Intent and Karmic benefit
score:2
While the act of saving someone's life does bring great overall benefits to the person's future lives, his intent does influence the orientation of such wholesome rewards. For example, a person performing the act with the intent toward relinquishment and liberation will receive an outcome conducive toward that direction, while another performing the same act, but with the intent of gaining worldly rewards, hence would also get positive outcomes, though oriented towards more of a mundane worldly kind of merits.
Upvote:1
The Pali scripture says "kamma is intention"
Intention, I tell you, is kamma. Intending, one does kamma by way of body, speech & intellect.
Therefore, intention born of greed will not be the same as intention born of good-will.
Bhikkhus, a god, a human or any other good state would not be evident from actions born of greed, hate and delusion. Yet, bhikkhus, from actions born of greed, hate and delusion a hellish being, an animal birth a ghostly birth or some other bad state would be evident.
AN 6.39
Upvote:1
The intent is certainly the most important thing for karma.
Let's use giving gifts as an example.
There are eight reasons why one may give gifts.
“Bhikkhus, there are these eight grounds for giving. What eight? (1) One gives a gift from desire. (2) One gives a gift from hatred. (3) One gives a gift from delusion. (4) One gives a gift from fear. (5) One gives a gift, thinking: ‘Giving was practiced before by my father and forefathers; I should not abandon this ancient family custom.’ (6) One gives a gift, thinking: ‘Having given this gift, with the breakup of the body, after death, I will be reborn in a good destination, in a heavenly world.’ (7) One gives a gift, thinking: ‘When I am giving this gift my mind becomes placid, and elation and joy arise.’ (8) One gives a gift for the purpose of ornamenting the mind, equipping the mind. These are the eight grounds for giving.”
AN 8.33
All eight are not equal.
Of the eight listed, the last one, which is ornamenting the mind or adorning the mind, is the highest reason with the highest benefit.
Please see this answer for details on what is meant by "ornamenting" or "adorning" the mind.
“Yes, Sariputta, there would be the case where a person gives a gift of a certain sort and it does not bear great fruit or great benefit, whereas another person gives a gift of the same sort and it bears great fruit and great benefit. .......
“Having given this gift seeking his own profit—with a mind attached [to the reward], seeking to store up for himself, [with the thought], ‘I’ll enjoy this after death’—on the break-up of the body, after death, he reappears in the company of the Four Great Kings. Then, having exhausted that action, that power, that status, that sovereignty, he is a returner, coming back to this world. ......
“—but with the thought, ‘This is an ornament for the mind, a support for the mind’—on the break-up of the body, after death, he reappears in the company of Brahma’s Retinue. Then, having exhausted that action, that power, that status, that sovereignty, he is a non-returner. He does not come back to this world.
“This, Sariputta, is the cause, this is the reason, why a person gives a gift of a certain sort and it does not bear great fruit or great benefit, whereas another person gives a gift of the same sort and it bears great fruit and great benefit.”
AN 7.52
Upvote:1
No the two are different in intent and what that intent does to you.
When you save someone with the intent of saving that person, that act is an act of compassion. Its an act you performed for the benefit of the other person. Not to accrue something for you. When you do such an act that Karma does little or no contribution to reinforce that the saknkna (signal) of yourself. Thus, such an act of altruism does not contribute to you building 'sakhkhaya dhitti' (the mistake of taking the process of living as a person - in short: 'I').
When you do the same act with an expectation on your mind, that act reinforces the concept of 'self' in you.
Say you saved person X, that means;
- You are the savior of X
- X exists
- X exists as part of the existing World
- If X was Saved by me, then I exist
- Because World exists and I perceive it, I exist
At the core of it, the effort is to reinforce yourself that 'you' exist. This is quite dangerous for the practicing Buddhist. This is why, practicing Buddhists perform their acts without any expectations or returns. They are trying to see through the process which we simply take for-grant as 'myself'. Anything that reinforces it, is thought of as a hindrance to Nirvana.
More post
- 📝 Helping Others Who Still Need to Suffer due to karma
- 📝 Shamata and vipassana - loss of willpower
- 📝 should i consider this as a hindrance in my practice
- 📝 Sanskrit and Pali roots
- 📝 Why did physical representations of the Buddha only start to appear a few centuries after his death?
- 📝 Is Nirvana eternal?
- 📝 Buddhist deathbed advice
- 📝 Unnecessarily Complicated Analysis of Anapanasati
- 📝 What is the exact difference between samatha and passadha?
- 📝 Then where did the concept of "rebirth" come from?
- 📝 Software programming/Art and Buddhist Practice - Pursuing creative activity
- 📝 How come movies/video games decrease the motivation to do buddhist practises?
- 📝 Why do the scriptures employ so much repetition?
- 📝 Doubt and Criticism
- 📝 Samatha, Vipassana, Shikantaza scientifically compared?
- 📝 To ordain in the west or in Asia?
- 📝 Reference request: Where is this this story about a pair of shoes, a stupa, and virtuous actions?
- 📝 In what ways you advance on the path ?
- 📝 Developing Positive Qualities and Diminishing Negative Qualities
- 📝 According to Buddhism , who achieves Nirvana?
- 📝 Questions about meditation
- 📝 If Buddhas don't feel bliss, what is the purpose of attaining nirvana?
- 📝 Meditation and body scan
- 📝 Justice through soul-reincarnation
- 📝 What are the three marks of existence?
- 📝 How does the craving lead to lust, hatred and delusion?
- 📝 How is white lie damaging?
- 📝 How can one apply the skills developed through Vipassana meditation to overcome FMO/PMO (fantasy, p**n, masturbation, o*g**m) addiction?
- 📝 Im making no progress on meditation
- 📝 Permanent brain damage can cause someone to loose their Arihathness?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Intent and Karmic benefit
- 📝 Desperate for help about intent and my fears
- 📝 There is no benefit and there is no intrinsic positive nature in a pleasant sensation
- 📝 Mercy killing (not assisted suicide) and the ramifications of the karmic action
- 📝 Is killing vermin and insects justifiable?
- 📝 What are the differences between vipassana and mindfulness meditation?
- 📝 Relationship with bad parents (kamma and issues)
- 📝 Are Vajrayana and Tibetan Buddhism the same thing?
- 📝 Comparison of Nirvana, Tao and Brahman/Atma
- 📝 How to deal with people and handle rude language?
- 📝 As a Buddhist with a Muslim family, community, and background... how do you integrate/cope?
- 📝 How concentrated is access concentration and how would one recognise it?
- 📝 How are 'conceit' and 'identity-view' not the same?
- 📝 Meditation and 'not trying to change anything'
- 📝 How do I slow down and start living according to my values? How do I change the direction of my life?
- 📝 Does studying mathematics or science lead to a practitioner of Buddhism acquiring wrong philosophical views and mental afflictions?
- 📝 How compatible are the beliefs of atheists and Buddhism?
- 📝 Strange feelings after meditation and mindfulness practice?
- 📝 Is there any benefit in learning Pali or Sanskrit?
- 📝 What is the difference between craving and clinging?
- 📝 What are the differences/similarities in the concept of faith as used in Buddhism and Christianity?
- 📝 What's Buddhism view on choice, choicelesness and causality?
- 📝 Does meditation increase productivity for software developers and related professions?
- 📝 Do Buddhism and Atheism contradict each other?
- 📝 What is the difference between rebirth and reincarnation?
- 📝 Buddhist view on Art and being an Artist
- 📝 Found items and the Second Precept
- 📝 Attachment is a poison. Why is attachment to the Buddha and to Buddhist philosophy not a problem?
- 📝 What is the difference between relative and absolute truth in Buddhist philosophy?
- 📝 Secular Buddhism and Suicide