Contemporary opinions on Caliph Omar's burning of the library of Alexandria?
score:8
There are no known contemporary opinions— perhaps because there was no such event to form an opinion about.
Entire books have been written on the loss of the library, but I would first note that most historians reject this story as scurrilous. In fact, the orientalist Bernard Lewis, not ordinarily considered a propagandist for Islam, wrote an essay entitled "The Arab Destruction of the Library of Alexandria: Anatomy of a Myth" which appears in What Happened to the Ancient Library of Alexandria? by Mostafa el-Abbadi and Omnia Mounir Fathallah, eds. (2008), a series of papers from a conference on the same topic.
A mention of Umar directing the burning of the library is first found in the 12th-century writings of Abdul al-Latif al-Baghdadi. Ibn al-Qifti, who visited Cairo in 1200, writes of the incident in his History of Learned Men (Ta'rikh al-hukama), and his story was repeated a few years later by Bar-Hebraeus. In other words, despite a rich literary tradition, half a millennium passed when no source, whether Christian or Muslim or Jewish, from anywhere within the Arab or Byzantine or Persian worlds, makes any reference to the destruction of the world-famous library that supposedly occurred in 642. That is, none until it surfaces in al-Qifti, for whom it was politically expedient.
The library had already suffered. A good part of its collection was destroyed in 47 BC, and another in 273 AD, and probably more in 391 (although blaming Patriarch Theophilus seems to be an equally scurrilous accusation, considering his real target was the Temple of Serapis in another part of the city). It's possible that the story is a fabrication; it's possible that Amr burned a different library, perhaps that of a monastery, that became conflated with the Great Library; or perhaps Amr did burn the Great Library— but by that time, itw as a library great only in name.
More post
- 📝 Is it true that Hitler led to the invention of the atomic bomb by the Americans?
- 📝 Did soldiers wear helmets in the 19th century?
- 📝 Independent development of ocean navigation
- 📝 How to identify this probably French Military uniform?
- 📝 Why hasn't Sub-Sahan African developed as fast as other regions between the beginning of civilisation and European colonialism?
- 📝 What advantage did Napoleon gain by attacking and antagonizing the Catholic Church?
- 📝 Would occupying Big Round Top have been a good idea for the Confederates?
- 📝 Does Amnesty International maintain a list of prisoners of conscience?
- 📝 Was it illegal to express sympathy for Nazi Germany during WW2 in Great Britain?
- 📝 The economic prosperity of former colonies and their demographic make up
- 📝 How could a skilled battle commander like Napoleon Bonaparte lose to Prussians at Waterloo (Belgium) as such?
- 📝 Who was responsible for the partition of India?
- 📝 Why was Hesse south of the Main left out of the North German Confederation?
- 📝 Is there any footage and/or photos of Germans surrendering towns and cities in the Western Front?
- 📝 Was the "natural born citizen" requirement for the President inserted into the US Constitution by Alexander Hamilton's enemies?
- 📝 Did pre-Columbian Americans know the spherical shape of the Earth?
- 📝 How were cattle cut out in the 19th century?
- 📝 What was the reason behind the Reinheitsgebot (beer purity law)?
- 📝 What was the ancient Jewish pantheon?
- 📝 Did the Romans eat fish on Fridays in honor of Venus?
- 📝 What made Stalingrad a turning point in the second world war?
- 📝 Forms of address of Roman Magistrates under Constantinus
- 📝 How were diplomats and their staffs treated when World War II was declared?
- 📝 Did the Allies benefit, by having Italy fight on Germany's side rather than remain neutral?
- 📝 What was the largest warship sunk by a Motor Torpedo Boat in WW2?
- 📝 What makes studying science different from studying the history of science?
- 📝 Has an entire generation of a young children in a civilization ever been orphaned and raised as loyals?
- 📝 Did it make sense to bring along infantry to reinforce attacking cavalry before the introduction of firearms?
- 📝 How much Ancient Egyptian survived into modern Coptic & Egyptian Arabic?
- 📝 According to game theory would Germany's post 1939 expansionism have provided the optimal economic benefits?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Contemporary opinions on Caliph Omar's burning of the library of Alexandria?
- 📝 What irreplaceable manuscripts were lost in the burning of Jaffna Public Library and what history did they contain (and subsequently lost forever)?
- 📝 What knowledge may have been lost at the Library of Alexandria?
- 📝 Why did the Mongols destroy the library during the siege of Baghdad in 1258?
- 📝 Has there ever been a truly bilingual country prior to the contemporary period?
- 📝 Who was the most successful German spy against Great Britain in WWII, from the contemporary German perspective?
- 📝 What was the contemporary German public opinion on the Herero Genocide?
- 📝 What do we know about the organizational structure of the Library of Alexandria?
- 📝 Is there contemporary evidence for the Roman Kingdom?
- 📝 What did contemporary countries in Europe call the Ottoman Empire?
- 📝 Were women allowed to study at the Library of Alexandria?
- 📝 A common find of metal detectorists across Britain is the silver "love token", from around 1700. Do any contemporary sources describe the custom?
- 📝 What were contemporary Japanese views on the Taiping Rebellion and Heavenly Kingdom?
- 📝 How was library classification done in English-speaking libraries prior to the 19th century?
- 📝 What are the scholarly opinions on the idea of the "European Civil War"?
- 📝 Did Roundheads have opinions on early leaders of the Reformation (e.g., Martin Luther) during the Civil War?
- 📝 What is the contemporary knowledge of the theoretical history?
- 📝 How to collate the available contemporary press coverage of the 1936 US olympic hockey team?
- 📝 Does any library hold the archives of the Russian-American Company?
- 📝 What was the contemporary reaction to Dante's Divine Comedy?
- 📝 How did philosophical and scientific knowledge in Christian Europe in 1085 compare to the body of knowledge contained in the library of Toledo?
- 📝 What's the history of bus hijacking & burning during the Troubles?
- 📝 What was the first recorded instance of burning a city or village in war?
- 📝 What was the contemporary popular opinion of the Anglo-Irish Treaty?
- 📝 Will Hegelian or Dialectical historiography regain any relevance into the contemporary historical discourse?
- 📝 Which SF author was unable to check his own work out of the library due to insufficient security clearance?
- 📝 Why was Caliph Suleyman disliked by the noted generals in the Umayyad army?
- 📝 Are there any contemporary diaries about the Yugoslav Wars?
- 📝 Who ruled India when the Abbasid ruler Harun al-Rashid was the Caliph of Baghdad?
- 📝 What was the role of Theon at the Library of Alexandria?