Are there notes by the Founding Fathers which indicate why DC citizens were denied a vote in Congress?
score:7
Such concern likely existed, and there is evidence of some cursory discussion to that effect during the proceedings of the Continental Congress. The rationale for creating a federal district with sole jurisdiction of the Congress was probably laid out best (among the surviving documents) by James Madison:
The indispensable necessity of complete authority at the seat of government, carries its own evidence with it. It is a power exercised by every legislature of the Union, I might say of the world, by virtue of its general supremacy. Without it, not only the public authority might be insulted and its proceedings interrupted with impunity; but a dependence of the members of the general government on the State comprehending the seat of the government, for protection in the exercise of their duty, might bring on the national councils an imputation of awe or influence, equally dishonorable to the government and dissatisfactory to the other members of the Confederacy. This consideration has the more weight, as the gradual accumulation of public improvements at the stationary residence of the government would be both too great a public pledge to be left in the hands of a single State, and would create so many obstacles to a removal of the government, as still further to abridge its necessary independence.1
The issue of representation is mentioned a little bit further in the document, and is basically pointing out that the importance of federal holdings to the nation runs counter to resident governance.
Nor would it be proper for the places on which the security of the entire Union may depend, to be in any degree dependent on a particular member of it. All objections and scruples are here also obviated, by requiring the concurrence of the States concerned, in every such establishment.2
While Madison is referring most directly to military installations, the inference is likely one that can be extended to the seat of government. To understand the connection between security and seat of government, the context of the decision-making process about locating the proceedings of the Congress is important. The bulk of the debate took place around October of 1783, and was in part precipitated by Pennsylvania Mutiny of 1783. Under the Articles of Confederacy, the Congress relied on the Pennsylvania militia to provide security. The Pennsylvania Council chose not to do so, and allowed an angry mob to march on the Congressional proceedings. Also, the role of being able to come to a compromise on where the seat of government should be located was likely a big part - on October 6, 1783 motions to house the Congress in each of the 13 states were voted down.3
About the only mention I can find from around this period is again from Madison, this time in a letter to Edmund Randolph dated September 20, 1783:
Among other subjects which divide Congress, their constitutional authority, touching such an establishment in time of peace is one. Another still more puzzling is the precise jurisdiction proper for Congress with the limits of their permanent seat. As these points may possibly remain undecided till November, I mention them particularly that your aid may be prepared.4
Outside of that, it doesn't appear to have been one of the considerations. Not only did the Congress have a much more pragmatic outlook on the subject, the area under consideration with only a few square miles. Wilhelmus Bogart Bryan summed up the record of discussions regarding the jurisdiction for the federal district in writing about the response to recommendations presented to the Congress for its establishment:
This report was referred to the committee of the whole, but there is no record that any further action was taken. In the papers of the continental congress there are two documents evidently intended as amendments, but their place and purpose are not indicated in any way. In one of the papers the principle is laid down that such a district "ought to be entirely exempted from the authority of the state ceding the same, and the organization and administration of the powers of government within the said district concentrated between Congress and the inhabitants thereof." The other paper prescribes that the state or states ceding the territory "should give up all jurisdiction whatsoever ... that the appointment of judges and the executive power within the said territory shall vest in Congress; ... that the citizens should enjoy the privilege of trial by jury and being governed by laws made by representatives of their own election." 5
Beyond that, there doesn't appear to me anything other than a general consensus that Congressional authority over the District, as it was incorporated without much modification as the beginning of Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution:
To exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over such District (not exceeding ten Miles square) as may, by Cession of particular States, and the Acceptance of Congress, become the Seat of the Government of the United States...
1 Madison, James. The Federalist No. 43, p. online
2 Ibid.
3 United States Continental Congress. Journals of the American congress: from 1774 to 1788 - Volume 4, p. 283-6
4 Madison, James. The Papers of James Madison, Volume 1, p. 573
5 Bryan, Wilhelmus Bogart. A History of the National Capital, Volume 1, p. 15
More post
- 📝 Why were North American indigenous peoples underdeveloped?
- 📝 What is the oldest state/nation that has abolished the death penalty?
- 📝 What did MLK, Jr. mean by "Mayor Loeb is in dire need of a doctor"?
- 📝 How did a student grant work in 18th/19th century Western Europe
- 📝 How did conditional POW exchanges work in WW2?
- 📝 How do we know that prehistoric hunter-gatherer societies were egalitarian?
- 📝 How much faster were the printing presses than hand writing?
- 📝 Has an entire generation of a young children in a civilization ever been orphaned and raised as loyals?
- 📝 Are modern day Egyptians the genetic descendants of Ancient Egyptians?
- 📝 Why are the Portuguese so obsessed with salted codfish?
- 📝 Has any country ever 'sold' a part of it's territory voluntarily to another?
- 📝 Did Hadrian have any children?
- 📝 What was the tonnage carried in the Triangle Trade?
- 📝 Link between Mary I and Bloody Mary
- 📝 "Three Pines" as code for British Loyalists during the Revolutionary War
- 📝 Settling legal disputes in high medieval Europe?
- 📝 Did John F. Kennedy know about his judicial nominee's racism?
- 📝 Can anyone identify this possibly Czechoslovak uniform?
- 📝 What was this building and what happend to it?
- 📝 Why do land mines seem to be a more serious problem in the Balkans than the Alps?
- 📝 Is there evidence of people moving east to Europe?
- 📝 Why didn't Nixon erase the smoking gun?
- 📝 Did Mesopotamia have coins to represent Gerahs & Minas?
- 📝 Were cities that enacted lockdowns during the 1918 flu pandemic successful in preventing any infections?
- 📝 What were the criteria for class ranking at West Point prior to the Civil War?
- 📝 In the US, why did anti-authoritarian sentiment grow only in the 1960s?
- 📝 Book about Glorious Revolution
- 📝 Did Iran host anti Soviet Afghan factions during the 1980's?
- 📝 Was hay invented only in the Middle Ages in Europe?
- 📝 Identify WW2 ammo
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Are there notes by the Founding Fathers which indicate why DC citizens were denied a vote in Congress?
- 📝 Are there any documented examples of wooden ships which were in active service for 100 years or more? If not, what is the longest?
- 📝 Why were there no internment camps for German-American citizens in USA during WW2?
- 📝 Is there a historical explanation as to why the USA people are so litigious compared to the French?
- 📝 Why are there so many laws about eye injuries in the Code of Hammurabi?
- 📝 Why were there no agricultural, city-state forming civilizations in the Ice Age?
- 📝 Why were there so few American deaths in the Bataan Death March?
- 📝 The WWI Christmas truce of 1914 resulted in no consequences, in spite of clear warnings against such beforehand - why were there no courts-martial?
- 📝 Is there any documentation that indicates the Aztecs were as violent as they are made out?
- 📝 Why are there no photorealistic paintings from the old days?
- 📝 Are there any historians who believe that the crusades were not motivated as a distraction from internal conflicts?
- 📝 Were there any Roman villas in Britain which were used rather than destroyed after the Romans left?
- 📝 In Europe, why were there few portraits showing a real likeness of the subject before the 15th century?
- 📝 Were there any Chinese expeditions to explore the world? If not, why not?
- 📝 Why were there no increases in the train speed records between 1854-1934?
- 📝 Why are Vikings singled out for raids in Britain and Ireland when records may indicate most raids were by local rulers?
- 📝 Have there been any nuclear accidents in the US at nuclear facilities which were not "commercial"?
- 📝 Were there any other systems which resemble the complex election procedure for the doge of Venice
- 📝 Are there cases of U.S. Founding Fathers burning flags of other nations?
- 📝 Why are there shields present on the sides of Henry VIII ships, did they serve any function or was it pure decoration?
- 📝 Why were there so many suffect consuls during the Principate?
- 📝 Why were there "Tributary States" to the Ottoman Empire?
- 📝 Were there attempts to rename the French language Prussian order Pour le Mérite, why was it never Germanised?
- 📝 Are there any specific events which grants a soldier permission to execute a prisoner on sight? (Like in the movie: Fury)
- 📝 Are there any misunderstandings in history that were resolved in the 20th century?
- 📝 Why were countries which were clearly aligned to one of the two power blocs during cold war a part of the non-aligned movement?
- 📝 Why were there so many US military deaths outside of the major battles in WW2?
- 📝 Why Did the Founding Fathers Create the Electoral College?
- 📝 Why are there multiple versions of the color plate "Excavation of Olive Mount"?
- 📝 Why was it deemed necessary that the “average person… knows they are on the border”, which resulted in the creation of the US-Canadian border slash?