What does Bhikkhu Bodhi mean by "mind objects"?
Upvote:1
BB's MN 148 is from 1995, appearing to be the completion of Bhikkhu Nanamoli's work. Here, I assume Bhikkhu Nanamoli correctly translated the Pali 'dhamme' as 'mind objects', which means sense objects that can only be known/sensed/contacted by the mind (mano; manañca) sense base. These mind objects include:
- Feelings (vedana)
- Perceptions (sanna)
- Mental formations (sankhara; emotions & thoughts)
- Consciousness itself
- Insight knowledges/laws of nature
- Liberation
- Nibbana
In short, the word 'dhamme' in Pali is used because it includes objects apart from mental phenomena (nama-dhamma). It also includes object that are not mental phenomena, such as the Laws of Nature and Nibbana. Ud 8.1 says Nibbana is an 'ayatana' ('sense object'; translated at the link as 'sphere'). The Truth/Laws of Nature are described in SN 12.20 & AN 3.136.
Unfortunately, based on references in his footnotes to discussions with Ajahn Brahmali, it appears BB later came under the insidious influence of the Ajahn Brahm cult, and in his later translations translated 'dhamme' as 'mental phenomena'. Similar to Sujato's "thoughts" & Thanissaro's "ideas", this later translation is completely wrong.
The Buddha clearly distinguished 'sankhara' ('conditional things') from 'dhamma' ('things'), as shown in AN 3.136. If 'dhamme' in MN 148 only means thoughts, ideas or mental phenomena, then what is the perception of Truth, such as the perception of conditionality, impermanence, unsatisfactoriness, not-self, emptiness, liberation & Nibbana? Are these insight knowledges thoughts, ideas & mental phenomena? For example, is the impermanence of the breathing a thought? Is a leaf falling off a tree a thought? Is the Earth rotating around the sun a thought?
To conclude, reiterating AN 3.136, the following verse from the Dhammapada is so crucial to understand. Here, 'dhamma' is distinguished from 'sankhara' because 'dhamma' includes Truth, the fixed Laws of Nature, Nibbana, etc.
"All conditioned things (sankhara) are impermanent" — when one sees this with wisdom, one turns away from suffering. This is the path to purification.
"All conditioned things (sankhara) are unsatisfactory" — when one sees this with wisdom, one turns away from suffering. This is the path to purification.
"All things (dhamma) are not-self" — when one sees this with wisdom, one turns away from suffering. This is the path to purification.
Thus when one sees with wisdom that all things (dhamma) are not-self, this seeing is performed by the mind sense base and the not-self seen is a mind object.
Upvote:1
"Dhamma" in this context is defined in the New Concise Pali English Dictionary as:
mental constructs, concepts, ideas, what is to be cognized by the mind, that which is the object of mental activity
The broadest sense of "dhamma" in the context of the quoted passage is "what is to be cognized by the mind". This is the same as "mind object".
Nibbana is not a thought or idea or concept. But it can be cognized by the mind, which is free from suffering.
Of course, Nibbana as a philosophical concept, is a concept or idea of the mind, but it's different from the actual Nibbana. This too can be cognized by the mind.
The five hindrances (e.g. sloth and torpor) are not thoughts or ideas. They are complex states of mind. But they can be cognized by the mind.
Of course, the five hindrances as a philosophical concept, is a concept or idea of the mind, but it's different from the actual five hindrances. This too can be cognized by the mind.
More post
- 📝 Is sky burial ritual inhumane and if not what is the reason for doing it?
- 📝 Popular culture portrayal of Buddha statues
- 📝 Where is careless attention (ayonisomanasikāro) in Dependent Origination?
- 📝 Which buddhist traditions use silent visual applause, instead of clapping, to show appreciation and what is the origin of this practice?
- 📝 What is the Avatamsaka Sutra about?
- 📝 Are there Theravada practitioners that aspire to be Buddhas?
- 📝 Intention and Karma
- 📝 11th Soul - last lessons
- 📝 Should you meditate with a timer?
- 📝 Emptiness in Theravada and Mahayana
- 📝 What is Buddhism (in a nutshell)?
- 📝 What would Buddha advise to farewell when one of your parents died?
- 📝 Vipassana report on breathing
- 📝 what is the difference between Anapanasati and the Satipatthana
- 📝 What is it that is re-incarnated ?
- 📝 Walking bare foot?
- 📝 Meditation through clearing the mind of all thoughts
- 📝 Word that refers to a "second chance" or redemption?
- 📝 Subjectivity Along the Buddhist Path
- 📝 What do buddhists do in a situation of war where all able-bodied men must become soldiers?
- 📝 Sensory Deprivation tank
- 📝 Who said "life is suffering"?
- 📝 Is there any benefit in learning Pali or Sanskrit?
- 📝 Establishing a shrine in the bedroom?
- 📝 How Walking meditation happen
- 📝 Thought-sending in Tibetan Buddhism and other traditions
- 📝 Retaining courage during mediation
- 📝 Why Alaya Vinnana and Manas is not supported in Theravada?
- 📝 References for not receiving alms in exchange for Dhamma teaching
- 📝 Becoming a monk and having to give up electronic devices
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What does Bhikkhu Bodhi mean by "mind objects"?
- 📝 What does it mean in Bhikkhu Bodhi's *Life of the Buddha* when he describes Maha Maya as being possessed of the five kāmaguṇa
- 📝 What does the word Bodhi mean etymologically?
- 📝 What does it mean to 'advert' to the factors of jhana after emerging from jhana?
- 📝 What does the Buddha mean by this quote? "There is no punishment for anger. It is the anger which will punish you."
- 📝 What does "Namaste" mean in Buddhism context and why is it even associated with Buddhism?
- 📝 What does it mean to find a teacher?
- 📝 What does 'passing away of dhamma' mean in Satipatthana sutta?
- 📝 What does the word "world" mean in the Buddhist context?
- 📝 What does it mean by perfect morality?
- 📝 What does "joy" mean in the phrase "dharma gate of great ease and joy"
- 📝 What does 'awareness of the flow' mean
- 📝 What does it mean to be upright?
- 📝 What does Samsara mean to Buddhists? How is it meaningful?
- 📝 What does "heard" mean in "I allow fish and meat that is pure in three respects: One has not seen, heard, or suspected..."
- 📝 What does "abandoned for no future renewed existence" mean in this sutta?
- 📝 What does "ease" mean in the phrase "dharma gate of ease and joy"?
- 📝 What does "Nothing like anything" mean according to Buddism?
- 📝 What does it mean by 'All beings have a Buddha nature'?
- 📝 What does 'Ignorance' mean in Dependent Co-Arising?
- 📝 What does random Images flashing during mediation mean ,if anything at all?
- 📝 What does "becoming" mean in the phrase "the 10 fetters of becoming"?
- 📝 What does celestial mean in 'celestial bodhisattva'
- 📝 What does pari-mukha mean in 16 APS anapana sati?
- 📝 What does "has students" and "has teacher" mean in this sutta?
- 📝 What does "break-up of the body after death" mean in the suttas?
- 📝 Visions of Hell Realm in Contemplation- What does it mean
- 📝 What does "sandhāvitvā saṃsaritvā" mean in AN 9.12?
- 📝 What does Buddha mean with '' to not sacrifice one's life for another' (Dhp 166)?
- 📝 What does Buddhism literature and tradition say about transgender folks?