Why are there no photorealistic paintings from the old days?

Upvote:17

According to many Hellenistic accounts, photo-realistic painting was well developed and popular at that time. The legend says that an artist made a picture of a boy with some fruits, and it was so realistic that the birds tried to peck the fruits. The artist however considered this a failure, because the birds who did recognize the fruits as real, were not scared by the boy whom they evidently did not recognize as real. There are many such and similar accounts in the Hellenistic authors who wrote on painting. Unfortunately almost no painting of that period survived.

Later famous artists also made photo-realistic drawings, here is an example: Young Hare,

However, most of them you encounter not in the art museums but in scientific libraries: before the invention of the photography, scientists made many drawings of animals, plants, landscapes etc. These drawings were included in the books as illustrations, but high quality book illustrations are prohibitively expensive, and the originals are difficult to see (most of them are made on paper, and libraries hide them to preserve). Here are examples:

Heart of Andes,

Monkey

Returning to the artists, few artists in various epochs AIMED at photographic drawing, but some did. Examples are the Dutch 17th century nature mort. Polish painter Semiradsky (who drew mythology scenes) or the Russian Vereshchagin who painted the real scenes (a kind of journalist-painter): see Google images Vereshchagin, Example.

Upvote:26

It's obviously not due to lack of talent. It's important to ask first whether the ancients even aspired to photorealistic paintings. Consider that the ancients were adept at a form of artistic representation that was even more "realistic" than a photorealistic painting: sculpture. Even the Egyptians, famous for their stylized two-dimensional art, where quite capable of realistic sculpture. This bust of Nefertiti is from 1345 BC:

enter image description here

There's more here. And of course, ancient Greek sculptures had even greater verisimilitude. 2D art can never be as representative of 3D space as 3D art can, so it is not surprising that 3D art has long had a more realist bias than 2D art.

In two-dimensional art, artists generally privileged thematic and spiritual considerations over realism. According to the article on perspective, they "typically sized many objects and characters hierarchically according to their spiritual or thematic importance, not their distance from the viewer

That said, perspective in 2D art is not intuitive, and the development of perspective required grounding in mathematics. While the ancient Greeks (who were quite good at math) did begin to develop some understanding of perspective, modern theories of perspective did not really start developing until the 15th century. Brunelleschi is an especially important figure here. Within two centuries of the development of perspective, we have artists like Vermeer who are noted for their "almost photorealistic" style.

Still, you are correct that not even early modern artists were as obsessed with "photorealism" as members of the modern photorealist movement. The photorealism movement, from its chosen name to its chosen style, was a reaction to the ubiquity of photography in the 20th century:

Pop Art and Photorealism were both reactionary movements stemming from the ever increasing and overwhelming abundance of photographic media, which by the mid 20th century had grown into such a massive phenomenon that it was threatening to lessen the value of imagery in art. However, whereas the Pop artists were primarily pointing out the absurdity of much of the imagery (especially in commercial usage), the Photorealists were trying to reclaim and exalt the value of an image.

The photorealists are clearly not, to a man, more talented than Vermeer and others like him. They are simply using their art to convey a message that no artist before the modern era would ever have needed or wanted to convey.

More post

Search Posts

Related post