How to understand a second order Karma?
score:2
So what is the result of the action of person C?
I think it would be unusual, a supernatural ability (e.g. of the Buddha's), to be able to see/know/explain the result of kamma.
I think it's called,
"Divine eye" (dibba-cakkhu), that is, knowing others' karmic destinations
For this reason (i.e. that few people have this supernatural ability), all questions of the form "what's the precise karmic result of such-and-such action" asked on this site are pointless or unanswerable.
People can explain a little more about the doctrine of karma-in-general (e.g. here), but I think we can only give some fairly general statements from the suttas, for example that "karma is intention".
Does she even have any choice to hurt B or not hurt B?
I think people debate (or question) whether or to what extent "free will" exists -- whether people are able to choose or whether choices are predetermined -- see e.g. Predetermined future vs. Free will in Buddhism
I think the doctrine says though that if you are person C then you are heir to your own kamma.
If this continues, this whole sequence will never ever end.
I think the doctrine allows for kammic seeds which never come to fruition (which is how it can end):
Kamma and its Fruit (by Nyanaponika Thera)
Most writings on the doctrine of kamma emphasize the strict lawfulness governing kammic action, ensuring a close correspondence between our deeds and their fruits. While this emphasis is perfectly in place, there is another side to the working of kamma — a side rarely noted, but highly important. This is the modifiability of kamma, the fact that the lawfulness which governs kamma does not operate with mechanical rigidity but allows for a considerably wide range of modifications in the ripening of the fruit.
If kammic action were always to bear fruits of invariably the same magnitude, and if modification or annulment of kamma-result were excluded, liberation from the samsaric cycle of suffering would be impossible; for an inexhaustible past would ever throw up new obstructive results of unwholesome kamma.
Also I think that the doctrine tells us to the kammic principle intentionally and skilfully, e.g.:
- Intending good for good to ripen (and/or to make any small evil relatively negligible, like a lump of salt dissolved in a river)
- Intending cessation for cessation to ripen (I think, more specifically -- abandoning greed, ignorance, and aversion; abandoning self-view; and the noble eightfold path).
Upvote:1
O! Bhikkhu monks, it is volition - cetana that I call Kamma, -cetanaham bhikkhave kammam vadami
If A, B or C has an unwholesome thought or speech/action caused by an unwholesome thought, it is bad Karma. It's that simple.
An intention to harm a person is always unwholesome whether that person deserves it or not.
Upvote:1
If this continues, this whole sequence will never ever end.
That is why the sanasara is endless loop till we understand it and break it. B hurt A intentionaly and for that karma B get hurt by C intentionally or not, if C didn't someone else will, till the end of B bad karma. Another thing only the Lord Buddha is able to understand the way of karma works, all behind the scence are only understandable to Buddhas only.
Upvote:1
As a result of that karma, it happens that a person C ends up hurting person B, intentionally or unintentionally.
So what is the result of the action of person C?
If the action is done intentionally, the result for person C is future unwholesome resultants.
If the action is done unintentionally, the result for person C is no unwholesome kamma. See the Twin verses in Dhp. v1-2.
Does she even have any choice to hurt B or not hurt B?
We always have a choice whether or not to act on an intention. Person C does not have to act on the intention to harm person B. She can choose to observe that intention with mindfulness and instead cultivate insights from it.
If C hurts B intentionally does that account for bad karma, but C did in because she had to as it was B's karma?
Every action that originates in the Three Unwholesome Roots (greed, hatred and delusion) will result in future unwholesome resultants.
If this continues, this whole sequence will never ever end.
It can end. It will end if one works out ones own liberation. The Buddha did it. Many of his disciples and followers did it too. Every person has within himself or herself, the potentiality to become free from suffering, to achieve Nibbana, to become a Buddha.
Upvote:2
In Buddhism, kamma and its fruits is not a system of universal justice. It simply is cause and effect. An individual's intention is the most important thing in kamma.
If a person has evil intentions and commits evil acts, then he may end up in unhappy destinations. Even if he comes back as a human being, he may be sickly or short-lived or ugly or poor etc. Please read the rest of MN 135 for details. If based on his intentions, he harmed others, then in future, he becomes sickly. If based on his intentions, he was miserly and did not donate to others, then he may become poor in future.
According to MN 135:
The Blessed One said: "There is the case, student, where a woman or man is a killer of living beings, brutal, bloody-handed, given to killing & slaying, showing no mercy to living beings. Through having adopted & carried out such actions, on the break-up of the body, after death, he/she reappears in the plane of deprivation, the bad destination, the lower realms, hell. If, on the break-up of the body, after death — instead of reappearing in the plane of deprivation, the bad destination, the lower realms, hell — he/she comes to the human state, then he/she is short-lived wherever reborn. This is the way leading to a short life: to be a killer of living beings, brutal, bloody-handed, given to killing & slaying, showing no mercy to living beings.
"But then there is the case where a woman or man, having abandoned the killing of living beings, abstains from killing living beings, and dwells with the rod laid down, the knife laid down, scrupulous, merciful, & sympathetic for the welfare of all living beings. Through having adopted & carried out such actions, on the break-up of the body, after death, he/she reappears in a good destination, in the heavenly world. If, on the break-up of the body, after death — instead of reappearing in a good destination, in the heavenly world — he/she comes to the human state, then he/she is long-lived wherever reborn. This is the way leading to a long life: to have abandoned the killing of living beings, to abstain from killing living beings, to dwell with one's rod laid down, one's knife laid down, scrupulous, merciful, & sympathetic for the welfare of all living beings.
"There is the case where a woman or man is one who harms beings with his/her fists, with clods, with sticks, or with knives. Through having adopted & carried out such actions, on the break-up of the body, after death, he/she reappears in the plane of deprivation... If instead he/she comes to the human state, then he/she is sickly wherever reborn. This is the way leading to sickliness: to be one who harms beings with one's fists, with clods, with sticks, or with knives.
"But then there is the case where a woman or man is not one who harms beings with his/her fists, with clods, with sticks, or with knives. Through having adopted & carried out such actions, on the break-up of the body, after death, he/she reappears in a good destination... If instead he/she comes to the human state, then he/she is healthy wherever reborn. This is the way leading to health: not to be one who harms beings with one's fists, with clods, with sticks, or with knives.
However, not everything we experience is caused by kamma according to SN36.21:
"There are cases where some feelings arise based on bile... phlegm... based on internal winds... based on a combination of bodily humors... from the change of the seasons... from uneven care of the body... from harsh treatment... from the result of kamma. You yourself should know how some feelings arise from the result of kamma. Even the world is agreed on how some feelings arise from the result of kamma. So any brahmans & contemplatives who are of the doctrine & view that whatever an individual feels — pleasure, pain, neither pleasure-nor-pain — is entirely caused by what was done before — slip past what they themselves know, slip past what is agreed on by the world. Therefore I say that those brahmans & contemplatives are wrong."
So it is pointless to assume that if somebody hit you, it must be caused by you hitting someone else in the past. It may not have any kamma-related cause. In the quote above, "harsh treatment" is separated from "result of kamma". So, they are separate causes. "Uneven care of the body" and "change of seasons" are also other separate causes. So, if somebody hit you and it caused pain, then it may well be just "harsh treatment" from someone else.
How to alleviate one's karma is explained in the Lonaphala Sutta or the Discourse of the Salt Crystal.
More post
- 📝 What to do when experience is different to teaching examples?
- 📝 What is the best way to practice humility
- 📝 What is Zen, what are Zen beliefs, and why is it called Buddhism?
- 📝 Is anxiety as hell-bound as cruelty?
- 📝 Are there any Buddhist charities or organisations funding education in Buddhist studies?
- 📝 How to avoid apathy in the absence of self?
- 📝 According to buddhism, do demons exists?
- 📝 About svasaṃvedana (reflexive awareness) and having bodhicitta
- 📝 How to Determine Meditation Object
- 📝 What is the starting of Samsara?
- 📝 What is/are the cause/s of becoming "perceiveless", an unconsciouse-being?
- 📝 Did the Lord Buddha say anything about magic and fortune telling?
- 📝 Are there any Buddhist scriptures about motivation & discipline?
- 📝 The invariant law of nature which forms the basis of Buddha's Dharma and existence of universe itself
- 📝 When was the word enlightenment introduced into Theravada Buddhism?
- 📝 Samatha Meditation
- 📝 How, if at all, does karma exist in the form and formless realms?
- 📝 What would a sotapanna do?
- 📝 Is Buddhism against scientific attitude?
- 📝 Where can I find the earliest possible version of the Mahā Karuṇā Dhāraṇī ("Great Compassion Mantra")?
- 📝 Is the self like a rainbow and is it just as real?
- 📝 There is a conventional self, so is anything conventionally permanent?
- 📝 Are there any attempts to prove the eternal blissful etc. self?
- 📝 Other than physical form which characteristics define a woman?
- 📝 Hard not to control my breathing
- 📝 Could the Buddha have touched goal and gems in the 7 weeks after enlightenment
- 📝 What is the text in which the Buddha gets a migraine?
- 📝 Not-Buddhism is the highest level of Buddhism?
- 📝 Is there a set of daily reminders and daily reflections one can contemplate on?
- 📝 What should be a Buddhist's response to derogatory depictions of Buddhism?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How to understand a second order Karma?
- 📝 How to deal with bad past karma that makes my current life miserable?
- 📝 How do I make non-buddhists help understand I operate with a different view?
- 📝 How to help non-Buddhists understand a young person's desire to be ordained as a monk?
- 📝 If karma is objective, how come it's cause for "good" rebirth?
- 📝 How does the force of ones karma determine where the mind stream goes?
- 📝 What Buddhist materials explain how to understand one's irrational feelings?
- 📝 How should i understand "Stored up kamma"?
- 📝 How to understand Buddhism original dogma?
- 📝 How do you understand Ananda Sutta?
- 📝 What Buddhist materials describe how to increase the number of people with good Karma in a geographic area?
- 📝 how important is self forgiveness in karma ?
- 📝 How can we use the triple round model to understand dependent origination?
- 📝 How can you use Q&A to gain good Karma and also aid to realize liberation
- 📝 In Relation to Rebirth After Death, How is Karma any Different than Supernatural gods?
- 📝 How does Karma works?
- 📝 How to enter the second Jhana?
- 📝 How does one effectively understand & navigate through the suicide cases found in the canon?
- 📝 To hell with metta - how to understand AN4.125?
- 📝 How does one experience or understand the experience of others?
- 📝 How does one understand the elements of the Pure Octad in Sunlight?
- 📝 Different realms,Different beings,Different times - How do they understand what we are saying?
- 📝 How to understand a patient's coma status in Buddhism
- 📝 How does Karma work for an inventor who changed lives of millions?
- 📝 How bad is the karma of feeding meat to your children?
- 📝 How do the concepts of anatta, rebirth and karma coexist together?
- 📝 How to escape Karma fight
- 📝 How to intentionally move to second jhana
- 📝 A question about my karma and how it’s affecting me
- 📝 How do Buddhists who believe in a non momentary conventional self during life account for karma without enlightenment?