score:6
The original chronicle was The Ecclesiastical History of England and Normandy by Ordericus Vitalis (or Orderic Vitalis), volume III, translated by Thomas Forester. It can be found here. William of Malmesbury is also mentioned the story in his Gesta regum Anglorum, found here
The accounts by Vitalis and Malmesbury are basically the same as you described: Ascelin, son of Arthur, breaks through the crowd at the funeral claiming that the land on which the abbey is built (where William is about to be buried) originally belonged to Arthur, and was stolen by William... After questioning a few locals, the bishop pays Ascelin 60 shillings for the burial plot, and William's son, Henry, pays him 100 pounds of silver for the rest of his claim.