Did medieval commanders exchange words before battle?
score:2
I have looked at the descriptions of many of the battles, especially the 100 Years' War, and most of them were preceded by negotiations, leading us to believe that it may have been customary and was at the very least common.
Upvote:-2
Sounds like a villain in a James Bond movie.
Seriously...dispatching emissaries prior to any contact with friend or foe alike was I believe it was considered normative in Roman Times especially prior to giving battle as there are no greater victories than ones that require no battle be given in the first place. This would change during Imperial Rome though. As far as Medieval Europe goes it's hard to imagine the notion of chivalry without the theory of failing to give battle without losing one's honor in so doing.
In Naval terms there is also the concept of "parlay" made famous by the movie series Pirates of the Caribbean and Captain Jack Sparrow.
Upvote:1
It just doesn't seem plausible to my ignorant brain just to see an enemy army and shout "ATTAAACK!" without first saying something to the enemy commander, especially in a situation where it was the respective armies first encounter. That makes me think there might have been a formal and cultural way of doing it.
Ideally, you'd like to shout "attack!" before the enemy army even knows you're there: an ambush. These are hard to pull off, but clearly happen without any negotiations, e.g. Hannibal at Lake Trasimene or the Battle of the Teutoburg Forest.
If there was no chance of hiding your forces from your enemies, your armies would maneuver around each other, trying to force battle at a tactically strong location. Some famous examples of such maneuverings include Pompey and Caesar in Greece and Hannibal and Fabius during the 2nd Punic War. If you could figure out where the opposing army was, you could send emissaries to negotiate, but both armies would be trying to hide their movements. An example of this type of communication is the delivery of Hannibal's brother Hasdrubal's head to Hannibal's camp by the Romans as a sign of his death. In this case, yes, generals could and would negotiate as long as it met the orders they were operating under.
Once the armies met, the chance to hide was over: they would get into formation, with each side trying to get into a position that benefited them while costing the other side. Given that the armies would then march at or charge each other, their lines had to be pretty close -- which also meant that it was possible for generals to send emissaries to negotiate their way out of the battle -- since any battle held the possibility of a rout, any general would like to win by peaceful means of at all possible, but might not have been authorized to: few generals would be able to negotiate a peaceful solution if their leader had decreed merciless war, say. I think the examples you give in your question are good examples, but I don't think negotiated settlements would have been very common, as both generals would have had specific military goals to accomplish (capture some land, eliminate some army) and would know that they'd be unlikely to get these by negotiation. So, while this was definitely possible, it was probably not generally attempted. A good example of the closeness of the armies was at the Battle of Pharsalus, where Caesar's legions advanced to within throwing distance of Pompey's, paused to regroup, and only then charged. So, yes, even at this late state, negotiation was an option. It seems unlikely to me, though: negotiating might show weakness to the enemy or to your own soldiers, and you might be accused of cowardice.
To respond to the other part of your question: the dwarves and elves had been allied not so many centuries ago and did not have perfectly contradictory goals here: the elves were looking for a monetary reward, and the dwarves could easily have paid them and both sides would have left peacefully. If the dwarves wanted to, say, eject the elves from Mirkwood, I don't think they'd've bothered to negotiate.
More post
- 📝 Who was the first to point out that transmutation of gold would be mostly useless, since it would simply lead to inflation?
- 📝 Where can I find what the cost of a train ticket in the USA was in 1930?
- 📝 Did Japanese officers refuse to engage in kamikaze attacks?
- 📝 Did a kamikaze ever impact the hull of a ship, as opposed to the deck?
- 📝 How big was the percentage of white people in the USA who were not against granting the blacks equal rights?
- 📝 Are there any theories of Tiglath Pileser III's origins?
- 📝 What uncertainties and questions surround the death of Attila?
- 📝 How beneficial were war bonds to the US during WWII
- 📝 Were Jews cut off from the Babylonian Geonim?
- 📝 Can someone identify this banknote?
- 📝 What were Egyptian rulers called before the honorific title "Pharaoh"?
- 📝 Why does a Star of David appear at a rally with Francisco Franco?
- 📝 How much did cannon cost in 1410?
- 📝 What religions were persecuted and disappeared (between 1000 BCE – 1 CE)?
- 📝 Why did the jews leave Israel and spread out through the world?
- 📝 Was there a serious proposal to offer India territory in East Africa?
- 📝 What route would 1st century BCE travellers have taken from Alexandria to Jerusalem?
- 📝 What were the reasons for making Prohibition a constitutional amendment?
- 📝 Was Wilhelm II aware of the Franco-Russian Military Convention 1892?
- 📝 Why did Sweden not fortify Swedish Livonia along its eastern frontier, including the approaches to Riga?
- 📝 What was the origin and purpose of the "Montes"?
- 📝 How could the 4/5 devaluation of Franc Poincaré in 1928 end the financial crisis France was going through?
- 📝 Has Nursing Always Been Female Dominated Like Today (90+%)?
- 📝 When did the Commonwealth of England start being considered a Republic?
- 📝 Did medieval Mongol horse archers have deformed arms like English bowmen?
- 📝 How did tobacco affect the English colonies economically during the 17th Century?
- 📝 Have there been government conspiracies that were successful for over 25 years?
- 📝 What is the oldest movie theater in the US that has been in continuous use as a movie theater?
- 📝 Why is Lady Jane Grey called Lady instead of Queen?
- 📝 Row for powers of 10 on 1950's French typewriter keyboards
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Did medieval commanders exchange words before battle?
- 📝 Did medieval scholars believe the Earth was round?
- 📝 Did medieval stores have names?
- 📝 How did people wash dishes before dish detergent?
- 📝 Did cows in Medieval times have calves in spring or all year round?
- 📝 What did babies eat before the advent of modern blenders?
- 📝 Where did Medieval Europe's gold come from?
- 📝 Did medieval peasants work 150 days a year?
- 📝 How did Medieval armies survive the use of mail armor in the deserts of the Middle East?
- 📝 Did Native Americans ever fight the indigenous people living in Mexico before Europeans arrived?
- 📝 How did cities operate in medieval times?
- 📝 What concessions did Hitler demand from the Poles before 1939?
- 📝 Did Muslim states hire Western European knights as mercenaries before the Crusades?
- 📝 Did any British working class men have the vote before 1918?
- 📝 Did the U.S. and Soviet Union have a submarine battle in 1968?
- 📝 How did medieval manors handle population growth? Was there room for more fields to be ploughed?
- 📝 What did squires do in the middle of a medieval battle?
- 📝 Classical battle sizes vs medieval battle sizes
- 📝 When did countries begin making up a pretext before starting a war?
- 📝 How did people wake up on time before alarm clocks?
- 📝 Did men and women feast together in early medieval East Francia?
- 📝 How did archers judge distance before range finders?
- 📝 Before television sets became commonplace, did people generally watch movies only once?
- 📝 Did "droit du seigneur" actually exist in medieval Europe?
- 📝 Did the Celts really go into battle naked?
- 📝 How did the British Navy pass orders to its fleet before radio?
- 📝 Did the aborigines of Australia and the Maoris in New Zealand know about each other's existence, before the Europeans came?
- 📝 How frequently did monasteries attack other monasteries in Early Medieval Western Europe?
- 📝 How did Islam and Hinduism thrive together in Medieval India?
- 📝 How did people have access to ice in warm areas before the industrial revolution?