What were the 20th century historical disputes?
score:23
In academic circles the late 20th century saw the culmination of the practice where no academic ever criticised the blunderings of any other academic.
Well, that shows Berkley to be an ignoramus with an axe to grind. Let's list some genuine 20th-century historical controversies. These are from WWII and related history, because that's what I know the most about.
- The Functionalism-Intentionalism debate over the origins of the Holocaust and the political structure of Nazi Germany.
- The debate over Hitler's war aims: was he intending to conquer Europe, Eurasia, Eurasia and Africa, or the whole world?
- The Historians' dispute among different political views within historians in West Germany in the late 1980s.
- The New Historians in Israel, who challenge the traditional narrative of the founding of modern Israel.
There are many, many more. Disputing other people's historical theories is one of the primary ways that historians improve their understanding of history.
(This is used in support of Berkley's controversial thesis, that the ancient Egyptians spoke Welsh.)
That's not controversial. It's nonsense. The only way he could support that claim would be if everyone who has learned Ancient Egyptian were part of a conspiracy to conceal its being a Celtic language, part of the Indo-European family. Since Egyptian is an Afro-Asiatic language, that makes his idea less linguistically plausible than the Black Egyptian hypothesis, which is quite a feat.
Since the titles of Grant Berkley's other books are The Discovery of the Ark of the Covenant and The King Arthur Conspiracy, you can safely write him off as a conspiracy theorist and a pseudo-historian.
Upvote:0
After some renewed googling I managed to find articles relating to the TΔrtΔria tablets, which seem to fit the bill quite well, but I'd still be interested to learn about other cases.
Upvote:0
Some historical disputes even became books, as in Scientists Confront Velikovsky.
Many more propaganda masquerading as history was and is heavily criticized. Such "history textbooks" were and are fairly common in autocratic countries, and, of course, heavily criticized.
Upvote:3
There are even disputes in the 21st century, e.g. around Christopher Clark's Sleepwalkers or about whether there actually ever was a Cathar heresy.
More post
- π How did US anti-Irish sentiment decline?
- π What is this ancient Egyptian material called "maklalu"?
- π Why hasn't Russia maintained significant numbers of aircraft carriers?
- π How to identify this coin with a bust on one side and the letters S and C on the other side?
- π How did an input of resources in 16th century Spain contribute to inflation?
- π How would residents of Central Slovakia travel to seaports in 1880's?
- π Maximum speed of communication prior to Trans-Atlantic Cable?
- π Border between the Western and Eastern Roman Empires
- π How efficiently did the Red Army conduct itself during the invasion of Poland in 1939?
- π At the end of WWII, were Nazis working on any other super weapon besides V-2?
- π Did medieval Mongol horse archers have deformed arms like English bowmen?
- π Did anything come from Sparta, besides fitness and war?
- π How did horses become animals of fancy while donkeys largely didn't?
- π Did they use nicknames in ancient Rome?
- π Who should be the king/queen of England?
- π Did the Spartans really taunt Philip II of Macedon with a single word?
- π Why were there no increases in the train speed records between 1854-1934?
- π How were the ladies of the Mughal harem titled and styled?
- π How long did it take to repair wooden war ships after battle in the 1600's to 1800's?
- π How did Muhammad bin Qasim die?
- π Vietnam war "blue tag"
- π Was it widespread practice to grant freedom to slaves in early Roman Empire?
- π Where did Asian Americans go to school during the 'separate but equal' era?
- π Who were the earliest Californian university students?
- π Can anyone help me identify this coin? Basiliea Selvykou. Rev: ICA
- π What evidence is there that Lenin died because he was poisoned?
- π Where was the cultural inheritance of the Greco/Roman world/antiquity preserved?
- π Did quantum theory originate as pure research?
- π When did the Arabic numerals appear on clock faces?
- π Which astronomical events have been the most important in dating historical events?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π What were the 20th century historical disputes?
- π What were the factors that caused the world to move away from the Gold Standard in the 20th century?
- π What kinds of goods were commonly smuggled in the Roman Empire up to the end of the 3rd century AD?
- π What exactly were the dealings of Ea-Nasir ("The Worst Businessman Of The 18th Century BC")?
- π What is the historical evidence for asserting Huns were one and the same as Xiongnu?
- π What were the rights and responsibilities of (various classes of) 11th century English commonfolk?
- π What were the typical arguments against women's higher education in XIX century Germany?
- π What did Central America export in the early 20th century other than coffee and bananas?
- π What were the factors that caused debtors' prison to disappear in most parts of the world in the 20th century?
- π What were the relative contributions of oral & literary education in 5th century BCE Athens?
- π What did "Dr." after a person's or a business's name mean around the turn of the 20th century in the USA?
- π How were precise hand drawn illustrations copied between the 16th and 20th century in Europe?
- π Were life imprisonment and mental insanity the only reasons a divorce couldn't be granted in early 20th century England?
- π What Were the Primary Causes of 15th to 19th Century British Chartered Companies' Failures?
- π What were the historical antecedents of Russia BTG-based military organization?
- π What drugs were used in England during the High Middle Ages?
- π What were the reasons for the Renaissance / scientific revolution in Europe?
- π What was the historical context of the 2nd amendment to the US Constitution?
- π What were the acceptance criteria in universities of medieval Europe?
- π What is the historical basis for the Exodus?
- π What language(s) were spoken within the Holy Roman Empire?
- π What were the reasons for making Prohibition a constitutional amendment?
- π What were the main causes of successful take over of India by Britain?
- π What disruptions were brought about by Islam that the Arabians saw so many victories?
- π Why were nomadic tribes (like the Mongols) from the Eurasian steppes a much reduced threat from the 15th century onwards?
- π Were there any Germans in Japan after the surrender of Germany in May, 1945 and if so, what happened to them?
- π Are there any documented examples of wooden ships which were in active service for 100 years or more? If not, what is the longest?
- π What were the logistics of whaling in the 1800s?
- π What were the reasons that the British colonies in North America rebelled but not others?
- π In WWII, what were the major differences in tank combat on the eastern and western fronts?