How Did Modern Weapons Change the Dynamics of City Fighting?
score:9
In any war, the strategic goals (and logistics) of the war defines what is worth doing and what is not. The same is true of sieges.
Environment: Pre-gun fire, the only way to raze a city was to (maybe sack it first and) burn it to the ground. Urbanisation of the country side moved more people into cities making them bigger. Now, guns could destroy large portions of a city but not fully. There should be cover, sneakaways, places to hide either bombs or snipers or small units for ambushes. Even fires would stop and not travel as far as they used to -- steel and concrete do not burn that well. So, you have more people and an environment where they can fight effectively. Add to this easy to use weapons (see below) and you the means to do effective urban warfare.
Strategic goals: Now, both Stalingrad and Warsaw were highly political targets that both sides really wanted to keep. Stalingrad because it was Stalin's City and losing it would have been a propaganda disaster. Warsaw because it was the Polish government's in exile (in London) way to assert control over Liberated Poland against the Soviet Union (veiled?) attempt at conquest. Keeping or liberating the city were war goals worth of the nightmare of getting into urban warfare.
As ever, it comes to the overall strategy of the war whether a battle is worth it or not.
A modern example: In more modern times, Baghdad fell to armoured divisions which was thought to be utterly impossible. Again, the goal of the defenders was to flee and create a civil war, not fight for the capital. Thus no major urban war within Baghdad happened. Maybe that helped with the above statement, maybe not. It's too early to tell. Was Baghdad seen as a strategic goal by the US? Yes. Was it seen as a strategic goal by Saddam forces? Maybe. Was it seen as a strategic goal by Al Qaeda? No. Again, it comes down to overall strategical goals.
Side note: Finally, firearms are much easier weapons to use than swords, bows, spears, crossbows, and co. They require limited expertise (thus why the Kalashnikov is so popular because it is so simple) which you can train easily. Its effects are hard to protect against. It takes a few minutes to be able to shoot, a few days to become competent. Thus your civilian population can learn to defend itself really quickly. Explosives need good bomb makers, the delivery system can be dumb -- see suicide bombers, IEDs, mines, etc...
Upvote:4
Modern vs. medieval: it's a matter of cover.
If you're facing someone with a sword or a pike, cover gains you little in the way of protection: an attacker can simply approach, reach around the cover, and stab you. In contrast, height gains you a great deal of protection: it's hard for an attacker standing below to reach you, but you can drop things on them, or reach over a low barrier you're standing behind while the attacker can't reach up and over. The city walls provide you with a great deal of height, but once they're breached, the cover provided by an urban environment gains you little.
In contrast, if you're using a gun or a grenade launcher, cover provides you with a great deal of protection by stopping bullets, while an attacker without similar cover is an easy target. Height, on the other hand, just makes you a bigger target. City walls function mainly as a mechanical barrier to advancing troops which can easily be countered by heavy artillery or combat engineers, but the city itself provides a seemingly endless supply of cover.
Stalingrad vs. Kharkov: it's a matter of objectives.
During the Battle of Kharkov, the Soviets were fighting a delaying action while they evacuated the city (including its industrial facilities). Once they'd finished that, the city itself was a strategically untenable position, so the Soviets retreated.
Holding Stalingrad, on the other hand, was a matter of vast pride to the leaders of both side. Thus, they kept throwing men and materiel into the fight long past the point of diminishing returns.
More post
- 📝 When did the practice of formal declaration of war start?
- 📝 What were acceptance criteria/process to the Vienna Fine Arts Academy in 1906-7?
- 📝 Did Europeans ever trade Eye Aids (telescopes, spyglass, etc) to the Native Americans (1608 - 1850)?
- 📝 What factors made success a possibility for the South in the American Civil War?
- 📝 Which countries banned Ferdinand the bull?
- 📝 Has scholarship shown that persecuted religious minorities have tended to be financially successful?
- 📝 When and why was Seleucia ultimately abandoned?
- 📝 How did the Swedish soldiers pray during the Thirty Years' War?
- 📝 Are there notable incident(s) where Russia/SU was wrongfully accused by Western powers in the 20th century?
- 📝 What was Poland's posture during the Seven Years' War?
- 📝 At what point, and why, did snuff tobacco fall out of favor with European nobility?
- 📝 What proportion of the Austro-Hungarian army fought on each of the fronts?
- 📝 How were Kurds involved (or not) in the invasion of Normandy?
- 📝 What pretext did Hitler use to justify Operation Barbarossa?
- 📝 Where are the agrarian reforms of Basil II codified?
- 📝 How many troops would the White Armies have had at their peak during the Russian Civil War?
- 📝 What is "the dead credit"?
- 📝 Has the accounting services industry ever been disrupted in the U.S.?
- 📝 Why does Spain have enclaves in Morocco?
- 📝 What has prevented the United Nations from failing the same way as the League of Nations?
- 📝 Why did the Allied Forces choose Normandy as their geographic point of invasion?
- 📝 What sources or documentation exists to indicate Stalin's level of popularity in Russia today?
- 📝 What is a strong state in history?
- 📝 How many RAF and USAAF/USAF airfields were built in the UK between the mid-1930s and 1960?
- 📝 Why didn't Japan expand into Ezo?
- 📝 What happened to people of color on interstate railroads traveling from segregated states to non-segregated states?
- 📝 Names of articles worn by men of ~11th century European nobility
- 📝 On what basis did Mao denounce Confucianism?
- 📝 What paintings might these be (2 sketches made in the Tate Britain Gallery)?
- 📝 Why did the assasination of Franz Ferdinand trigger WW1?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How Did Modern Weapons Change the Dynamics of City Fighting?
- 📝 How did Moscow become the capital/most important city in Russia?
- 📝 Were bookshops 'common' in the late 19th century, and how did they differ from modern ones?
- 📝 How did the Egyptian engineers of the Third and Fourth Dynasty construct the Pyramids and Sphinx without modern science and mathematics?
- 📝 How did the British Army unit size and structure in WWI change from 1915 to 1918?
- 📝 How did one's statistical chance of survival as a hidden Jew change during the course of the Nazi occupation of northern France?
- 📝 How did agricultural productivity change in Italy with the fall of the Roman Empire and through the early Middle Ages?
- 📝 How did the modern hyper-appreciation of antiquities develop?
- 📝 How did life change for the average American as a result of the end of World War 1?
- 📝 How and when did the border regime change when the USSR broke up?
- 📝 How did women's roles and rights change during the early Republican period in China?
- 📝 How did the Crimean war change British society?
- 📝 How did Austrian paramilitary organisations amass weapons during the interwar period?
- 📝 How did attitudes of German citizens toward Hitler and the Nazi Party change over the course of the pre-war and the post-war periods?
- 📝 How did the Crusades change medieval Islamic culture?
- 📝 When and how did Thailand cease to be Siam and become the modern Thailand?
- 📝 Why and how did climate change affect the Mayan civilization?
- 📝 How did the primary means of communication between the British government in Delhi and UK change during WW2?
- 📝 How did steppe-nomad military tactics change in response to widespread firearms in the 18th/19th centuries?
- 📝 How did the layout of a Medieval European village typically change as it grew into a town?
- 📝 How did the Palace of Poitiers change from its depiction in Tres Riches Heures to now?
- 📝 How did WWII change the GDPs of the great empires of the world?
- 📝 How did the development of unbreakable and asymmetric encryption change warfare?
- 📝 How did Lincoln's views change up to the Lincoln-Douglas Debates?
- 📝 Why did Hitler attack the Soviet Union when he was still busy fighting the United Kingdom?
- 📝 How and when did the word "nuclear" replace the word "atomic"?
- 📝 How did Israel win the Six-Day War?
- 📝 How did the general population of England convert so smoothly to Protestantism?
- 📝 How did the USSR manage to innovate in an environment characterized by government censorship and high bureaucracy?
- 📝 How did the Romans do division?