Is it possible to become UNenlightened?
score:13
No! Once you attain Nibbana, the defilements are annihilated without the possibility of return. Just like uprooting a tree instead of chopping it down or trimming it. So it can never grow back from roots. Nibbana does not depend on the condition of the body or any other thing. It is uncaused, unborn and permanent. Venerable Moggalana was beaten up by thugs until his bones were pulverized. Still his mind was at perfect peace. One Arahath thero in Sri Lanka was thrown into a cauldron of boiling oil by the order of a King. That even caused a Tsunami in sri Lanka. But he was still at perfect peace when his life ended.
Take a Sothapanna person as an example. He can die 6 times before attaining Arhathship. If death itself is not going to affect his attainment, how can brain damage affect it?
Upvote:0
If I am to add to the existing answers, it is like a singularity where all conventional laws break down. So what happens beyond on in this state cannot be communicated through conventional wisdom or language.
Nirvana is the experience beyond the singularity. Once you experience it you have experienced it. You cannot unexperience it. Say you have gone and see Rome. This is a fact. Is it possible to turn back time so you have not seen Rome. Not possible. Likewise once you have seen what is beyond the singularity you cannot be made to be brought to the state where you have not seen it.
Also you experience Nirvana when you are in Pala Samapathi. When you come out of it you don't experience it but the fact you have seen it will not change. Since you know how you got there you can get to it when you want. This experience has a lasting impression / imprint on you. So your ways will change once you come out of the Samapathi.
To further elaborate. The lasting impression is like once your where in Rome had a life changing experience. This sticks.
Upvote:3
It's possibly worth adding to this that although the Theravadan school states that once a being is an Arhat they can't regress this wasn't a universal view within the early Buddhist schools. Both the Pudgalavada and the Sarvastivada schools did maintain that an Arhat could indeed regress from that state. So for those schools it would have been possible to become unenlightened. This was the fifth point in some versions of the five points of Mahadeva which are a number of debating points about the qualities and attributes of an Arahat. However since these schools have since died out this concept of unenlightenment would be of historical interest only.
Just as a reference note this is from An Introduction to Buddism by Peter Harvey (page 97 in the second edition).
Upvote:4
No, an Arahant cannot become unenlightened. Does that mean that an Arahant will automatically be free from illnesses that affect the mind? I don't think so. They will always be free from the three unwholesome roots of greed, hatred, and delusion, but I think it is a serious mistake to translate that into physical claims about Arahants.
Interestingly enough questions similar to this were a point of controversy between the Theravada school and other early schools. Some of the other schools claimed for example that an Arahant was physically incapable of having sexual arousal, and so could not have a nocturnal emission. The Theravada school rejected this, saying that such a thing is purely physical.
Arahants can still experience the purely physical aspects of things without having unwholesome mind states. If you inject an Arahant with adrenaline, their heart rate would increase and they would undergo all of the reactions of a person with fear, but the difference would be that there would be no aversion in the experience, even if they might physically present the signs of it.
Similarly, I think that an Arahant could have what are usually refereed to as mental illnesses, although I think that term is somewhat misleading in the case of an Arahant. Perhaps the term neurological illness would be more appropriate. If they get Alzheimer's disease, then they would undergo all the memory problems and such, but throughout all of this there would be no greed, hatred, or delusion in the mind.
Someone mentioned PTSD. I think an Arahant could have PTSD as well, having the flashback experiences and the physical arousal that goes along with it, but again, without greed, hatred, or delusion.
That's just my take on it.
More post
- 📝 Did the Buddha talk about karma and sexual misconduct independent of the lay precepts
- 📝 Searching for a sutta where Buddha talks about Nibbana
- 📝 What explains the membership of Shingon's 13 Buddhas list?
- 📝 Punishments for breaking vinaya rules
- 📝 Principles of moral conduct
- 📝 Infinity, eternity, countlessness in Buddhism
- 📝 Giving not outside in relation to merits, how should this proper perceived?
- 📝 Does any buddhist school, extant or otherwise, say that there is no svabhava what-so-ever?
- 📝 Four Satipatthanas
- 📝 Are there any websites that contain Buddhist dictionaries?
- 📝 Do Buddhists think other religions are wrong?
- 📝 Buddhist Perspective on Value, Sentiment, Attraction?
- 📝 Spoke to the Buddha in my dream-discard?
- 📝 What is the meaning of "Nothing new will be said here, nor have I any skill in composition. Therefore I do not imagine that I can benefit others."
- 📝 Does the absence of the son of a barren woman truly exist?
- 📝 Is kamma the driving force behind dependent origination
- 📝 Its been said that deep meditationl leads a meditator to another world, what is this another world actually?
- 📝 Origin of the "Scorpion Story". (Your nature to sting, My nature is to save)
- 📝 A Monk Reborn in a Lower Realm for Breaking a Leaf
- 📝 Why is a soul reincarnated, and the purpose of reincarnation?
- 📝 Did the Buddha ever refute the view of "extreme metaphysical nihilism" e.g. a view that "nothing is real"?
- 📝 What specific emotion would best describe dukkah?
- 📝 When we do any moral act on the basis of greed, we get merit or sin
- 📝 Are Vajrayana and Tibetan Buddhism the same thing?
- 📝 Is Buddhist practice a form of suicide?
- 📝 In need of help in meditation
- 📝 Being a monstery monk while training in career online?
- 📝 Practice taxonomy
- 📝 How to deal with people who try to prove your compassion is fake?
- 📝 What does pari-mukha mean in 16 APS anapana sati?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Is it possible to become UNenlightened?
- 📝 Is it possible to become a buddhist without a formal teacher?
- 📝 Is it possible to recognize a person who has achieved Arhatship?
- 📝 Is it possible to have a romantic relationship without attachment?
- 📝 Is it possible to reconcile the evolution theory with Buddhism?
- 📝 Is it possible to "over-train" in samatha meditation?
- 📝 What do buddhists do in a situation of war where all able-bodied men must become soldiers?
- 📝 How does one become a lay Buddhist?
- 📝 Is it possible to experience powerful sensations, such as o*g**m, without getting attached to it?
- 📝 As per buddism, how is it possible to leave behind my obsession with drugs?
- 📝 I would like to become Buddhist
- 📝 Is there any point in learning meditation from an unenlightened person?
- 📝 How is it possible to change habits cultivated over lifetimes
- 📝 Is it possible to adhere to the practices and beliefs of both Buddhist and Christianity?
- 📝 Can a lay person become an Arahant according to the Suttas?
- 📝 Is it possible to achieve universal detachment? How?
- 📝 Is it helpful to stay single if I am not going to become a monk?
- 📝 How can I become less affected by politics?
- 📝 Why choose to attain Nirvana when we can become Brahmas (or Bodhisattvas)?
- 📝 Is it only possible to pay attention to one thing at a time?
- 📝 Is it possible for absolutely everyone to attain enlightenment?
- 📝 Is it even possible to attain Nirvana?
- 📝 How to become a samma sambuddha (Theravada)
- 📝 Is it possible for active people to truly live practice "mindfulness"?
- 📝 How to prevent the development of insight to become ignorance anew?
- 📝 Is it possible to set goals for the future and be present at the same time?
- 📝 How to ordain and become a monk?
- 📝 Is it possible to use meditation to gain Self control?
- 📝 How can a person become a real Buddhist?
- 📝 In Mahayana Buddhism, do they expect everyone to become a Buddha? If so how can any Buddha help anyone to attain enlightenment?