Can straight samatha ever lead to enlightenment?
Upvote:2
If I'm not mistaken, Samatha alone leads to attainment of Jhanas. With perfection in certain levels of Jhanas, one could get reborn in certain Brahma worlds, which by itself is a good thing, but as per Lanka's answer, it doesn't lead to enlightenment.
From here:
A group of laypeople who had studied the Abhidhamma together came to Ajaan Fuang to try out his version of mental training, but when he told them to sit, close their eyes, and focus on the breath, they immediately backed off, saying that they didn't want to practice concentration, for fear that they'd get stuck on jhana and end up being reborn in the Brahma worlds. He responded, "What's there to be afraid of? Even non-returners are reborn in the Brahma worlds. At any rate, being reborn in the Brahma worlds is better than being reborn as a dog."
Upvote:7
If you are asking about whether Samatha meditation alone can lead to enlightenment the answer is no.
Why is that?
In Vipassana meditation you have ultimate reality as your object of meditation. By having reality as your object you achieve insight into how reality functions i.e. the 3 signs of existence; anicca, dukkha, anatta. When penetrating into reality one can attain enlightenment through realizising one of these signs.
When one is doing Samatha meditation alone one can only gain tranquility i.e. a strong concentration and the jhanas. One cannot any achieve insights into reality and therefore not become enlightened. That is because in samatha meditation one does not have ultimate reality as an object. Instead one has a concept as an object e.g. one of the 10 kasinas. One is trying to keep that object static by keeping attention on the object through the means of applied and sustained thought.
You can think about it in another way. Lets say you had a big stone in front you and you want to carve out a figure from that stone. To do that you need an instrument, a tool. Concentration is your tool and the stone is reality.
In order for you to be able to carve into the stone you need the tool to be sharp. In other words you need to sharpen your tool. That is where samatha meditation is used. You use samatha meditation to train and sharpen your concentration so that you can use concentration as a tool to carve/penetrate into reality and then gain insights into how reality functions.
So back to the stone. If you only sharpen your tool will that ever lead you to enlightenment?
No its not possible. Samatha meditation is like that sharpening. By doing samatha meditation you are only making your tool sharper, better and more precise but you are never actually applying that tool to the stone. You are never actually carving the stone.
That is why samatha meditation alone cannot lead you to enlightenment.
Lanka
More post
- 📝 Should I do reflection before eating if I don't plan to keep it
- 📝 Intensifying sensations during meditation after switching to an Ayuverdic lifestyle
- 📝 Conversions and former bad deeds
- 📝 What is rhys david dictionary's license for now?
- 📝 How do Buddhists that think of karma figuratively do so about rebirth?
- 📝 How to avoid doing things that suck the energy out of you?
- 📝 Is karma of arms giving depends on the reciever?
- 📝 Are Charnel Grounds still a thing?
- 📝 Why does my mind naturally wander?
- 📝 Regarding mindfulness during practice
- 📝 Did the Buddha discourage antropomorphic representations of himself?
- 📝 Questions on Attachment, Entertainment and Pleasure
- 📝 Are there any differences in karma?
- 📝 How to deal with our aversions & judgements?
- 📝 A question about my karma and how it’s affecting me
- 📝 What is the mean of 'samma ditti' in Ariya-Ashtanga Marga?
- 📝 What are the requirements in order to happen a complete sin?
- 📝 In Vipassana meditation - How long does one keep watching an object?
- 📝 How to have a relationship
- 📝 Who said 'if you are too busy meditate for two hours'?
- 📝 What does Bhikkhu Bodhi mean by "mind objects"?
- 📝 Observing the breath vs Pranayama
- 📝 How to inculcate metta in me?
- 📝 Fathersday - how would a western disciple of the Buddha make use of this fest?
- 📝 How do you trade a career for a life geared toward becoming awakened?
- 📝 Where and what to study - Buddhist compassion and business communication
- 📝 Looking for sutta about purification of fish, turtles, etc
- 📝 What is the different between Nirodha Samapatti and Phala Samapatti?
- 📝 Union with Brahma, or company of Brahma?
- 📝 Monks precepts - Not to teach dhamma to women and not to recite dhamma in pali with laymen?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Can straight samatha ever lead to enlightenment?
- 📝 Can the Buddha ever be a woman?
- 📝 What determines whether a style of meditation can or cannot lead to insight?
- 📝 Can the substantiality of phenomena ever be conclusively ruled out through Buddhist practice?
- 📝 Can contemplation of the four noble truths lead to penetration of them?
- 📝 Can Buddhism lead to eternal happiness?
- 📝 Can Buddhist practice lead to pure consciousness experiences?
- 📝 had an episode of psychosis - can I ever become a monk?
- 📝 Can you skip the 7 purifications and gain straight insight into phenomenon?
- 📝 Can Cyborg/ Trans-human reach enlightenment? When enlightenment is depended on a Human Body
- 📝 Can one become so sensitive by an enlightenment that one can't have people near/around you?
- 📝 Can someone give references of the four stages of enlightenment in the four major Nikayas?
- 📝 Can the same kamma cetana and action lead to somewhat different future physical consequences (the physical aspect of the kamma-vipaka)
- 📝 Is Enlightenment a momentum with a continuum or can have regressions?
- 📝 Can Meditation lead to Suicide?
- 📝 I only know that I will know nothing: can that ever have any currency for Buddhists?
- 📝 If every bad event is because of karma, how can anyone ever murder an arhat or buddha?
- 📝 Can (an) Urban-Dhamma lead to path, fruits and liberation?
- 📝 Can one reach enlightenment if they need to care about the wellbeing of another?
- 📝 Can trying to control the mind also lead to attachment?
- 📝 Can open monitoring meditation lead to states of Jhana?
- 📝 If there is no soul, how can there be rebirth?
- 📝 What exactly differentiates Vipassana from Samatha meditation?
- 📝 Lust - How Can it be Overcome?
- 📝 Where is the Buddha quoted as saying do not believe anything I say until you can prove it by yourself?
- 📝 How can I assess the quality of a local Buddhist group?
- 📝 Can or should a Buddhist defend themselves physically?
- 📝 Can Buddhists be good workplace leaders?
- 📝 Is Enlightenment a misleading ideal?
- 📝 Can you attain stream entry without meditation?