Is it possible for a human being to live without the mind?
score:5
To answer this question accurately is very difficult if you are not a scientist but often people have accidents that results in them being in a coma for an extended period, where their physical body is alive but their mind is not conscious. If the mind is not conscious at all here then that physical body is living without mind (however from a Buddhist perspective, this is probably not a "human" living since, in Buddhism, the word translated as "human" means to have a reflective & wise mind).
Also, there is a meditation state where the mind becomes unconscious, called 'the cessation of perception & feeling'. This meditative state is compared to a dead body, where even breathing cannot be felt yet the 'life force' or 'vitality' of the body & heat remain.
For example, in the Buddhist scriptures, there are stories about monks that enter into the meditation state of 'the cessation of perception & feeling' & people watch them meditating (not moving) under a tree for many days, believe they are dead & try to bury or cremate them.
Therefore, it appears it is possible to that a 'human' can live without mind.
What is the difference between one who is dead, who has completed his time; and a monk who has attained the cessation of perception & feeling?
In the case of the one who is dead, who has completed his time, his bodily fabricator (breathing)...his verbal fabricator (thinking) ... his mental fabricator (perception & feeling) have ceased & subsided, his vitality is exhausted, his heat subsided & his (five sense) faculties (eye, ears, nose, tongue & body nervous system) are scattered.
But in the case of a monk who has attained the cessation of perception & feeling, his bodily fabricator... his verbal fabricator ... his mental fabricators have ceased & subsided, his vitality is not exhausted, his heat has not subsided & his (five sense) faculties are exceptionally clear (pure).
This is the difference between one who is dead, who has completed his time, and a monk who has attained the cessation of perception & feeling.
Upvote:0
Without the mind the human body dies, there are many case of people in comas, but in cases where there is absolutely no brain activity these people are kept 'alive' using life support.
So I would argue that you can't live without the mind.
Upvote:0
Mind is Vinnana and is one of the very basic six elements (Dhatu) that constitute you and me. What would it be if we take out this ‘Mind’ element?
Viññāna as dhatu or elements, are divided into 7 classes: cakkhu-vinnana-dhatu = cakkhu-vinnanadvi. They depend on cakkhu-vatthu for their arising. (eyes) sota-vinnana-dhatu = sota-vinnanadvi. They depend on sota-vatthu for their arising. (ears) ghana-vinnana-dhatu = ghana-vinnanadvi. They depend on ghana-vatthu for their arising. (nose) jivha-vinnana-dhatu = jivha-vinnanadvi. They depend on jivha-vatthu for their arising. (tongue) kaya-vinnana-dhatu = kaya-vinnanadvi. They depend on kaya-vatthu for their arising. (body) mano-dhatu = panca-dvaravajjana and sampaticchanadvi. They depend on hadaya-vatthu for their arising. (mind)
Mind is Vinnana and is one of the four type of food that is required for our survival. What would it be if we take out this ‘survival’ factor – the Nutriment of Consciousness (Vinnana Ahara)?
There are six classes of consciousness. When eye and forms are both present, eye consciousness arises dependent on them. Similarly when ear and sounds are present, ear consciousness arises dependent on them; nose and smells are present, nose consciousness arises dependent on them; tongue and tastes are present, tongue consciousness arises dependent on them; body and tactile objects are present, body consciousness arises dependent on them; mind and mental objects are present, mind consciousness arises dependent on them. This is a cause which results in the our existence.
Upvote:0
When I was about 17 years old, my grandmother told me she would sometimes suddenly come out of her body.
I was thinking that in all the time I had lived with my grandmother as a child, I never seen her fall unconscious or anything. She told me that was because her body would never loose consciousness when she went out of it.
She would feel "herself" or her "mind" hovering above her body but the body was still walking and talking.
Apparently, a lot of the time when my grandmother was lucid and holding intellegent conversations with me and everyone else, she wasn't even in her body!
I don't claim to know if this means there actually was no mind in her body but I thought it might be worth mentioning nonetheless.
More post
- 📝 How can the sensations of the meditation object (attention to the breath) be made more noticeable?
- 📝 Timeframe of meditation's relaxing effect
- 📝 What does Diamond Way Buddhism say about obstacles at times of becoming more conscious?
- 📝 Was Steve Jobs a Buddhist?
- 📝 How does mindfulness practice (sati) lead to jhana?
- 📝 Mahāsamādhi in Buddhism?
- 📝 How to part with potentially harmful possessions
- 📝 Distinction between Dharmaguptaka and Mahayana
- 📝 How to practice Metta without a Benefactor?
- 📝 Metaphysical Contemplation and Speculation
- 📝 Mindful driving
- 📝 Phsyical, emotional, mental, what is next?
- 📝 The Various Theravada Traditions
- 📝 How to let go of the will to let go or reach a certain state?
- 📝 How can the details of the mappō age be discussed skillfully?
- 📝 What is the goal of Meditation- is it increasing the gap?
- 📝 Is vipassana outside a ten day retreat possible?
- 📝 Iconography in Buddhism - from the Greeks? And why isn't the Buddha bald?
- 📝 Is the 'best meditation you do' the meditation you do?
- 📝 What are the texts that contain words which can be attributed directly to the Buddha?
- 📝 How do animals attain enlightenment?
- 📝 When is an ideology a religion and not just philosophy, or a way of living?
- 📝 Wing Chun Buddhism Zen Stance - Standing Meditation
- 📝 What is (re)born? Did the Buddha explicitly state that it is "the mental idea of the self" that is reborn?
- 📝 What is this personality split I'm feeling since practicing Vipassana?
- 📝 In the doctrine of no arising does the past and future still exist?
- 📝 Which Pali suttas describe the Buddha & monks demonstrating psychic powers to laypeople?
- 📝 Understanding Mindfulness through outwardly qualities
- 📝 How should one look at buddhist mythologies and cosmologies from a scientific perspective
- 📝 The alayavijnana and emptiness
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Is it possible for a human being to live without the mind?
- 📝 The needs of the same human being may differ at different stages of life. Can there be one Dharma for all stages?
- 📝 Have all human beings got the capacity for compassion?
- 📝 Can a human being reside both in this world and Nirvana at the same time?
- 📝 Is it possible for active people to truly live practice "mindfulness"?
- 📝 Is it possible to set goals for the future and be present at the same time?
- 📝 If I am not the skandhas, then what entity/group of entities am I being responsible for by being a good person?
- 📝 Is mindfulness for quick enlightenment being exaggerated in the Sutta MN10?
- 📝 If no sentient being exists, for whom is there compassion? 'A Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life' by Santideva
- 📝 Is "the mind is without feature or surface, limitless, ..." in the Pali canon?
- 📝 Pali Canon: Did the Buddha ever offer teachings without being asked to?
- 📝 Is it possible for a Buddhist to develop spiritual bypassing? What are the main traps?
- 📝 If a kind and generous Christian died 20 years ago, might their rebirth have resulted in there being a 19 year old person in the human realm now?
- 📝 text for the 2013 course: Shamatha and the Bodhisattva Way of Life. Class 2 on Motivation and 7 Point Mind Training
- 📝 Possible for worldling to practice the Ariyamagga, to walk it?
- 📝 Is there a Pali name for a state of being in which one experiences “craving without a target”?
- 📝 Where did the Buddha say: "What a person considers and reflects upon for a long time, to that his mind will bend and incline."?
- 📝 Does suffering entail being overwhelmed for the person who is suffering?
- 📝 Is there a source for the story about the sun being covered by the cloud?
- 📝 Looking for a reference about the significance of The Buddha being a teacher
- 📝 How was it possible for some people to refute the Buddha face to face?
- 📝 Is it good for the mind to be excited?
- 📝 How to determine the end of a meditation session without a clock?
- 📝 Is Nirvana the goal for all Buddhist?
- 📝 Isnt the desire for giving up the desires, a desire?
- 📝 Can environmental degradation be used as a justification for the culling of an invasive alien species?
- 📝 Is it possible to have a romantic relationship without attachment?
- 📝 Is it possible to reconcile the evolution theory with Buddhism?
- 📝 How does one explain consistency within phenomena if the mind generates phenomena?
- 📝 Can a person live by the Dhamma and have another religion as well?