Why did Napoleon march to Moscow instead of Saint Petersburg?
Upvote:0
- Moscow was a capital in XIX cent. It was "old capital", "second capital", but capital it was. Without any doubt it was the main religious center.
- Moscow was a main road hub. Taking it and controlling the nearest surroundings, Napoleon controlled all main roads. At least, he thought so. The problem was, that being the best tactic, he was weak as a strategist. And against him Kutuzov stood, maybe the best strategist at all. He was famous for winning wars without battles. This time Napoleon had the hub, Kutuzov sat nearly and it was Kutuzov who blocked Napoleon, not vice versa.
- Yes, taking St.Petersburg was much easier. So, Napoleon thought that Ponyatovsky would be enough. The same as he thought that Schwarzenberg will take the Kiev.
- None of his strategic plans in Russia were successful. By the way, Napoleon never thought about the retreat until it happened and never thought about famine until Kutuzov MADE him to return the same road.
- If 640000 ( Or even 320000 that went in this direction) army would go all along the same road to the ST.Petersburg, they would start to die of hunger much earlier than on the BACK route.
Conclusion: There were reasons to choose Moscow for a target, but it could be only a preliminary target. And it was. Taking it did not help to make Russia to capitulate. So, the decision to go for Moscow was voluntary, purely personal and erroneous. But choosing the St-P would be even worse error. Napoleon simply could not solve the task - what intermediate tasks could win the war in Russia.
Napoleon wanted a decisive win. History teaches that it is impossible to win over Russia without it having the inner conflict. In 40 years the half of Europe, having the technological edge had managed to get only one important port from Russia.
Overtaking the rich western regions of Russia would be much more effective and easy. And really possible. Or Napoleon could initiate and support the civil war in Russia, claiming the freedom and ground for farmers. And Russia would become his willing and eager ally.
But Napoleon wanted to prove his geniality of a tactician once more. So, he had set the impossible task of total and pure military win over Russia. An impossible and/or foolish task is an often reason of fail for dictatorships. Maybe the main one.
Upvote:7
Napoleon's initial objective was defeating Russian army in a border battle. Immediately after that he was planning to start negotiations and, among other things, to restore the alliance with Russia. Neither Moscow, nor St.Petersburg were of any use for him.
On the other hand, Alexander I considered the possibility of losing both St.Petersburg and Moscow from the very beginning. And the plan would remain absolutely same.
Still being in Smolensk Napoleon tried to start peace talks, but had no success. Then he must have realized that the things didn't go as planned, and Russia was ready for a long war of attrition. And even capturing, say, St.Petersburg would change nothing. So he took his chance in pursuing Russian army and forcing it into battle.
Napoleon expected that public opinion wouldn't let Russian army to retreat forever. But, as we know, the battle of Borodino gave him nothing except abandoned city of Moscow. He tried to start peace talks several times, but had no answer at all.
Thus going to St.Petersburg instead of Moscow in the beginning of the war would let Napoleon to retreat from Russia easily, that's true. But he sought for a chance to win, and capturing St.Petersburg was totally useless from this point of view.
More post
- π What was the official position of China during the Sino-Soviet border clashes in the 1960s?
- π Why does the US have many top-level web domains?
- π How did tobacco affect the English colonies economically during the 17th Century?
- π Incentive to ban women having more than one husband?
- π What is the source for this story about Plato expelling a student?
- π Has NATO ever started a war?
- π Were the Vikings descendents of the Tribe of Dan?
- π Why was the Hexamillion wall incapable of preventing invasion?
- π How can you see what rank a British redcoat is?
- π What does this acronym and the symbol in the middle represent?
- π Were there a British 'NΓ©gritude' movement?
- π Why did the rest of the Eastern Bloc not invade Yugoslavia?
- π How far could an English war bow shoot?
- π Was game theory used during World War II?
- π Was Anne Frank's story common?
- π Who was included in the "Moors" of Spain?
- π Ancient civilizations and their habits
- π Why couldn't bastards inherit titles?
- π In a challenge to duel, what happened if a thrown gauntlet (and later, glove) was refused?
- π Did any country threaten war on the US because they didn't pay their debt after the Revolutionary War?
- π Is there mutual significance in the year 1807, so far as abolition of the slave trade in Britain and the United States is concerned?
- π Was coat of arms of Afghanistan of 1928 influenced by Soviet symbols?
- π Did Andrew Jackson kill Dickinson fairly according to the customs of duels at the time?
- π Why did army in Napoleon era never use hand-grenades to temporarily disrupt the square formation?
- π Have the Arabs ever conquered Kayseri?
- π What is this strange uniform?
- π What's this 1607 Hispania coin?
- π Why would graphite have been confused with lead?
- π Why did the East India Company accept the Government of India Act 1858?
- π Why did Romans use the sesterce in written monetary records when the coin itself was so rarely used?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Why did Napoleon march to Moscow instead of Saint Petersburg?
- π In the Revolutionary War, why did General Howe attack Philadelphia, instead of continuing his march to join General Burgoyne?
- π Why exactly did telegraphs have to use "STOP" instead of a period and "QUOTE" instead of a quotation mark? (Or special codes.)
- π Why did Columbus cross the mid-Atlantic instead of exploring from Greenland?
- π Why did English adopt Kamikaze (η₯ι’¨) as a loanword instead of Tokko (ηΉζ») during/after WWII?
- π In WW2, why did Germany sink allied supply convoys instead of capturing them?
- π Why did Poland keep Warsaw as its capital instead of returning it to Krakow in the 20th century?
- π Why did the USA invade Okinawa instead of one of the many other islands in southern Japan
- π Why did Roosevelt and Churchill use voice-based telecommunication, instead of simpler text-based options which were easier to encrypt?
- π Why did the term "Byzantine Empire" enter common usage instead of "Eastern Roman Empire" or "Roman Empire"
- π Why did Peter the Great name Saint Petersburg, Russia with a foreign styled name?
- π Why did the United States drop a uranium bomb instead of a plutonium bomb on Hiroshima?
- π Why did Churchill become the PM of Britain during WWII instead of Lord Halifax?
- π Why did Nero order many of the Pisonian conspirators to commit suicide instead of having them executed by the sword?
- π Why did the US insist on invading Japan instead of blockading it in WWII?
- π When Louis I of Hungary died in 1382, why did Polish lords choose Jadwiga instead of Mary as the monarch?
- π Why did the father of algebra speak Arabic instead of Persian?
- π Why did the British take Hong Kong instead of any other of the later treaty ports?
- π Why did Fall Blau start at Voronezh instead of further south?
- π Why did Bavaria join Prussia/Germany instead of Austria?
- π Why did Odoacer choose to be king Instead of emperor?
- π Why did Spartacus turn South at Mutina instead of continuing North towards Thrace?
- π Why did Napoleon change his mind and continue the attack into Russia?
- π Why did Henry I imprison his older brother and rival Robert for almost 30 years instead of having him killed?
- π Why did Roosevelt and Truman change the usual switch date of presidency? (4th of March to 20th of January)
- π Why did Stalin exile Trotsky instead of killing or imprisoning him?
- π Why did Napoleon IV die fighting in the British Army?
- π Did Helsinki have higher standards of living than Saint Petersburg when it was a part of the Russian Empire?
- π Why did army in Napoleon era never use hand-grenades to temporarily disrupt the square formation?
- π Why did Napoleon divide his army during the retreat from Smolensk?