Logic vs Karmic principles
Upvote:3
The answer for this comes in the Acela Sutta (although this quote comes from here). Of course, the question was phrased differently by Kassapa, but the essence of the question is the same.
Again, when the Buddha was asked by the naked ascetic Kassapa whether suffering was of one's own making or of another's or both or neither, the Buddha replied "Do not put it like that." When asked whether there was no suffering or whether the Buddha neither knew nor saw it, the Buddha replied that there was, and that he both knew and saw it. He then said "Kassapa, if one asserts that 'He who makes (it) feels (it): being one existent from the beginning, his suffering is of his own making,' then one arrives at eternalism. But if one asserts that one makes (it), another feels (it); being one existent crushed out by feeling, his suffering is of another's making,' then one arrives at annihilationism. Instead of resorting to either extreme a Tathaagata teaches the Dhamma by the middle way (by dependent origination)".
The second useful sutta is the Acintita Sutta which states that the precise working out of karma cannot be conjectured:
"The [precise working out of the] results of kamma is an unconjecturable that is not to be conjectured about, that would bring madness & vexation to anyone who conjectured about it.
The third useful quote below comes from the Sivaka Sutta, teaching that not everything we experience in life is due to karma. Some times it's due to the weather or indigestion etc.
As he was sitting there, he said to the Blessed One, "Master Gotama, there are some brahmans & contemplatives who are of this doctrine, this view: Whatever an individual feels — pleasure, pain, neither-pleasure-nor-pain — is entirely caused by what was done before. Now what does Master Gotama say to that?"
[The Buddha:] "There are cases where some feelings arise based on bile. You yourself should know how some feelings arise based on bile. Even the world is agreed on how some feelings arise based on bile. So any brahmans & contemplatives who are of the doctrine & view that whatever an individual feels — pleasure, pain, neither-pleasure-nor-pain — is entirely caused by what was done before — slip past what they themselves know, slip past what is agreed on by the world. Therefore I say that those brahmans & contemplatives are wrong."
"There are cases where some feelings arise based on phlegm... based on internal winds... based on a combination of bodily humors... from the change of the seasons... from uneven care of the body... from harsh treatment... from the result of kamma. You yourself should know how some feelings arise from the result of kamma. Even the world is agreed on how some feelings arise from the result of kamma. So any brahmans & contemplatives who are of the doctrine & view that whatever an individual feels — pleasure, pain, neither pleasure-nor-pain — is entirely caused by what was done before — slip past what they themselves know, slip past what is agreed on by the world. Therefore I say that those brahmans & contemplatives are wrong."
More post
- 📝 What must be done before rebirth in the hell realms becomes inevitable?
- 📝 What are the 10 Samadhis of the Avatamsaka Sutra?
- 📝 Resemblance between bhanga and jhana
- 📝 Husband and wife for hundreds of times of consecutive rebirth. How?
- 📝 What is opinion of Nichiren Buddhism on the concept of a Creator or Supreme Being?
- 📝 How can someone integrate the Buddhist philosophy on life's purpose into daily life?
- 📝 Cause and effect
- 📝 How to Practice Vipassana?
- 📝 For what reason did the Dali Lama's traditional daily schedule have washing before meditation?
- 📝 Is it possible to exercise Metta to all or is Metta only a mental state only? If so how does one act to remain dispassionate?
- 📝 Five tricks to avoid unwholesome kamma
- 📝 Visual representation of mind and kamma
- 📝 Are there reliable accounts of Buddhists who have remembered past lives?
- 📝 Did the Buddha work with teachers from other spiritual traditions?
- 📝 What is the Difference between Desire and Compulsion?
- 📝 Did Ledi Sayadaw teach that Vipassanā should be practised by observing bodily sensations with equanimity?
- 📝 What is the history and (current) location of the root text sources comprising the Pali Cannon?
- 📝 When Zen monks are completing a task, why are they doing it very quickly?
- 📝 Is Buddha a source of suffering?
- 📝 Are ideas real?
- 📝 How to understand a second order Karma?
- 📝 Trouble understanding "sensual misconduct"
- 📝 How does our inactions contribute to Karma?... For eg:How can you justify act of your cook killing an animal for your non buddhist guest?
- 📝 Relics/ dhathu have supernatural powers?
- 📝 Relationship between Buddhism, Hinduism and Yoga?
- 📝 Problem with the logic of karma
- 📝 Can a layperson/householder live the 'Holy Life'?
- 📝 Does the Consciousness vanish when the objects of consciousness are removed?
- 📝 Vipassana retreat while in post acute withdrawal?
- 📝 DN 15: Whose or which consciousness enters the mother's womb?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Logic vs Karmic principles
- 📝 Logic of Emptiness still unconvincing. Please help explain
- 📝 Why can't we reason or logic our way to NIrvana?
- 📝 Are there formal mechanisms in any Buddhist institutions that explicitly reconcile Buddhist principles with science?
- 📝 Buddhist logic and Nagarjuna
- 📝 How does Buddhist Logic work?
- 📝 What's the karmic cause for loneliness
- 📝 Is there a way to "reset" all karmic conditions with immediate effect?
- 📝 How to mitigate the negative karmic effect of killing
- 📝 Is this just a logic or experience about mind(reality)?
- 📝 How important is motivation in determining the virtue/non-virtue of a karmic action?
- 📝 Does Vajrayana accept the idea that Buddha placed Lord Yama (a supposed Bodhisattva) in charge of the hell realms to ensure karmic retribution?
- 📝 Why difference in karmic effect to same evil deed?
- 📝 Where in the Tripitaka completion of the formation of Karmic result is mentioned?
- 📝 What is the Karmic Effect of Harsh Speech?
- 📝 Problem with the logic of karma
- 📝 What would be the karmic result of worrying?
- 📝 Circular logic and Practice
- 📝 Principles of moral conduct
- 📝 What is the logic behind visualization meditation
- 📝 why can't the spirtual experience explained from logic
- 📝 How do we determine when to use logic and reason in Buddhism?
- 📝 Karmic remnants after advice
- 📝 Intent and Karmic benefit
- 📝 When is a wordly consequence a karmic retribution?
- 📝 what is logic behind rebirth
- 📝 Effects of modern culture (Movies/Gaming) on karmic reactions
- 📝 What's the karmic cause for shyness?
- 📝 Invalid logic pertaining to karma in sutta AN 5.129?
- 📝 Mercy killing (not assisted suicide) and the ramifications of the karmic action
