What explanations have been given as to why the Jews were not killed in Italy?
score:26
It is wrong to say that Italian Jews were not exterminated. They in fact were, but only after Italy was occupied by German forces.
Regarding the stance of the Italian government and fascist party, it did not express much of anti-Semitic ideology. At the origins of the fascist party were many Jews, and also Jewish black-shirt brigades of Jabotinsky were trained in Italy in a preparation to invade British Palestine.
When the Holocaust started, Italy gave asylum to Croatian Jews who were killed by the Ustashe regime in Croatia. Despite demands of German government, Italy refused to transfer their Jews or Jews from the occupied territories to Germany.
It should be noted though that in the beginning of 1940s Italy under German pressure enacted some anti-Jewish legislation in exchange for Germany's consent regarding forced expulsion of ethnic Germans from Italy's South Tyrol. Hitler sought persecution of Jews as a more important task than protecting ethnic Germans in Italy.
The legislation was easily avoidable by the Jews though: to be exempt from prosecutions a Jew could either attend a Christian church or enroll into fascist party (some other categories such as WWI veterans were also exempt).
The situation changed when Italy declared war on Germany and was consequently occupied by German forces: all the caught Jews were sent to German extermination camps.
Upvote:0
This is something which have to do with the differences in ideology between the different totalitarianisms: fascism, nationalsocialism and stalinism.
It is nationalism on steroids with access to the methods and tools of an industrialized country/economy but with different reason and criteria for differentiating (or not) between groups in its own population.
The reason for differing between the groups in a population according to three different authoritarian ideologies is:
- bolsjevikism/lenin-stalinism
- sees society as competition between classes (the bourgeois as exploiters of the oppressed workers - both in industry and agriculture)
nazism:
- communist ??? not good - you are possible competition
- socialdemokrat ?? ok... don't argue with me (which includes forbidding socialdemokrat unions)
- union activist ? Don't you want to be a member of my union ?
- which religion and which is your race ?? (racism)
- Jew ? not good (racism, but the nazi party also required a method of explaining Germany's loss in WWI)
- Slav ? .. not good, also your land interests me (rasism and expansionistic urges)
Fascism
- race or religion
- Italian Jew ? no trouble, YOU are Italian ! I also don't want to control people's religion but i want a good relation with your congregation.
- possible opposition:
- Communist ? maybe a bit of trouble. Don't be vocally against me!
- yugoslavian ? no trouble, i basically only wants a bit of your land (imperialistic/expansionistic)
- race or religion
One of the common traits of fascism (and the other totalitarian ideologies) is the demand on total control which means that forces which are potentially strong opposition needs to be quashed.
The wiki (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totalitarianism) describes fascism in Il Duce's own word as :
everything within the state, nothing outside it, nothing against it.
The fascist ideology isn't racist against groups while the nationalsocializm in Germany is (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascism) One reason is that italian fascism were roman-romanticist ie they wanted to recreate the roman empire which did accept conquerred people as they were (but was loath to accept tries to gain independence - become a roman , alway a roman!)
Bolsjevikism viewed any opposition as something which should be destroyed while stalinism also wanted total control of economy of the state and control of people's thoughts.
In fact fascism is a little like the old authoritarian conservative monarchy. Think a Friedrich der Grosse with a modern army and a large bureaucracy on his hands (ie the tools which came with the industralization.)
Think nothing against me
The old authoritarians didn't have the means to control society to the same degree as some of the 20th century's dictators. Franco didn't have the desire to say:
everything within the state, nothing outside it
Upvote:1
It looks like you’re trying a theoretical comparison of fascisms using a theory of fascism where both Germany and Italy are considered fascist. You ought to consider nationalist revanchevist movements of radical extra parliamentary national renewal generally. Across movements like Salazar’s, Horthy’s, Franco’s or Pinochet anti-semitism is not an essential part of all these movements. Therefore anti-semitism should not be considered a core element of fascism and therefore there is no expectation that Italian fascism should have murdered Jews.
Fascisms describe an imaginary national community that needs to be renewed, but the constitution of the imaginary community varies from blood racism to linguistic racism to cultural racism in different fascist configurations. Many of these do not consider Jewish people to be fundamentally outside the national community.
Upvote:14
First of all notice that although many Jews might have perished in Germany, by large the highest fraction was killed in the extermination camps of occupied Poland. Back to Italy now.
Even though the Italian Government put emphasis on the purity of the "Italian Race", it was not until 1938 that a specific law against the "Jewish Race" was approved. Italian Jews were normally admitted into the Fascist Party.
This because for Mussolini the rhetoric of the race was purely for propaganda reasons, and he did not intend to prosecute different "races". Italians living in the colonies (the Empire) had no particular problems mixing with the local population.
This changed with the aftermath of the war in Ethiopia. Italy decided to side with Germany: the British initiative at the Society of Nations (that punished Mussolini's war of aggression) removed his last doubts in that direction.
So it was more to appease the German Government than to fulfill any per-existing intention that the laws were approved.
When the extermination campaign was started in 1942, the location of extermination camps was chosen to be Poland, probably because of its lower population density, large forests and central position in occupied Europe.
Italy did not participate to the extermination at the beginning. However, following the Allied Operation Husky in 1943, and the Government inability to do anything to prevent the occupation of Sicily by invading forces, Mussolini was deposed and an armistice was signed by General Badoglio on 8th September 1943. Following the armistice, German forces occupied Italy and the Italian Army was largely dispersed due mostly to lack of instructions.
The Germans annexed parts of Northern Italy to the Reich and created a puppet state, the Italian Social Republic, or "Repubblichina" as it was derogatorily referred to by Italian partisans.
Deportation and liquidation of the Italian Jews happened only in this period of time, and within the parts of Italy occupied by Germany.
Now there is some rumor regarding the Risiera di San Sabba, according to some historians it was a (smaller scale) extermination camp, while other see it as a transit camp only. Because of the political implications the debate floats on lots of ideological noise, and I find it difficult to tell what happened. Numbers were likely small though (when compared to the overall holocaust dead).
More post
- 📝 Why didn't Semmelweis perform a simpler experiment, to stop all the anatomical work?
- 📝 Why couldn't Germans and Finns capture Leningrad?
- 📝 Why Didn't Hitler order an immediate attack on Moscow in August 1941?
- 📝 During the Peninsula War, what British material aid was given to Spain/Portugal?
- 📝 In the late 1800s how did American Indians portray resiliency in the in the midst of oppression?
- 📝 Why did the San Marco Marine Brigade adopt the winged lion of Venice?
- 📝 Is the entire history, we read, accurate?
- 📝 When was the last cavalry charge?
- 📝 Is there any historical evidence that Sultan Mehmed II bought the Hagia Sophia?
- 📝 What are these hats and the function of those wearing them (worn by the Russian imperial army at Borodino)?
- 📝 When did furniture become common in the homes of most people in the British Isles?
- 📝 Latin/Greek for assassin
- 📝 Which American Civil War admiral said he would not punish people for getting their ship close to the enemy?
- 📝 Was Churchill a poor HR manager?
- 📝 Did books from classical times delay scientific progress in the middle ages?
- 📝 What is the origin/history of the practice of standing up if an elder or respectable is approaching?
- 📝 Were the NKVD hated by the regular army like the SS was?
- 📝 What happened to the belongings of fallen Roman soldiers?
- 📝 Roman Legion composition
- 📝 Who is the man in the red jacket in this painting?
- 📝 Did Saladin speak any European languages?
- 📝 How might someone have gotten a note forwarded from a transport train headed to Auschwitz?
- 📝 What are these items in this 16th century plan of an English town?
- 📝 How were the prime ministers of Japan selected during the Taisho era?
- 📝 How Bell turn backed electricity fluctuations to sound?
- 📝 Where to find a comprehensive list of proto-cuneiform Sumerian glyphs?
- 📝 Accuracy of Ancient Dates of Persian/Middle East Based on Astronomy
- 📝 Did samurai wear hakama long enough to hide their feet?
- 📝 What proportion of the Arab population of Palestine pre-1948 came from families that lived there before 1880?
- 📝 What is meaning of 4 letter abbreviations in Roman names like Titus Flavius T. f. T. n. Sabinus?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 What explanations have been given as to why the Jews were not killed in Italy?
- 📝 What were the most common reasons why draft-age men were not conscripted for the Union Army?
- 📝 Have there been any nuclear accidents in the US at nuclear facilities which were not "commercial"?
- 📝 What were factors that led to a decline in bond yields during World War II given that the opposite should have happened?
- 📝 What would have been the signal that Pontiac would have given to attack in Fort Detroit?
- 📝 What knowledge may have been lost at the Library of Alexandria?
- 📝 Why were so many more Jewish men than Jewish women killed during the Holocaust?
- 📝 Why were helmets and other body armour not commonplace in the 1800s?
- 📝 Why were British ships not of the same quality as French and Spanish ships until the latter part of the 18th century?
- 📝 What would have been the typical drinks for a US farmer in the late 18th/early 19th century?
- 📝 What were the reasons that the British colonies in North America rebelled but not others?
- 📝 Why did Jews not immigrate to the Muslim world?
- 📝 How many lives were estimated to have been saved by the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs?
- 📝 What would have been the price of a loaf of bread in 1645 Amsterdam?
- 📝 What courses would have been required to get a B.A. in America in the 1930s?
- 📝 Why was the Greek alphabet not adopted by other languages, given the Greek influence?
- 📝 Why did the states that were born out of the Louisiana purchase adopt a common law system, and not a civil law system?
- 📝 Why were gravediggers, actors and former gladiators (but not slaves) banned from the Colosseum?
- 📝 What would have been the carrying capacity for 11th-13th century backpacks?
- 📝 Why did Russians have guns towards the end of the Mongol Yoke, but not the Mongols?
- 📝 What were the Government Press Prosecutions of 1858 and why did they occur?
- 📝 What murals and decor might have been present in the earliest Sumerian temples?
- 📝 What would have been on the menu in an Ancient Egyptian tavern?
- 📝 Why were "holding out" outposts a feature of the European war in 1944-5 but not 1940-1?
- 📝 Why would the heads of the Manhattan Project have been imprisoned in the event of its failure?
- 📝 Why was Italy unified under the Kingdom of Piedmont-Sardinia and not under a stronger state?
- 📝 What psychology would have been taught at the 19th century Lyceum?
- 📝 Why were Japanese submarines not able to defend in the Battle of the Philippine Sea?
- 📝 What alternate north-south supply routes did the Soviet Union have when the Volga and Stalingrad were under attack?
- 📝 In the British Invasion of Greece, what happened to the British troops who were not captured?