At the Battle of Zama, was the Roman army more "native" than the Carthaginian?
score:9
The exact amounts of forces that took part in this battle seem to be unknown or at least controversial. My opinion bases on the lecture of 10 pages of discussion at the main Polish historical board.
In overall, it's safe to say that the the answer is yes, most of the Roman soldiers "Roman" and most of Hannibal's soldiers were mercenaries. Even if it would be more adequate to replace mercenaries with allies.
But I don't claim that it was the reason for winning the battle, which is much more complicated thing.
The following quotes come from Appian's History of Rome.
Hannibal:
He speedily put in battle array about 50,000 men and eighty elephants. He placed the elephants in the front line at intervals, in order to strike terror into the enemy's ranks. Next to them he placed the third part of his army, composed of Celts and Ligurians, and mixed with them everywhere Moorish and Balearic archers and slingers. Behind these was his second line, composed of Carthaginians and Africans. The third line consisted of Italians who had followed him from their own country, in whom he placed the greatest confidence, since they had the most to apprehend from defeat. The cavalry were placed on the wings. In this way Hannibal arranged his forces.
Scipio:
[Β§41] [202] [Proconsul Publius Cornelius] had about 23,000 foot and 1,500 Italian and Roman horse. He had as allies Massinissa with a large number of Numidian horse, and another prince, named Dacamas, with 1,600 horse.
This way we can assume that Hannibal had three separate armies that didn't know each other and didn't have previous experience in cooperating together. One of them being Magon's army, containing Celts, Ligures and other tribes, the second Africans (Libyans and Carthaginians) and the third army in which Hannibal believed the most - veterans from Italy. Also half of his cavalry were Numidians.
At the same time, Scipio's army were mainly Roman and Italian soldiers, strengthened by forces of Masinissa who wanted to take revenge on Carthaginians for supporting his opponent on the way to take over the power in Numidia.
Upvote:0
One of the most troubling things about the Carthaginian army at Zama was the fact that Hannibal's "veteran" troops from his Italian campaigns were non-Carthaginians. And the Carthaginians in his army though enthusiastic and well-trained, were non-veterans who were basically enrolled for this one battle. There was a third group, non-veteran mercenaries from Spain. Thus, the Carthaginians did not have anything of a "home court" advantage that one might expect.
The Romans on the other side, were "native sons" (to Rome), and mostly veterans of campaigns against Hannibal in Italy, or other Carthaginians in Spain. There was one group of non-Romans who were even more "native" than them to North Africa, where the battle was fought. These were the Numidians, from a country bordering Carthage, whose cavalry decided the day. Although not Roman, their country in fact had the most to gain from a Roman victory (specifically Carthaginian territory). It's possible that another group of cavalry with less at stake would have failed to win the battle for the Romans, allowing the Carthaginians to win.
Upvote:5
The Romans used mercenary Numidian cavalry at Zama, and they were more effective than the "Native Sons" in the Roman cavalry, so the assertion is false.
Scipio was a better general, statesman and politician than Hannibal. That's pretty much the beginning and end of it.
More post
- π How does Louise Bryant's assessment of how the Soviet Union would fall hold up at the beginning of the 21st century?
- π What was Finland's role in the siege of Leningrad?
- π Were slings used for throwing hand grenades? If not, why?
- π What happened to the wealth of the Rothschild banking family?
- π What was the extent of influence of James Byrnes on President Truman in the decision to use nuclear weapons?
- π Did Truman threaten a nuclear strike if the Soviet Union didn't withdraw from Iran in 1946?
- π What are some major military successes the Soviet Union achieved against the Western World?
- π How did the French and English forces "stack up" toward the end of the Hundred Years' War?
- π What was the reason that Poland wanted a part of Germany north of Stettin/Szczecin and west of the Oder?
- π Who placed first on entrance exam 1805 at Γcole Polytechnique?
- π What was the device that general Birdwood was using in the "Gallipoli" TV series?
- π Post world war one mandates model
- π How common are the following activities historically?
- π How did ancient Nomadic communities conduct trade?
- π What happened to Saxe Altenburg circa 1827?
- π Has the strength of the historical-archaeological method ever been tested experimentally?
- π Were Communists drafted for the Vietnam war?
- π The Goths and The Roman Empire (Alaric)
- π Why did Charles V divide his holdings as he did?
- π Battles where baits are overlooked by the enemy in expense of the baiter
- π How did people categorize each other in the middle ages, how did racism work?
- π How historically accurate is Age of Empires III?
- π Was it Bismarck who said: "He who is master of Bohemia is master of Europe"?
- π Communist Party member Stances on Molotov Ribbentrop Soviety German Treaty
- π Were any California presidios conquered?
- π Who was Asselin FitzArthur?
- π What are the origins of organized crime?
- π What did the word "leisure" mean in late 18th Century usage?
- π How did the Russian-American Company respond to employee desertion?
- π Which were the most entrepreneurial AND prosperous cities in different eras?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π At the Battle of Zama, was the Roman army more "native" than the Carthaginian?
- π Why was ancient Christianity more successful than the Roman pantheon and Judaism in gaining followers?
- π Was the 1939 Red Army more disciplined / better behaved than the 1943-1945 Red Army?
- π Why was sugar cultivation more profitable in the Caribbean/Brazil than West Africa?
- π Why was the Roman Empire considered an empire rather than a kingdom (again)?
- π During feudalism in Europe, was one's allegiance to the lord more or less important than the allegiance to the king?
- π How was the naval battle of Guadalcanal affected by Japanese ships loading High Explosive shells rather than Armor Piercing?
- π Was the Macedonian phalanx more effective than hoplites?
- π How was the Roman army in fact organized during Caesar's campaigns in Gaul?
- π Did the food economy of the late Roman republic rely on foreign imports, or was it more localized?
- π Was the Byzantine follis larger than the Roman (and why, if yes)?
- π During the 1850βs and 60βs, was the free North (and its cause in the U.S. Civil War) considered more virtuous than the slave-holding South?
- π Why was agriculture more conducive to slavery in U.S. South than the North?
- π Did Cato the Elder think destruction of Carthage was more important than anything else for Rome?
- π Was the quality of Roman armor really worse than the armor of knights of the XII-XIV centuries?
- π Was "Street" more common than the abbreviated "St." in pre-1910 American newspapers?
- π Was there ever a president of the united states related to more than 1 other president?
- π Why were so many more Jewish men than Jewish women killed during the Holocaust?
- π Why was the Council of Nicea held in Nicea rather than Rome or Constantinople?
- π Why was World War I ended on Nov 11 11:00, rather than immediately upon signing the armistice?
- π When was Silver ever more valuable than Gold?
- π Which battle was the most lopsided result in terms of casualties?
- π Is it true that there are more slaves in the world now than ever at one point in history?
- π Was the tugboat ever part of a WWII battle group?
- π Why was Kaliningrad placed under the Russian SFSR rather than the Lithuanian SSR?
- π Was there an assassination attempt against Xerxes in the battle of Thermopylae?
- π What was the average height of Roman men and women?
- π How difficult was to escape from a naval battle after engaging into one during the Age of Sail?
- π Was there really a navy officer named Picard at the Battle of Trafalgar?
- π What was the first battle in history fought by vast-majority-% "distance-shooting" non-mechanized force?