How far away could one be and still see the atom bomb explosions?
score:23
This is not possible. And this has nothing to do with the actual brightness of explosion. A similar explosion on the Moon will probably be visible from the earth if the weather conditions are good and if you know when and where to look.
According to the Wikipedia, the Nagasaki bomb was exploded at the height of 503 m, about 1/2 km. To be directly visible from 810 km distance it had to be exploded at the height more than 60 km.
(Calculation: 810 km=437 nautical miles=7.289 degrees. The radius of Earth is 6370 km; 6370/cos 7.289=6423. Subtract 6370, we get 63 km. This is the height at which the bomb had to be exploded to be visible at 810 km. I neglected refraction but the difference between 60 km and 0.5 km is so large that refraction can be neglected.)
Of course there are described cases of strong anomalous refraction, but they usually occur in polar regions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novaya_Zemlya_effect, and one does not expect it on the latitude of Japan.
EDIT. A suggestion in a comment was that a reflection from a cloud could be seen. Again, the information found in Wikipedia shows that clouds do not reach such heights, except in polar regions (stratospheric clouds). In addition to this, a reflection would be much weaker than the original flash, and perhaps cannot be seen at 800 km.
EDIT2. I am surprised by the number of comments to this answer. Nobody would discuss the question whether the Great Fire of London could be visible from Switzerland (about the same distance), because of some super-unusual refraction or some super-high clouds, or whatever. The only difference is that a nuclear explosion involves a very bright (and very short) flash. But this difference is irrelevant.
Upvote:0
With Earth curvature in mind, 810km gives a 50km high curve. So the earth is flat or the clip in the movie is full of crap. On the other hand, after doing some research, they state nuke explosions can be seen from 600 miles distance, but 600 miles gives a curve of 71km, I don't think we can see a plume, unless the earth is flat.
Curve calculator here http://dizzib.github.io/earth/curve-calc/index.html
Upvote:4
Note that the atomic cloud after the explosion is said to have reached a height of 70,000 feet (about 21 km). Although this still appears to be too low, with refraction and other effects, it might have been possible to see it from Shanghai.
Upvote:12
The link provided by @T.E.D. combined with the observations of Major Charles Sweeney that the height of the flash, off the cirrus clouds over Nagasaki, was "at least 6 miles (or 31,000 feet) [above the explosion]" giving a refraction-free visibility for such a reflected flash as about 230 miles or 370 km.
The underside of the great clouds over Nagasaki was amber-tinted, as though reflecting the conflagaration at least 6 miles below. Beneath the top cloud mass, white in colour, there gradually climbed a turbulent pillar of black smoke and dust which emitted a second fireball less vivid than the first.
distance in miles =~ sqrt( 7 * height-in-feet / 4) = sqrt(7 * 31,000 / 4)
=~ 230 miles ~ 380 km
However, as noted further down in the link provided by T.E.D.:
Unfortunately, the refraction varies considerably from day to day, and from one place to another. It is particularly variable over water: because of the high heat capacity of water, the air is nearly always at a different temperature from that of the water, so there is a thermal boundary layer, in which the temperature gradient is far from uniform.
...
In conditions that produce superior mirages, there are inversion layers in which the ray curvature exceeds that of the Earth. Then, in principle, you can see infinitely far — there really is no horizon.
...
However, there is one situation in which objects can be made out at great distances: when they are silhouetted against a bright background, such as the setting Sun, or (just after sunset) a bright twilit sky.
...
What's the record for visibility without help from the silhouetting effect? I think that might belong to the report of the expedition led by Korzenewsky (1923), who reported seeing snow-capped peaks of a mountain range 750 km away. Conditions were perfect: the lower atmosphere was in shadow at sunset; the peaks were quite high (4650 meters, or over 15,000 feet); they were covered with white snow, increasing their visibility; and there must also have been considerable looming to bring these distant features above the observers' horizon.
This observation by Korzenewsky is very similar in circumstances to the reported sighting from Shanghai, so I would not rule it out completely without further investigation of the meteorological conditions that day. It was late summer, with clear calm conditions (breeze < 5 mph at ground zero), which is typical of mirage conditions.
This link goes into the detailed meteorological conditions necessary for a long-distance superior mirage, such as the reported observation must have been. The required temperature inversion could easily have existed in late morning in early August over the cooler waters of the Sea of Japan.
Update:
Sweeney can accurately say that "the underside of the great clouds over Nagasaki" were at least 6 miles high, because he himself was at 30,000 feet for the bombing run and aftermath.
More post
- 📝 How long was a journey "from the Varangians to the Greeks?"
- 📝 Did Roosevelt's New Deal lift the U.S. out of the depression or did it actually prolong the Depression and cripple American capitalism?
- 📝 How did the First French Empire and allies differ from the other European monarchies at that time?
- 📝 What is the reason for Burma/Myanmar's recent reforms?
- 📝 Where does Marsilio Ficino write that all nations worship a God whose name is spelled with four letters?
- 📝 When did tea become "a thing" in England?
- 📝 Was it common to brush off Hitler's radical remarks as just figures of speech to whip up the supporters among US commentators in the 1930's?
- 📝 How long did it take for mail to get to London from New York in 1919?
- 📝 Did Brahms really leave Germany because he was dissatisfied with the political realities of that time?
- 📝 How many days of supply did units in WW2 carry?
- 📝 Which is the oldest language in the World?
- 📝 What explains the large number of US Security Council vetoes between 1970-1991?
- 📝 Early instances of bacteriological warfare
- 📝 How were Roman Legions disarmed/disbanded before entering Italia?
- 📝 What damage did anti-tank rifles hope to inflict on tanks in WW2?
- 📝 What were Nazi policies around converts to Judaism?
- 📝 Roman aristocrat with slave assassins named after him?
- 📝 What is the best method/ readings to learn WWII
- 📝 Has the strength of the historical-archaeological method ever been tested experimentally?
- 📝 WWI: British blockade of Germany (and neutrals)
- 📝 Why did the US have a plan for the event of war against Britain in the 1920s?
- 📝 What were the origins of Etruscan Civilisation?
- 📝 Monuments of Sesostris
- 📝 How long did it take to make a 16th century arrow?
- 📝 Did the Greeks and Romans use reputational incentives to induce people to pay more tax?
- 📝 How historical are early Chinese (Shang dynasty and earlier) dynastic records?
- 📝 When was the property tax introduced in early Mexico? Who paid?
- 📝 From where did Aryans originate?
- 📝 What was the point of hanging in “hanging, drawing, and quartering”?
- 📝 How many times did the the sacred fire of Vesta die?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How far away could one be and still see the atom bomb explosions?
- 📝 From how far away could an experienced and skilled archer hit a man?
- 📝 How could one understand the essence of Greek mythology and the deep meanings? Understanding the belief system of Ancient Greeks
- 📝 How fast and how far could one travel, by means of horse relay posts, in ancient China in 1500CE?
- 📝 When and how did the Han ethnic group become by far the biggest ethnic group in China?
- 📝 How to identify this coin with a bust on one side and the letters S and C on the other side?
- 📝 How far away could zeppelins drop bombs?
- 📝 How could a prisoner get lessons to read, write and do mathematics in jail, while innocent people didn't get the basic knowledge in 18th-19th century?
- 📝 Why did no one take Siberia over before the Russians, and how did they do it?
- 📝 How were the Burmese able to sack Ayutthaya when it was one of the wealthiest and most powerful cities in Asia at the time?
- 📝 Why did officers fire revolvers with just one hand, while wielding a sword in the other hand despite being too far away to use swords?
- 📝 How do historians and linguists know how to pronounce the names from non-phonetic scripts?
- 📝 How and when did the word "nuclear" replace the word "atomic"?
- 📝 How did the USSR manage to innovate in an environment characterized by government censorship and high bureaucracy?
- 📝 When and how did the USA and the UK become allies?
- 📝 In the Battle of the Coral Sea, how could two Japanese scouts grossly mis-identify two American ships?
- 📝 How and when was the modern company ownership structure invented?
- 📝 How were the cities of Milan and Bruges spared by the Black Death?
- 📝 How did the ruling class in the Muslim world react to the discovery and colonization of the Americas?
- 📝 How difficult was to escape from a naval battle after engaging into one during the Age of Sail?
- 📝 How to explain the apparent discrepancy in the use of papyrus vs. clay tablets between Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia?
- 📝 How true is the statement "Soviet troops got into Berlin riding American trucks, walking in American boots and using American trains"?
- 📝 How many lives were estimated to have been saved by the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs?
- 📝 How and why was the boundary between West and East Berlin decided to be where it was?
- 📝 How was the modern geographic boundary between Europe and Asia decided?
- 📝 How far could an English war bow shoot?
- 📝 How long did it take for a diplomat to travel between Berlin and Vienna in the 1770's?
- 📝 How expensive were castles? And how were the costs distributed?
- 📝 How did knights who required glasses to see survive on the battlefield?
- 📝 How do Friedman and Bernanke's explanations about the causes of the Great Depression compare?