Did Jonah fail the test of a prophet?
score:17
What's clear from the account of Jonah is that God would have destroyed the city if it were not for the people's repentance. Jonah's prophecy was accurate in that it articulated what God was going to do, but God relented. There was no failing in Jonah's ability to discern and communicate the will of God prior to the people's repentance, but that remarkable repentance was a hugely significant event that altered the subsequent history of that city.
There is a bit of chicken-and-egg here. God could of course have prevented Jonah from making this prophecy since he knew the people would repent, in which case the people of Nineveh wouldn't have heard about what God had in store for them. They therefore might not have repented, and the city would have been destroyed... it's similar to the liar paradox. In other words, the people needed to hear Jonah tell them what was in store if they didn't repent in order to repent: the prophecy was conditional.
You could also argue that Jonah's prophecy holds true: the city was overthrown within 40 days, but in a spiritual sense rather than a physical one.
In the case of Joseph Smith, those who maintain he was a false prophet argue there were no such events that altered history in the same way yet still his prophecies did not come to pass; this isn't a case of God relenting, it's simply a case of getting it wrong in the first place. (Mormons of course disagree and maintain that some of his prophecies were later cancelled and others came to pass to a certain degree).
There are several supporting online resources... these are from a Google search, so may not all be representative of mainstream Christianity: Let Us Reason Ministries | Christian Research Institute | Third Millennium Ministries | Mormonism Research Ministry
Upvote:0
So I have to point you to the book of Nahum and the fact that the kingdom of Nineveh is no longer around. In addition, we have to understand that human time is a lot different than God's time. How long was the Messiah prophesied?
Upvote:1
Jonah was the only prophet in the Hebrew Bible that was sent to some of the Gentiles. Generally there was no reason to send a prophet to the Gentiles, since they were not given the same set of laws as the Israelites. So unless they got totally depraved, God left them as they were.
It's interesting to note, that even in that case, when the Gentiles needed to correct their ways - they were able to do it without any Jesus. Jonah does not preach to them about having faith in Jesus as the only way to attain forgiveness from God. On the contrary, they are simply told to do it the old (testament) way - avoiding from immoral behavior. Jesus is never mentioned.
The story of Jonah is quite striking to the Christian theology. Not surprising that the only useful moral that the New Testament's writers were able to make out of that story is, to mention that Jesus was believed to be dead for three days (48 hours?), the same amount of days that Jonah spent in the stomach of the whale.
Upvote:5
Consider this: If the only words that Jonah spoke were "Forty more days and Nineveh will be overthrown." the Ninevites would not "have believed God and repented". This is because they would not have known upon what authority Jonah was speaking, nor would they have known what to do.
It's clear from the actions of the Ninevites and the unchanging nature of God, that Jonah preached: "This is what the Lord your God says: 'Repent of your wickedness or in forty more days Nineveh will be overthrown.'"
The author of this story explained the context surrounding what Jonah was to do, which gives him plenty of reason to leave out the exact phrase that Jonah spoke and instead paraphrase it.
How does this fit with Deut. 18, where God says that if the word of a prophet doesn't come to pass, it's not from the Lord?
The Ninevites believed that God would overthrow them in forty days if they had not repented, why is it that we would not believe that God would have done this? To say that God would not have done this, thus Jonah spoke presumptuously, even though the author makes it clear that God commanded Jonah to say something, is ignorant and scoffing of this story.
Should the inhabitants of Nineveh have considered Jonah a false prophet?
If the inhabitants of Nineveh hadn't believed Jonah in any way shape or form, then they would have been given plenty of evidence that Jonah was a true prophet, as they would have been overthrown. That is clear.
The inhabitants of Nineveh believed that Jonah was a true prophet, because Jonah preached that they should repent of their wickedness, or else perish. This warning is in complete coherence with the nature and the will of God, therefore the Ninevites believed that he was a prophet.
If Jonah had preached that the Ninevites should become Holy by their own standards and Lord it over each other in order to become Gods themselves, well, this is not in coherence with anything that God has ever told us. Therefore Jonah would have died a false prophet.
Should we consider Jonah a false prophet?
This Bible story gives us a complete context to this situation that Jonah was placed in. If you compare the message that Jonah spoke with the actions of God and the actions of the Ninevites, then it's clear that Jonah was a prophet.
Again, the Ninevites believed Jonah and God relented of His destruction against Nineveh.
What Jonah preached was exactly what happened, therefore this story gives us every reason to believe that Jonah was a true prophet of God.
More post
- 📝 Why is the Holy Spirit often referred as "Ghost"?
- 📝 Does a list exist showing Papal succession from Peter through our current Pope?
- 📝 Can a Sovereign-will authorize personal liberty?
- 📝 What is the earliest surviving reference to the Paschal Greeting?
- 📝 Is it allowed to do bad things for a good reason?
- 📝 Where does the story of "the Cross on top of Adam's Skull" come from?
- 📝 Biblical basis of exaltation (LDS)
- 📝 What was the 'orthodox' view of God and Christ when the Arian Controversy began?
- 📝 Do mainline Protestant seminaries in the United States involve rigorous study of Hebrew and Greek?
- 📝 Is Cecil B. DeMille's narration of Moses in the desert based on the Bible?
- 📝 How does Christianity view such persons who are Xianpo(s)?
- 📝 Did the invention of the printing press change Christianity?
- 📝 What is the norm for celebrating First Friday/Saturday Novena Masses on Holy Days of Obligation?
- 📝 What are the main biblical interpretations used to defend the point of view that Nicodemus had inferior faith?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis against a child's right to privacy?
- 📝 Can Papal Supremacy be relinquished?
- 📝 Do any denominations take "turn the other cheek" as a literal command to be followed?
- 📝 What is the Christian counterpart of Sharia and Halakha?
- 📝 What specifically changed about Catholic seminaries in the 20th Century?
- 📝 Is there biblical reference to Michael, the archangel’s role and being?
- 📝 What does Matthew mean by "if your eye causes you to sin, tear it out", etc.?
- 📝 How does "being born a sinner" compare to "being born perfect" affect one's outlook on life and problem solving?
- 📝 To understand the "The Bible is the Word of God"
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for prohibiting sex outside marriage?
- 📝 Is participation in the near occasion of mortal sin and openness to the possibility of sin, mortal itself?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for typology between Moses and Jesus?
- 📝 What does Luke 11:5-8 mean?
- 📝 Priestly hiring competitions in the Catholic Church
- 📝 Where was Herod's temple built?
- 📝 What is the history of silent prayer?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Did Jonah fail the test of a prophet?
- 📝 How did the author of Jonah know about this conversation?
- 📝 Does Joseph Smith fail the test of a prophet?
- 📝 Did Jonah die and rise from the dead?
- 📝 Is the Prophet Jonah the same Jonah as in 2 Kings 14:23-25?
- 📝 On what basis did Mormon Prophet Joseph Smith declare that God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit cannot indwell a believer?
- 📝 Mormon Prophet Joseph Smith claimed that God the Father and Jesus Christ appeared to him. How did he know it was really the Father and the Son?
- 📝 On what Biblical basis did Mormon prophet Joseph Smith teach that the "Ancient of Days" at Daniel 7:22 is the first man Adam?
- 📝 Did the oil fail to come out 1 Samuel 16?
- 📝 According to Catholicism at the Upper Room, did the Apostles follow the tradition of laying of hands and pouring of oil like the prophet Samuel?
- 📝 How did all the animals fit into Noah's ark?
- 📝 When did the prohibition of marriage for priests in the Catholic church originate?
- 📝 Why did Jesus not want to be known as the Messiah?
- 📝 Why did the Pharisees need Judas to betray Jesus?
- 📝 Why did people live so long before the Flood?
- 📝 According to those holding that Lazarus was literally raised from the dead, why did Matthew, Mark, and Luke not mention it?
- 📝 Why did Jesus wear the crown of thorns?
- 📝 Did reformation leaders throw out the Summa Theologica?
- 📝 How did the livestock of the Egyptians die twice?
- 📝 How did the cross come to be a symbol for Christianity?
- 📝 What does it mean that Jesus fulfilled the law but did not abolish it?
- 📝 When did "tithing" come to mean "giving 10% of your gross income to the Church"?
- 📝 What were the Nephilim, and what role did they play in the Bible beyond just being mentioned?
- 📝 Did Paul write the Epistle to the Hebrews?
- 📝 Did early church fathers understand the doctrine of trinity?
- 📝 Why did the apostle John call himself, "the disciple whom Jesus loved"?
- 📝 Why did God kill a man for picking up sticks on the Sabbath?
- 📝 Why, according to the Catholic Church, did the Reformation happen?
- 📝 Did the Apostles' Creed originate with the Apostles?
- 📝 In Theistic Evolution, when did the alleged evolutionary animal/ape/man become accountable for his sins?