In the wheel of life, how can death be a condition for ignorance?
score:5
Bhava-chakra, the wheel of life, or, as I would translate it, "the wheel of individuation" is a relatively late depiction of the 12 Nidanas. In the suttas of Pali Canon, the nidanas are usually presented as a list, that is reviewed both in forward as well as in reverse direction -- but never (to my knowledge!) as an infinite loop.
If you read the wheel clock-wise, the 12 nidanas are:
avidya -> samskara -> vijnana -> nama-rupa -> six ayatana -> phassa -> vedana -> tanha -> upadana -> bhava -> jati -> jaramarana & dukkha
Although the interpretation of the wheel as depicting the cycle of death-and-rebirth is accepted by most schools, according to Triyana framework it represents the basic/literal ("hinayana") level of understanding.
Instead, some instructors, including Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche, taught twelve nidanas as a process of gradual individuation, or emerging and hardening of the illusory ego.
In this line of thinking, avidya is the innate ignorance, samskaras are the arbitrary imprints of sensory stimulation, vijnana is inductive intelligence born from the imprints, nama-rupa are inductively postulated external objects, six ayatanas are the implied "windows" onto the world, phassa is a subjective experience of contact with the postulated objects, vedana is a sensation attributed to the contact, tanha is an obsessive replay of the contact and sensation, upadana is feeding the obsession by making its object one's goal, bhava is becoming the "this" of here-and-now, dependently-co-arisen with the twofold "that" of space-and-time, jati is identifying with a living organism, and jaramarana is experiencing the organism's perspective culminating in death.
(Because the list shows subjective experience, not an objective physical process, the physical birth is not shown, but if it were, it would fit right before Ignorance. The Birth that is shown, is not a physical birth, but conceptual (subjective) assumption that one is an individual living organism.)
Although 12 nidanas explained this way describe subjective experience of one sentient being, which begins with physical birth and ends with death, we could say that after death the cycle logically "restarts" from scratch, again starting from ignorance, progressing through individuation, and culminating in death of another "being" and so forth indefinitely.
To be sure, objectively there is no cycle, beings arise and cease asynchronously, but in some sense we could say that death of a (unenlightened) being is a return to innate ignorance.
@ChrisW found a tremendously elegant quote in Wikipedia:
When the cessation of the continuity of experience occurs, we speak of death. It is the total breakdown and dissolution of experience and experiencer. The process of disintegration, destructuring, and entropic scattering yields a nexus of vibratory murkiness which is the condition of avidyΔ, the first motif. Thus the entire structure of patterning feeds back on itself.
Upvote:0
In the original Pali scriptures, death is a condition for suffering (rather than for ignorance). For example, ordinarily, when a person you love dies, you suffer. This is why death is a condition for suffering. Such 'death' only causes suffering when you are attached to the object & have established (by becoming) a sense of personal identity ('birth') with the deceased object.
If you do not learn from that experience of suffering then ignorance will continue. If you do not learn, you will keep attaching to impermanent objects with some ignorant expectation those objects have permanence.
But if you learn, as stated in the Upanisa Sutta: "suffering is the supporting condition for faith", which then leads to enlightenment.
Ignorance is the supporting condition for formations, formations are the supporting condition for consciousness, consciousness is the supporting condition for mentality-materiality, mentality-materiality is the supporting condition for the sixfold sense base, the sixfold sense base is the supporting condition for contact, contact is the supporting condition for feeling, feeling is the supporting condition for craving, craving is the supporting condition for clinging, clinging is the supporting condition for existence, existence is the supporting condition for birth, birth is the supporting condition for suffering, suffering is the supporting condition for faith, faith is the supporting condition for joy, joy is the supporting condition for rapture, rapture is the supporting condition for tranquillity, tranquillity is the supporting condition for happiness, happiness is the supporting condition for concentration, concentration is the supporting condition for the knowledge and vision of things as they really are, the knowledge and vision of things as they really are is the supporting condition for disenchantment, disenchantment is the supporting condition for dispassion, dispassion is the supporting condition for emancipation, and emancipation is the supporting condition for the knowledge of the destruction (of the cankers).
Upanisa Sutta
The scriptures describe 'death' as the death of 'beings' ('satta'). 'Beings' is a mental state or idea.
Whatever deceasing, passing away, breaking up, disappearance, dying, death, completion of time, break up of the aggregates, casting off of the body, interruption in the life faculty of the various beings in this or that group of beings, that is called death.
SN 12.2
~~~~
Any desire, passion, delight or craving for form, feeling...consciousness, Radha: when one is caught up there, tied up there, one is said to be 'a being.'
Satta Sutta
~~~
Mara, why now do you assume 'a being'? Have you grasped a view? This is a heap of sheer constructions: Here no being is found.
Just as, with an assemblage of parts, The word 'chariot' is used, So, when the aggregates are present, There's the convention 'a being.'
It's only suffering that comes to be, Suffering that stands and falls away. Nothing but suffering comes to be, Nothing but suffering ceases.
Upvote:2
I am answering from the Theravada standpoint. (hoping this also will add some value)
Death is:
- breaking of the aggregates due to decay or some accident, end of sustainable life span
Rebirth:
- reformation of the aggregates
As long as the wheel of dhamma is turning, each time the aggregates breakup in one body it forms in another and rebirth. Even in this life the argeragers are arising and passing away. At death the aggregates pass away in this body but arises again in another body.
Eliminating ignorance causes the links in this cycle to break.You are not adding fuel to the fabrication process. Once this life ends there is no power for the aggregates to form in another body. So there are no more rebirths. If there is no rebirth there is not death or any of the calamities that follow birth.
Upvote:2
It is taught by some teachers (if not many) the chain of dependent origination is divided into 3 lifetimes: past, present, and future. However, because each part describes a single lifetime, I think each part is simply one of 3 ways we can look at our present experience.
We can see our present experience in the sense that our ignorance gives rise to karmically potent volitional formations. Or, we can go deeper and see the conditioned nature of our experience in terms of the aggregates and how ignorance leads to craving (and eventually becoming) after feeling. Or, we can look at our present experience in terms of birth, aging, sickness, and death (as suffering). I think the Buddha wanted us to use all 3 ways as different tools for investigation of ignorance.
This would mean that the dependent chain of origination taught by the Buddha refers to the conditioning process of a being fettered by ignorance. In that case, it would also be justified to say that the chain refers to 3 different life times because the "present" life time contains the teaching of the aggregates, which are present (to my understanding) for all beings, enlightened and unenlightened, whereas the "past" and "future" lifetimes concern the unenlightened being (since enlightened beings aren't ignorant, they don't create karma; birth, aging, sickness, and death refer to dukkha and future rebirth which is not applicable present for the enlightened being).
More post
- π Nose Object Problems
- π Anicca, dukkha, Buddhism and depressive nihilism
- π What does "break-up of the body after death" mean in the suttas?
- π Working with cycles in meditation
- π Does levitation really exist?
- π Other people may misinterpret my "calming my mind"
- π How is Gedhun Choekyi Nyima connected to the Buddhist community?
- π What is tathata?
- π Does any sutta talk about the right conditions for teaching the Dhamma?
- π What is Zen, what are Zen beliefs, and why is it called Buddhism?
- π Truth Table of Buddism/Four fold logic?
- π How does the Dhamma reconcile slavery?
- π Are the positive qualities of enlightenment ultimate or conventional realities?
- π Thought-sending in Tibetan Buddhism and other traditions
- π How does metta sutra develop loving kindness
- π How can I escape the suffering of losing my father?
- π The fourth path to attaining arahantship
- π Morally unwholesome deeds knowing the consequences but without unwholesome intentions
- π What is the difference between Yogacara Buddhism and Idealism?
- π What is meant by "a profound knowledge of words" in dhp 352?
- π Does anybody knows origin and reference Buddha teaches a bossy & angry the seven kinds of wifes
- π Did the Buddha ever 'thunder' during a Fire Sermon?
- π What are good resources to study the historic evolution and comparative studies of Abhidhamma
- π Is the 'best meditation you do' the meditation you do?
- π Compulsive desire to correct others
- π Cyclical time in Buddhism
- π Question about the PitΔpΕ«trasamΔgama-sΕ«tra
- π Bodhisattva wisdom vs. Arhat Wisdom
- π Taking Vinaya as a measure of the weight of kamma?
- π Which aggregate (khandha) is or generates 'suffering'?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π In the wheel of life, how can death be a condition for ignorance?
- π How can Name-and-form be the cause and condition for the manifestation of the consciousness aggregate?
- π How much is the minimal time for practicing Vipassana in daily life for achieving better mindfulness?
- π What exactly are the last two of the Arupa Jhanas? How can we transcend them and for what?
- π How can I stop thinking about the clock when meditating? I meditate for 30 minutes every day
- π How can I stop feeling guilty that Iβve taken the lives of so many insects in my life unintentionally
- π How can I live life knowing other people work so hard for so little and people and animals suffer
- π How can I assess the quality of a local Buddhist group?
- π How can I remove my desire for a relationship/girlfriend?
- π Can environmental degradation be used as a justification for the culling of an invasive alien species?
- π Does being in a commited married life make it impossible to attain Nirvana? If not, how can one progress towards Nirvana?
- π How can I build up to being able to get into the full lotus position?
- π How can you see suffering in the breath?
- π If a Buddhist believes lay life is not ideal for the practice, why does he or she continue?
- π How do you trade a career for a life geared toward becoming awakened?
- π Can the Buddhism.SE site function as "the Sangha" for me?
- π How can a lay person approach the learning process of Buddhism?
- π How can one define luxurious beds and seats in the eighth precept?
- π Looking for a book that covers the biography of the Buddha's life
- π How does kamma create a new set of aggregates for a rebirth; how do the mechanics of this process work?
- π How can the idea of reincarnation be true if all the information of who we are is already destroyed
- π How can I make amends with the one I wronged?
- π If someone was an Once-returner in last life how can he know that ?
- π How to prevent the development of insight to become ignorance anew?
- π How we can develop metta for terrorists?
- π The needs of the same human being may differ at different stages of life. Can there be one Dharma for all stages?
- π How can you use daily walks for spiritual growth in Diamond Way Buddhism?
- π How can I escape the suffering of losing my father?
- π Can a buddhist enjoy life - what are the limitations and restrictions
- π How should a theravada centre approach the lay people for support?