What were the political and military constraints on Vercingetorix at Alesia?
Upvote:8
Although I read War of the Gauls a long time ago, my answer is based on a fairly recent listen to Dan Carlin's Celtic Holocaust podcast.
Now, Carlin's not a real historian, but comes a damn sight closer than most of us and in any case is just going to be doing the same thing as everyone else: looking at Caesar's book. Which, for all its lack of corroboration and self-serving propaganda, is a damn sight more documentation than a lot of ancient history gets.
Leading up to Alesia, the basic facts (and claims) are as follows:
by the time of V's revolt, Caesar had been campaigning in Gaul for a while and had largely subjugated the individual tribes.
Gaul was not a unified country, and Caesar had not been fighting a king or kingdom. Rather, he had been taking out tribes one by one or in small groups.
V is chosen/elected as a unified war leader, but still answers to tribal politics. His central authority is unprecedented, for the Gauls.
V explicitly recognizes the superiority Romans enjoy in set piece battles and wants to target their logistics. Essentially, he wants to fight a large scale guerrilla war, using scorched earth tactics. But he doesn't have say Stalin's authority to just burn things. He does it, but it's not popular. Neither, probably, is "cowardice" to the Gauls.
Alesia (according to Carlin):
Is supposed to be extremely well-fortified and is supposed to have political/cultural significance. A "town worth fighting for". V finds it difficult to convince his confederacy to just burn and leave.
Roman superiority in set battles and in sieges was well known, but the Gauls might have not fully appreciated how capable they were. Think Masada or the crossing of the Rhine - double-walling Alesia looks extraordinary to us already, let alone folk without our hindsight or other Roman examples to look at. They may have thought they could hold out.
The numbers on the Gaulish side are immense, maybe even too large to be credible. But keeping large armies in the field has always been a weakness tribal systems have when fighting established imperial powers. It could be that the Gauls felt they had sufficiently hurt Caesar and needed to force an outcome.
As V. was not a king but rather an elected/chosen war leader, he might have limited leeway to cut and run and fight another day. By running away, either before he got pinned, or later on, he might have lost his claim to leadership. That would really depend on the power and influence of the tribe that owned Alesia.
Evacuating the civilians is also easier said than done. I am pretty sure the standard Roman response to insurrection tended to enslaving everyone. So it might have at first seemed safer to keep them in the city and wait for the relief force to fix the whole problem, rather than turning them out (from their own city) sufficiently long before the Romans arrived. V does try to send them out later, and the Romans send them back, precisely to hasten starvation.
In short, given the Gaulish numbers, his political position and the relative success they had had until then, V might just have miscalculated and bitten off more than he could handle. On the other hand, we know what happened and we know that sitting in Alesia was a death sentence, even if we don't know all that much about the bigger picture and possible alternatives. So it's natural for us to assume a clever leader would not have made this mistake.
More post
- 📝 Does city-specific economic data for the pre-WW2 decades exist for Japan and Germany? How do I find out?
- 📝 What is the earliest depiction of a crane?
- 📝 Were there any attempts to assassinate Joseph Stalin?
- 📝 Identify the country, service and historical context of this bright red dress uniform, and ideally the nature of the medals. Relationship to Taiwan?
- 📝 A Roman Admiral, a Tribune, a Legatus and a Promagistrate all walk into an arena
- 📝 When were the different stories of Hindu gods written?
- 📝 Did senior US officials advocate a 'a final solution' for the 'red race' circa 1905?
- 📝 Can anyone explain why a wreck of a battleship lies in the Nevada desert?
- 📝 What exactly do eyewitness testimonies say about Hitler's behavior during the Munich Putsch?
- 📝 How was Mao Anying killed?
- 📝 Historical tax revenue as a proportion of GDP
- 📝 Why did the Allied Forces choose Normandy as their geographic point of invasion?
- 📝 What would have been the typical drinks for a US farmer in the late 18th/early 19th century?
- 📝 Who was this Roman General/figure of authority who, on his deathbed, named these two regrets?
- 📝 What differentiates a priest, a clerk, a capellanus, a subdeacon and a rector?
- 📝 What was the official currency used in North Carolina in 1814?
- 📝 Why are Arabian Nights set mostly in Persia?
- 📝 Sources on common people history
- 📝 Were there any attempts at a federation or commonwealth to save Austria-Hungary from breaking up after ww1?
- 📝 Why did the assasination of Franz Ferdinand trigger WW1?
- 📝 Is history always written by the victors?
- 📝 Has Sun Tzu ever advocated for something that in modern society is a war crime, or what has Sun Tzu ever said about war crimes?
- 📝 Did Palaeolithic humans live longer than early Neolithic farmers?
- 📝 Why didn't Romans conquer/explore the African Atlantic Coast?
- 📝 What were the insignia of the Western Roman Empire and what happened to them?
- 📝 What kind of US Army uniform is this?
- 📝 From how far away could an experienced and skilled archer hit a man?
- 📝 What specifically did Caesar believe he would be charged with had he disbanded his army?
- 📝 When was it first noticed that airplane passengers really seemed to like tomato juice?
- 📝 Did US soldiers typically keep an official journal or log during the Civil War era?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What were the political and military constraints on Vercingetorix at Alesia?
- 📝 What transit restrictions were in place in Occupied Germany limiting military and civilian movement between the four occupation zones?
- 📝 Were there any Germans in Japan after the surrender of Germany in May, 1945 and if so, what happened to them?
- 📝 In WWII, what were the major differences in tank combat on the eastern and western fronts?
- 📝 What is the evidence to claim that political order in ancient Rome was sufficiently different under "kingdom", "republic" and "empire"?
- 📝 What were the EMP effects, if any, of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
- 📝 What East German laws and regulations were extended to the West after unification?
- 📝 What were the demographics and economics of South-East Asian islands around year 1400?
- 📝 What were the Nazi racial views on Hungarians and the Japanese?
- 📝 At what point were the most current and former US Presidents alive?
- 📝 What were the thoughts of the Celts, Romans and other ancient European people about the standing stones which survive from prehistoric times?
- 📝 What were the original casualty projections for Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
- 📝 What are the historical reasons for religious and political negative attitudes towards h*m*sexuality?
- 📝 What were the operating principles of Japan's MITI during the 1950s and 60s?
- 📝 Were there any political checks on the U.S. executive during their covert support of the military junta of Pinochet?
- 📝 What were the Government Press Prosecutions of 1858 and why did they occur?
- 📝 What were the insignia of the Western Roman Empire and what happened to them?
- 📝 What were the key differences between United States' and Indian revolutions?
- 📝 What were contemporary Japanese views on the Taiping Rebellion and Heavenly Kingdom?
- 📝 What benefits were there to the USA of developing both Uranium and Plutonium bombs in World War 2?
- 📝 What is the historical evidence for asserting Huns were one and the same as Xiongnu?
- 📝 Why did the Nazis guillotine criminals but mostly hang political enemies, and why were the White Rose group an exception?
- 📝 What were the military justifications for the bombing of Dresden?
- 📝 What were the advantages and disadvantages of Mongolian cavalry (compared to European cavalry)?
- 📝 What universities existed in Dutch East Indies, and how available were they to the native population?
- 📝 What were the rights and responsibilities of (various classes of) 11th century English commonfolk?
- 📝 Were there bows employed by tribes living in the desert, and if so, what were they made of?
- 📝 What specific changes were made to political ideologies around during and before World War I?
- 📝 What were the traveling practices of merchants, roughly between the Middle Ages and the Renaissance?
- 📝 What trains were used on the Dakar-Niger Railway in the late 1950s and early 1960s?