Battle of Xiaoting: was Shu's invasion doomed from the start?
score:6
In terms of the objective you defined in the question, the Shu army had a reasonable chance of success. Liu Bei's army held two significant advantages:
Superior infantry: the Shu army consisted of battle hardened, professional veterans who were better versed in field combat than Wu soldiers, especially in mountainous regions. The strength of the Wu military was in their navy. On the ground, Wu forces were largely ineffectual against relatively fewer Wei defenders than their Shu counterparts.
Home ground: The backbone of the Shu forces were from the Jing province. This applied to both his officer corps, and also to the rank and file. Not only was morale high in the fight to recapture their homes from the Wu invaders, Shu's diplomats (also Jing natives) were quite successful in inciting the regional minorities into rebellion against Wu.
In terms of overall strategic situation, Shu had the additional advantage that Wei's armies were poised for an invasion of the South. In fact, Wu's forces were facing a war on two fronts, leading the following exchange soon after the battle:
劉備聞魏軍大出、書與遜云「賊今已在江陵、吾將復東、將軍謂其能然不？」遜答曰「但恐軍新破、創痍未復、始求通親、且當自補、未暇窮兵耳。若不惟算、欲復以傾覆之餘、遠送以來者、無所逃命。」
Liu Bei, hearing of the Wei invasion, wrote Lu Xun to say, "I heard the enemy has reached Jiangling. I'm thinking of returning to the East too. What do you think?"
Lu Xun replied, "I'm afraid your army was just defeated, and haven't recovered from wounds and illnesses yet. It is time to sue for peace and recuperate, instead of pursuing jingoism. If you don't listen, and insist on on attacking after a defeat, the soldiers you send will have no place to run."
-- 《晉·張勃·吳錄》
Throughout the Wei invasion, Lu Xun stayed in position blocking Liu Bei's invasion path. By the time Wei forces lifted the siege due to rampaging disease, Jiangling was on the verge of surrendering, and relief forces scrapped together from elsewhere were repulsed every time. Lu Xun's inaction demonstrates how potentially formidable Liu Bei's surviving forces still were, at least in the minds of Wu's leaders.
Given the tactical and strategic advantages in Shu's favour, Liu Bei's invasion had at least some chance of success for retaking western Jing. On the other hand, pushing further east would have been an entirely different question; the extra distance significantly shifts logistical and terrain advantages in Wu's favour. If Liu Bei intended the Shu invasion to conquer all of Jing or even Wu itself, then you could say the invasion was doomed. The Shu navy's depleted state would by itself rule out conquering beyond Jiangling.
That said, forcing a negotiated settlement seem like the more likely plan on Liu Bei's part.
Note also that Liu Bei's invasion was not "hasty" by any means. The Shu province was captured in 214. Kuan Yu was defeated and killed in 219. It took until 221 before Liu Bei launched his invasion. By this point Liu had administered the Yi province for 7 years. For reference, Liu began his conquest of Yi a mere 4 years after taking control of Jing.
More post
- 📝 During the time of the British Mandate, who opposed the term "Hashemite Kingdom of Palestine" and who if any were OK with it being called that?
- 📝 What was the reason for the Dutch attack on Venezuela in 1908?
- 📝 What kind of law courts existed in first-century Palestine?
- 📝 Treatment of h*m*sexuals in Nazi Germany
- 📝 What should I call bands of armed men in the Middle Ages?
- 📝 Were there ever Taoist missionaries?
- 📝 What is the history of stay at home moms?
- 📝 Why didn't the Roman maniple make a comeback in the Renaissance?
- 📝 Why was Austria given the best chunk in the First Partition of Poland, even while protesting it?
- 📝 Maximum speed of communication prior to Trans-Atlantic Cable?
- 📝 How do new countries legally and without bloodshed declare themselves independent?
- 📝 What made the discovery of Tutankhamun's tomb such a significant archeological find?
- 📝 Was the British Army a millionaire factory in the early 20th century?
- 📝 Who liberated Denmark in WWII?
- 📝 Why was the Treaty of Versailles so harsh?
- 📝 Did Palmerston contribute to Louis Philippe's downfall?
- 📝 Can anyone help identify this, possibly Greek, type of uniform/dress?
- 📝 Why did British Gen. Frank Messervy oppose the invasion of Kashmir?
- 📝 Why was Apple not able to compete with Microsoft in the home PC market?
- 📝 Was the Roman Empire based on a 'plunder economy'?
- 📝 How could an Englishman be forced to fight for Austria-Hungary against his will during WW1?
- 📝 Why was the water in roman fountains cold?
- 📝 In what way were Renaissance battles like chess matches?
- 📝 Why did Japan never "apologize" enough for World War 2?
- 📝 In Europe, why were there few portraits showing a real likeness of the subject before the 15th century?
- 📝 Why was East Pakistan never divided into multiple provinces?
- 📝 Cost of peac**k throne vs Cost of Taj Mahal
- 📝 Why didn't Semmelweis perform a simpler experiment, to stop all the anatomical work?
- 📝 What was the role of Scotland during the Hundred Years War?
- 📝 What is the origin of the first dynasty in Scotland?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Battle of Xiaoting: was Shu's invasion doomed from the start?
- 📝 How difficult was to escape from a naval battle after engaging into one during the Age of Sail?
- 📝 Why did Japan not withdraw from China as its pacific front was crumbling and the threat of US invasion imminent?
- 📝 Was the Kerensky Offensive doomed from the start?
- 📝 Why was Poland spared from the Black Death?
- 📝 What was the reason for Soviet troops to withdraw from Yugoslavia in World War II?
- 📝 Which battle was the most lopsided result in terms of casualties?
- 📝 Was the tugboat ever part of a WWII battle group?
- 📝 Was there an assassination attempt against Xerxes in the battle of Thermopylae?
- 📝 Was Rosie the Riveter sourced from a Michelangelo painting?
- 📝 Was there really a navy officer named Picard at the Battle of Trafalgar?
- 📝 What was the first battle in history fought by vast-majority-% "distance-shooting" non-mechanized force?
- 📝 What was the last battle fought mainly by sail-powered ships?
- 📝 When was the last documented occasion that Arab or Ottoman slave traders abducted people from Europe?
- 📝 Who was the most successful German spy against Great Britain in WWII, from the contemporary German perspective?
- 📝 What was the "Favorable result" that the German admiralty was expecting from the naval attack on the Royal Navy in 1918?
- 📝 What was the first successful mass tank battle of WW1?
- 📝 How was life in the Iron Age different from life in the Middle Ages?
- 📝 Who was the last US president who did not start a war?
- 📝 When was the change from kalends, ides and nones to numbers
- 📝 Why was the last battle of the War of 1812 fought fully half a year after the official end of the war?
- 📝 Was the transition from the Bronze Age to the Iron Age violent?
- 📝 When was tofu invented? Was it specifically for vegetarian consumption from the beginning?
- 📝 Constantine the Great created the Chi-Rho from the Greek word for "Christ". Why choose Greek over Latin, even though he was Roman?
- 📝 From 1936-45 what was the prescribed punishment in Nazi Germany for failing to join or participate in the Hitler Youth?
- 📝 Was the Battle of Tours really the turning point for the Umayyad expansion into Europe?
- 📝 Who was the richest person in the world at the start and end of WW2?
- 📝 Who was Richard of York at the Battle of Grunwald?
- 📝 Is it true that slavery was banned from discussion on the Senate and/or House floor before the American Civil War?
- 📝 Was the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan one of the major reasons that led to the fall of Soviet Union?