Why did Stalin exile Trotsky instead of killing or imprisoning him?
Upvote:12
According to Trotsky (excrept from Коминтерн и ГПУ, published in Бюллетень оппозиции (большевиков-ленинцев) № 85, translation mine):
In 1928 […] not only the shooting squad, but even arrest would be inconceivable: the generation, alongside which I went thorugh the October Revolution and the civil war, was still alive. Politburo felt it was under siege from all sides. From Central Asia I had the ability to keep in constant contact with the growing opposition. In these conditions Stalin, after a year of doubt, decided to use exile as a lesser evil. His arguments were: isolated from USSR, with no staff or material resources, Trotsky will be unable to act […]. Stalin admitted on multiple occasions that my exile was his "greatest mistake".
He simply was too popular at the moment. Even his deportation to Almaty in January 1928 was handled in a very roundabout way - sure, he was forcibly removed from Moscow, but on the other hand - he was allowed to keep most of his posessions (most importantly - his vast personal archive), and until October he had full freedom in communication. On another hand, keeping him in Soviet Union was not an option, either: he kept on rallying his supporters. So he was exiled.
P.S. This isn't really related to the decision-making process regarding the exile, but: what I found interesting while researching this question was that even when Stalin consolidated his power he was mainly concerned by Trotsky's archive (in fact, the Stalin's "greatest mistake" remark Trotsky mentions was about allowing him to take the archive with him). The order for Trotsky's murder only came in 1939, when Trotsky in his article "Сверхборджиа в Кремле" publicly denounced Stalin for the pact with Germany (and also pretty much implied Stalin poisoned Lenin).
More post
- 📝 How rich were carpenters in Roman Galilee in the 1st century AD?
- 📝 What was the effect of the Panic of 1837 on financial/banking policy?
- 📝 History of monogamy
- 📝 Presidents of the French Tribunate from 1799 to 1807
- 📝 Why did the Erdoğan government like to worsen Turkey's relationship with Israel?
- 📝 What is Lorenzo de' Medici holding in this painting?
- 📝 Nuremberg Laws - Did they affect existing marriages between Jews and Non-Jews?
- 📝 Which came first: polytheism or monotheism?
- 📝 Did Roman unmarried men have a preferred hand and finger for wearing their seal ring?
- 📝 Naming of (strategic) hills on a map as numbers (example Hill 60)
- 📝 Can a source be considered 'primary' if it is not written by an eyewitness and partly based on another source?
- 📝 How did the Medici originally get into finance?
- 📝 What is the back story behind the Baja California towns of "Purgatorio" and "Providencia"?
- 📝 How did Spain justify building a major port at San Blas, Nayarit?
- 📝 What was lost when the British burned the White House in 1814?
- 📝 WW1: What would happen if an aerial bomb was dropped from too high an altitude?
- 📝 Why does Europe have so few skyscrapers compared to East Asia?
- 📝 Are there any historical accounts of Aisha (the wife of Muhammad) giving public speeches?
- 📝 Why didn't Mao see that the "Great Leap Forward" would be such a disaster?
- 📝 How do I learn more about untitled artworks on the internet? (like this specific Basquiat painting)
- 📝 How could a chariot work against a phalanx?
- 📝 Inquiry into the nature and roots of the temporal power of the Roman Catholic Pope:
- 📝 In 1700-1900 England, how were 'manners an end in themselves and not merely a means to achieve propriety by conformity'?
- 📝 How many acres per person were needed for the early American settlers vs. the native Americans?
- 📝 When did monogamy become the norm in Ancient Greece?
- 📝 How rigorously do combat engineers follow command hierarchy?
- 📝 Before the imposition of Sakoku, did any Japanese people travel to Africa, the Middle East or Europe?
- 📝 Did Shackleton's crew all "miss out" on WW1?
- 📝 What was the relationship between Ottoman emperor Murat IV and his mother Kosem Sultan?
- 📝 What did contemporary countries in Europe call the Ottoman Empire?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Why did Stalin exile Trotsky instead of killing or imprisoning him?
- 📝 Why did Stalin and the Soviet leadership have Leon Trotsky assassinated?
- 📝 Why did Henry I imprison his older brother and rival Robert for almost 30 years instead of having him killed?
- 📝 Why exactly did telegraphs have to use "STOP" instead of a period and "QUOTE" instead of a quotation mark? (Or special codes.)
- 📝 Why did Columbus cross the mid-Atlantic instead of exploring from Greenland?
- 📝 Why did English adopt Kamikaze (神風) as a loanword instead of Tokko (特攻) during/after WWII?
- 📝 In WW2, why did Germany sink allied supply convoys instead of capturing them?
- 📝 Why did Poland keep Warsaw as its capital instead of returning it to Krakow in the 20th century?
- 📝 Why did the USA invade Okinawa instead of one of the many other islands in southern Japan
- 📝 Why did Roosevelt and Churchill use voice-based telecommunication, instead of simpler text-based options which were easier to encrypt?
- 📝 Why did the term "Byzantine Empire" enter common usage instead of "Eastern Roman Empire" or "Roman Empire"
- 📝 Why did Stalin keep the famine of 1932 a secret?
- 📝 Why did the United States drop a uranium bomb instead of a plutonium bomb on Hiroshima?
- 📝 Why did Napoleon march to Moscow instead of Saint Petersburg?
- 📝 Why did Churchill become the PM of Britain during WWII instead of Lord Halifax?
- 📝 Why did Stalin push for the Great Purge against the Red Army in 1936?
- 📝 Why did Nero order many of the Pisonian conspirators to commit suicide instead of having them executed by the sword?
- 📝 Why did the US insist on invading Japan instead of blockading it in WWII?
- 📝 When Louis I of Hungary died in 1382, why did Polish lords choose Jadwiga instead of Mary as the monarch?
- 📝 Why did Stalin deem Quantum Mechanics 'counter-revolutionary'?
- 📝 Why did the father of algebra speak Arabic instead of Persian?
- 📝 Why did the British take Hong Kong instead of any other of the later treaty ports?
- 📝 Why did Fall Blau start at Voronezh instead of further south?
- 📝 Why did Bavaria join Prussia/Germany instead of Austria?
- 📝 Why did Odoacer choose to be king Instead of emperor?
- 📝 Why did Spartacus turn South at Mutina instead of continuing North towards Thrace?
- 📝 Why did General Gürsel plea to forgive Adnan Menderes after overthrowing him in coup?
- 📝 As far as Themistocles's journey after his exile is concerned why do modern historians conclude that Plutarch meant Thasos instead of Naxos?
- 📝 Why did Meriwether Lewis think that William Clark was coming to help him just before he killed himself?
- 📝 Why exactly did Messiaen never meet the Nazi guard who helped him again, after the war?