How do Buddhists who believe in a non momentary conventional self during life account for karma without enlightenment?
Upvote:-1
How do Buddhists who believe in a non momentary conventional self
I doubt many Buddhists would believe in a "non momentary" conventional self. I imagine most studied Buddhists would believe there can be a "momentary" conventional self.
during life account for karma without enlightenment?
Karma depends on the delusion of self. There cannot be ordinary (black &/or white) karma without self-belief.
Specifically, what happens to "my" karma when I die, if I am not enlightened and my karma has not been exhausted?
Karma will continue to reap results when the view of "I", "my" & "self" continue to exist. In the Buddha's teaching, only the false view of "I" dies. For example, MN 140 says "death" ("marana") does not occur when "I" is not conceived.
I'm not asking how to think of cause and result if the lack of self identity extends from moment to moment in this life, because then "my" karma would face a similar obstacle in this life (there being no personal identity from moment to moment means it cannot be "my" karma at all).
Sorry but the above sounds merely intellectual. If strong vexatious thoughts of "I" & "mine" continue to arise, these are personal identity.
Clearly most historical Buddhists
Buddhism became extinct in India and nearly twice became extinct in Sri Lanka. Clearly most historical Buddhists had terrible understanding of Buddhism.
believed that karma did not just exist in the suffering I cause others, but that what comes around goes around. So if my life does not, automatically without enlightenment, generate a new one, why doesn't "my" death cut off that cycle?
Sorry but SN 12.2 defines "death" as the death of "a being" ("satta"). SN 23.2 & SN 5.10 define a "satta" ("being") as merely "strong attachment", "a view", "a convention". Many many suttas say the Arahants do not "die" ("marana"). That is why a synonyn for Nibbana is The Deathless. Buddhists who believe in "rebirth" merely spin around & around in speculative views & questioning forever.
Upvote:2
Specifically, what happens to "my" karma when I die, if I am not enlightened and my karma has not been exhausted?
If one is not enlightened when death occurs, rebirth will take place. That process cannot be stopped as long as there exists greed, hatred and delusion in the mind.
So if my life does not, automatically without enlightenment, generate a new one, why doesn't "my" death cut off that cycle?
Merely dying is not enough to cut off the defilements that cause beings to be reborn. It takes hard work, effort, right view and persistence in training of the Noble Eightfold Path. As long as there exists defilements (greed, hatred and delusion) in the mind death and rebirth will continue to happen. That's a process have been going on for countless of aeons - even the Buddha said that he couldn't see a discernable beginning of the wandering in Samsara.
This process of death and rebirth can only be stopped when a being becomes enlightened. Why is that? Because enlightenment is what destroys and cuts off the root defilements that bind us to Samsara.
More post
- 📝 How is possible that monks memorised 10.000 sutras?
- 📝 Is there a contradiction in the translation of the Bhūmija Sutta?
- 📝 Life testament, illness and Buddhism
- 📝 Unchanging Awareness
- 📝 Choosing between contemplative traditions
- 📝 Is the reputation system counterproductive to Buddhist practice?
- 📝 Are these simple sentences right? They are about 4 noble truths, 3 characteristics, craving, etc
- 📝 Parents suppressing the teaching
- 📝 Why are 'eternalism' & 'annihilationism' mentioned in SN 12.17?
- 📝 Did Shakyamuni Buddha say anything in regard to fear
- 📝 So what is a Buddhist and what makes a person a Buddhist?
- 📝 Losing awareness
- 📝 Irritation due to breathing noises in dojo
- 📝 How to understand a patient's coma status in Buddhism
- 📝 What is Buddhist debate and how do I get started?
- 📝 What are the alternative titles of Thayodhamma Sutta, it's reference number, subsections where it appear in?
- 📝 Audio guided meditation recommendations?
- 📝 Where do westerners get their "Buddhist" names?
- 📝 Can Jiddu Krishnamurthy's teachings be considered Buddhist in nature?
- 📝 Are actions in computer games bad for karma?
- 📝 Was Buddha ever born as an elephant?
- 📝 Does anyone read the part 2 of Nagarjuna's karika as an argument about infinite divisibility?
- 📝 What is appropriate usage of medicines that are intoxicating?
- 📝 Would a stream enterer no longer need the "I am the owner and heir of my karma" reflection?
- 📝 Stages of the Bardo
- 📝 How does one explain consistency within phenomena if the mind generates phenomena?
- 📝 Disclosing Spiritual Experiences
- 📝 Was Vipassana discovered by the Buddha (Siddhartha)?
- 📝 What is the difference between papanca and sankhara, and in particular citta-sankhara?
- 📝 Uncertainty vs Cause and Effect
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How do Buddhists who believe in a non momentary conventional self during life account for karma without enlightenment?
- 📝 How is it wrong to believe that a self exists, or that it doesn't?
- 📝 How do Buddhists reconcile "Anatta" with Buddha supporting the existence of the Self in the Mahayana Mahaparininirvana Sutra?
- 📝 Why is speaking about the conventional self in this life ok, but speaking about the conventional self in past and future lives forbidden?
- 📝 If Buddhists believe that life is just suffering why don't they just kill themselves?
- 📝 How do Buddhists express condolences?
- 📝 How should Buddhists handle prayer requests?
- 📝 How do you tell a 4-year-old who the Buddha was?
- 📝 Why do Buddhists believe there is no creator?
- 📝 How to deal with bad past karma that makes my current life miserable?
- 📝 How concerned should Buddhists be with the actions of others?
- 📝 How does one practice mindfulness during thinking - e.g. thinking about how to solve a problem?
- 📝 Does being in a commited married life make it impossible to attain Nirvana? If not, how can one progress towards Nirvana?
- 📝 Meditation, compassion: How to handle people who dominate you in the office?
- 📝 Do Buddhists believe in gods?
- 📝 How much is the minimal time for practicing Vipassana in daily life for achieving better mindfulness?
- 📝 How to deal with body pain during meditation?
- 📝 How should a Buddhist approach honoring parents who abused them?
- 📝 Why do Buddhists believe that the Buddha was enlightened, despite that he claimed it himself?
- 📝 How to keep balance in the thin line between non attachment to reputation and "not caring about anything"
- 📝 How do you trade a career for a life geared toward becoming awakened?
- 📝 How do Buddhists justify or explain that monks and/or temples amass and use wealth?
- 📝 How do Buddhists use mudras?
- 📝 Are there reliable accounts of Buddhists who have remembered past lives?
- 📝 In a Buddhist perspective how do we recall memories of this life and beyond?
- 📝 How are Buddhists supposed to spread Buddhism?
- 📝 Without an enduring quid between lifes, how to explain past life recalling?
- 📝 How to discipline self to practice meditation everyday?
- 📝 How can the idea of reincarnation be true if all the information of who we are is already destroyed
- 📝 How do Buddhists handle mental illness such as depression or bipolar disorder?