Where did substance language enter the Trinity debate?
Upvote:0
Where did substance language enter the Trinity debate ?
Since the belief in both God and his Son is a basic Christian tenet, the question naturally arises as to what exactly is meant by it:
- Is God Christ's father in the same sense in which He is also ours, namely as creator ?
- Or is He his father in the fullest sense of the word, namely as procreator ?
Since the difference between actual offspring, and metaphorical ones, is that the former literally share one's flesh and blood (or DNA, in modern parlance), a concept had to be sought to express the same idea in more abstract terms, as the divine is ultimately immaterial.
The Wikipedia page Sabellianism states that the Gnostics...
Sabellianism and Gnosticism are not (meaningfully) related to one another.
the generator and the generated have the same substance
They don't. In Gnosticism, the emanated is (ontologically) inferior to the emanator, the last (and therefore most inferior) emanation being the physical (and therefore intrinsically evil) world (this represents the fundamental Gnostic belief).
Were these people also Christians ?
Gnosticism was a highly syncretic, but ultimately independent, belief system, interacting with various other ancient religions, such as Platonism, Judaism, Christianity, or Zoroastrianism. At its roots, however, it was no more Christian than either pagan Platonism, or Judaism proper (which also interacted with one another, as evidenced by both the Septuagint Apocrypha, as well the writings of Philo, for instance).
Sabellius used the word h*m*ousi[os].
Technically true, but its meaning was diametrically opposed to Nicaea's usage of the same term. It is like I were to tell you that English and German are related languages, and that both use the term Gift, but I would conveniently omit to inform you that, in German, it means poison, not present, as it does English.
Is it possible that [Praxeas] was one of the Gnostics [?]
No. Unitarianism is not Gnosticism.
The closest thing, within Christianity itself, that I could (meaningfully) compare Gnosticism with, is Pseudo-Dionysius' system of angelic hierarchies.
Upvote:1
The term ὁμοούσιον (h*m*ousion) predates Dionysius Bishop of Alexandria (r. 247-265 A.D.), who wrote in response to a c. 262 A.D. letter to him by Pope St. Dionysius (259-268 A.D.):
I have not found this term (ὁμοούσιος τῷ Θεῷ) any where in Holy Scripture, yet my remarks which follow, and which they have not noticed, are not inconsistent with that belief
cf. Pohle The Divine Trinity: A Dogmatic Treatise pt. 1, ch. 2, §1, a. 2. "Its [Sabellianism's] Condemnation."
Tertullian [b. c. 160 A.D.] had already used the Latin equivalent of Homoousion, conceding to [his contemporary] Praxeas the Sabellian that the Father and the Son were unius substantiæ, of one substance, but adding duarum personarum, of two persons (Adv. Prax., xiii).
[…]
Origen [b. 185, d. c. 253-4], who is, however, inconsistent in his vocabulary, expressed the anti-Sabellian sense of Dionysius of Alexandria by calling the Son "Heteroousion".
—Bridge, J. (1910). Homoousion. In The Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.
More post
- 📝 What did C. S. Lewis base his idea of sehnsucht/joy on?
- 📝 Impact of Catholic Church Sanctions on Remarried Divorcees' Salvation?
- 📝 What KJV publishers today include the "Translators to the reader"?
- 📝 Which prophecies have definitely been fulfilled?
- 📝 Why has St. John or the three Nephites not come out in support of the LDS Church?
- 📝 Does training up a child always work out in the end?
- 📝 How can we identify, sometimes, the angel of the Lord as God if the prophets also spoke as God?
- 📝 Do the LDS believe in the Hypostatic Union?
- 📝 What is the difference between Evangelical and Protestant?
- 📝 What are the arguments that the book of Acts was written after 70 AD?
- 📝 What is the meaning of "rest in peace" ("RIP")?
- 📝 Who or what established the divine inspiration for the authors of the bible?
- 📝 Can God and Unclean Spirits dwell in the same human being at the same time?
- 📝 What are the historical arguments against a literal interpretation of Luke 22:44?
- 📝 Matthew/Luke Generations missing between Rahab and David
- 📝 Are there any bundles of subsets of the New Testament that are common?
- 📝 Does "Kehilat Bethlehem" community believe that the Law of Moses are the commandments Jesus is referring to in John 14:15?
- 📝 Does a person lose anything by just praying to God the Father all the time?
- 📝 Who decides if a verse is literal and what parts of the Bible metaphorical?
- 📝 Did the Passover Crucifixion Involve a Double Sabbath?
- 📝 Is the Genesis creation account consistent with the Big Bang theory according to Catholic theology?
- 📝 How do opponents of penal substitutionary atonement theory handle Isaiah 53?
- 📝 History of Christian Prayer
- 📝 What was the earliest Papal condemnation of slavery?
- 📝 St. Thomas Aquinas' contingency proof and LDS cosmology
- 📝 How does John Owen account for scriptures which state that justification by faith is not through the law?
- 📝 Why is Green Martyrdom green?
- 📝 How many books of the bible agreed on any Christian denomination?
- 📝 Was the Lord with whom Abraham negotiated material or Holistic?
- 📝 Which monk states that the Old Testament is about the Father and the New Testament about the Holy Ghost
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Where did substance language enter the Trinity debate?
- 📝 Where did the idea of the Trinity come from?
- 📝 Where did the trinity concept come from?
- 📝 When did Arabic enter into usage as a liturgical language among Christians?
- 📝 Where did the idiom "asking Jesus into your heart" come from?
- 📝 Where did the notion that Adam and Eve ate an APPLE come from?
- 📝 Did Saint Patrick actually explain the Trinity using a shamrock?
- 📝 Where does the Catholic tradition that Mary did not have pain giving birth to Jesus come from?
- 📝 Why did the people believe that no one would know where the Christ came from?
- 📝 Where did the "humans become angels" tradition come from?
- 📝 What is the basis for King Melchizedek actually being Jesus? Where did this idea come from?
- 📝 Where did the Young Earth Creationist doctrine originate?
- 📝 Where did the belief that Saul fell from a horse come from?
- 📝 Where did the ecclesiastical offices go?
- 📝 Where did the religious symbol of the 'halo' come from?
- 📝 From where did Mary get the attribution of "Full of Grace"?
- 📝 Where did the concept of Christians attending a church building come from?
- 📝 Where did the dates at the bottom of the pages in the Book of Mormon come from?
- 📝 Where did the idea that Cherubs were baby Angels originate?
- 📝 Where did the artistic rendering of Jesus originate?
- 📝 When and where did the Catholic tradition of first communion at 7 years old start?
- 📝 Where did the account of Veronica originate?
- 📝 Where did the idea of the inerrancy of the King James Bible come from?
- 📝 Where did the hierarchical designations of priest, cardinal, bishop, and pope come from in the Catholic church?
- 📝 Where did the Petrine title of "First Among Equals" originate?
- 📝 Where did the translators of the New World translation study the Biblical languages?
- 📝 Where and/or when did the tradition that Methuselah died seven days before the Flood (for a period of mourning) originate?
- 📝 Where did Roman Catholicism connect modern heresies with the Reformation?
- 📝 Where did Augustine say that the same fire that tortures the damned purifies the elect?
- 📝 From where did the Pearl of Great Price come and how did it become recognized as Scripture in the LDS church?