - the more the better. In a big war scenario, which Fiore seems to allude to, I would argue that you would not be facing one BTG but many (so long as the Russians are able to do so). So the question is not how to handle the one BTG, but the ten that are being worked by one commander against you with a singular purpose.
In other words, examining a Russian BTG from Ukraine circa 2013-2021 or Syria may cause one to draw some misleading conclusions, or at least misunderstand the scope of the BTG. And finally, often things go awry in the field that are worth study - just because a BTG flubbed a mission doesn't mean it was the fault of the TO&E, and the whole Grau book is built on those instances.
[1] The Bear Went Over the Mountain. Lester Grau.
[2] History of the Second World War. B. H. Liddell Hart.
Upvote:-2
I figured out two of the closest examples of units similar to the BTGs in the pre-modern world:
Under Napoleon: Artillery mixed with division
While most of units operated independently during the Napoleonic era, some did mix units under the pressure of the circumstances or in the prevision of a battle on a large front that would lead to difficulties in communication.
Those "augmented divisions" could be compared to BTG to the point that there were not permanently mixed, and that their autonomy was limited in time.
A comparison that could be made therefore is that when Napoleon created the "Grand Battery", he triggered a concentration of fire that could counter-strike enemy units. This could be compared to the use of long-range artillery against adverse, tactical formations.
American Civil War: Artillery mixed with cavalry
During the Civil War, Nordist units of cavalry were accompanied with artillery batteries that help them to hold strong points against enemy cavalry and more important, against enemy infantry. These units were autonomous in their maneuver and mix different weaponry, so they could be compared to BTGs.
Note that these units were often successful, and that their resistance against Lee's infantry initiate the battle of Gettysburg.
Upvote:0
Pre-Modern Examples
So I can't think of any modern battalion/regiment-sized forces of similar all-arms makeup, but since you also were interested in pre-20th century examples I've got a couple that come to mind.
Sonae, Sengoku Jidai "Warring States Period" Japan
The Sonae was the basic maneuver unit in Japanese warfare of this period and was normally between 300-800 men strong. It was a feudal unit where the commander called up his retinue, which called up their retinue, etc. However unlike Feudal armies of medieval europe, the called-up troops fought together as a single unit rather than be grouped with similarly-equipped troops. So a Sonae would contain pike (ashigaru, which were peasantry but could also be professional troops depending on the exact time), teppo (matchlock ashigaru), bowmen (ashigaru, ideally 1 for every 2 teppo), along with mounted and dismounted samurai. A breakdown I've seen No two Sonae were identical of course because of the feudal nature of their formation. But all the various tactics of the time assumed that an all-arms formation was the tactical maneuver unit a general was working with. I think this is the best example, as it contains all the arms the culture fought with and was 100% planned to be the standard tactical unit of the army amid a larger battle against peer opponents.
The British Legion American War of Independence
The British Legion consisted of approximately 250 cavalry and 200 infantry at its height, along with a few small field pieces. This was mostly an anti-partizan force that operated independently, but it participated as a unit in multiple pitched battles. There were other examples on the American side, (Lee's Legion comes to mind. It had 300ish men, 2:1 infantry:cavalry but I can't recall if they had organic artillery) but as this wasn't the "normal" formation for units in the war and therefor might not totally suit your question I didn't look too deeply at other potential examples in the AWI.
More post
- 📝 Did the US gov't pay the Cherokee for their lands in Georgia?
- 📝 Was it Bismarck who said: "He who is master of Bohemia is master of Europe"?
- 📝 Have there been any known cases of governments/military powers PRETENDING to be incompetent, as a sneaky form of security?
- 📝 Why did the Middle Kingdom stop building pyramid tombs?
- 📝 Why was the Håndfæstning forced on Erik V of Denmark?
- 📝 Where did the Romans store their cash?
- 📝 Did the Canadian Tuxedo emerge out of the Wool Shortage of 1973?
- 📝 Was Senegal involved in the 1918 Russian Revolution?
- 📝 Southern Manifesto main idea
- 📝 Dunkirk little ships collection
- 📝 What's this coin? IMP CAES M IVL PHILPPVS OVBOVS; Rev: IOMH COL HEL
- 📝 What was the difference between a WWII Engineer General Service Regiment and a Service Unit?
- 📝 Were Roman emperors in the first century AD shown as holding stars in their hands?
- 📝 If Nietzsche was against anti-semitism, how did he become an inspiration to Hitler?
- 📝 Did the Danes sack Hamburg after the conquest of Hedeby in 983?
- 📝 If SS Californian were within 5 miles of Titanic, could she have saved more passengers?
- 📝 Italian & Italian-American Internment camp locations in the United States in WWII
- 📝 How many defensive lines did China build for the Second Sino-Japanese War?
- 📝 What was the highest ever win for a decision in a nationwide *democratic* voting?
- 📝 Where is Havillah, the land of gold, described in Genesis?
- 📝 A German immigrant ancestor has a "Registration Affidavit of Alien Enemy" on file. What does that mean exactly?
- 📝 What happened at the Battle (or not?) of Luding Bridge, during the Long March of Chinese Communists in 1935?
- 📝 Why is it said that the Qin dynasty was the first to unite China?
- 📝 Marbury vs Madison, what about other midnight judges?
- 📝 How did one look for missing people in the 19th century?
- 📝 What did squires do in the middle of a medieval battle?
- 📝 How many people were in an average Iron Age Celtic settlement?
- 📝 What was the lowest available population to the Soviet Union in WW2?
- 📝 Why did Sheikh Mujibur Rahman refuse to negotiate on Six Points [after] the 1970 election?
- 📝 Why didn't Britain's nuclear weapons deter Argentina from invading the Falklands?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What were the historical antecedents of Russia BTG-based military organization?
- 📝 What were the political and military constraints on Vercingetorix at Alesia?
- 📝 What transit restrictions were in place in Occupied Germany limiting military and civilian movement between the four occupation zones?
- 📝 What is the historical evidence for asserting Huns were one and the same as Xiongnu?
- 📝 What were the military justifications for the bombing of Dresden?
- 📝 What were the limitations on possession of wealth in Soviet Russia and how were they enforced?
- 📝 What were the 20th century historical disputes?
- 📝 Based on historical experience what would happen if/when the USA/EU fell?
- 📝 What were Russia and the US were planning to do if Ukraine refused to give up their nuclear arsenal?
- 📝 What drugs were used in England during the High Middle Ages?
- 📝 What were the reasons for the Renaissance / scientific revolution in Europe?
- 📝 What was the historical context of the 2nd amendment to the US Constitution?
- 📝 What were the acceptance criteria in universities of medieval Europe?
- 📝 What is the historical basis for the Exodus?
- 📝 What language(s) were spoken within the Holy Roman Empire?
- 📝 What were the reasons for making Prohibition a constitutional amendment?
- 📝 What were the main causes of successful take over of India by Britain?
- 📝 What disruptions were brought about by Islam that the Arabians saw so many victories?
- 📝 Were there any Germans in Japan after the surrender of Germany in May, 1945 and if so, what happened to them?
- 📝 Are there any documented examples of wooden ships which were in active service for 100 years or more? If not, what is the longest?
- 📝 What were the logistics of whaling in the 1800s?
- 📝 What were the reasons that the British colonies in North America rebelled but not others?
- 📝 In WWII, what were the major differences in tank combat on the eastern and western fronts?
- 📝 What is the earliest known account of the modern military salute?
- 📝 What is the historical basis for the claim that "Taiwan has always been part of China"?
- 📝 Third Reich? What were the other two?
- 📝 What is this military patch with the silhouette of a pegasus on it?
- 📝 What were the Allies' plans if they caught Hitler alive?
- 📝 What were the EMP effects, if any, of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
- 📝 What made the Russian Navy suspect Japanese torpedo boats were in North Sea in 1904?