How culpable was Captain Smith for the Titanic disaster?
Upvote:9
That's a difficult question to answer. Partly yes, partly no.
Yes: He received at least 6 messages warning for icebergs in the area. Nevertheless, he ordered full speed.
No: The Titanic didn't have enough lifeboats. Even if there was time enough to evacuate all passengers and crew, the loss of life would have been enormous.
No: The Titanic had more lifeboats aboard then legally was required at the time.
You can't blame him for not having enough lifeboats. Supposing he would have objected or refused to sail, he would have been fired on the spot by his company. With good reason, as they complied with all legal regulations.
Ordering full speed is a different matter. That was his responsibility. But in his defense I think he was under a lot of pressure because the owner of the White Star line was on board. In those days it wasn't done to ignore "requests" from the owner. He would have to pay for ignoring them once the ship arrived in New York.
Don't say things are different now. If you piss off your CEO today you'll have to pay the price for it. That was then, that is now. Some things don't change that much...
Compare the Titanic with the Costa Concordia: both ships suffered fairly similar damage. Both got sliced over many more watertight compartments than the ship could handle.
Worse for the Costa Concordia, in my opinion. (That is without looking at the gross loss of life on the Titanic, just at the accident itself.) When the Titanic was build, watertight doors were a new concept. Safety at sea basically didn't exist. With the Costa we have a full century of experience. And still it happened, more or less the same.
It's easy to say 'he should have done that'. With 100% hindsight, he should have. But we are all humans. Most of us probably would have chosen for our job rather than for a possible (when he gave the command he didn't see that many icebergs) collision.
About lowering the lifeboats:
That's not really an issue. Some lifeboats couldn't be lowered, due to the angle of the ship. Others were lowered with not enough passengers to board. But none of them were ordered to be lowered immediately by the captain. At that time, panic started to kick in. The captain was on the bridge, different officers in charge of different lifeboat stations. Each handled as he saw fit. Some allowed 3rd class passengers to board 1st class lifeboats, others didn't. There was no life boat drill, nobody had practiced any evacuation exercises - this was something totally new. This is clearly something out of control of the captain.
I just finished a book about the Titanic. I'm far from an expert, but in my opinion, captain Smith did what he could given the circumstances. He didn't abandon the ship (Ismay did, and was heavily criticized for that), stayed on board and went down with it. Contrast this with captain Schettino, who was one of the first to jump into the lifeboats. Oopsie ... 'fell into a lifeboat' ;-)
With regard to cap. Schettino: yes, he claimed he fell into a lifeboat. True enough. But the court rejected that excuse. So did the coastguard who was present at the accident. Va a bordo, cazzo! became a popular meme. If he fell into a lifeboat, he could have climbed out of it, couldn't he? But he didn't.
Captain Smith remained in command of a hopeless situation, and tried to manage it as best as he could. Schettino immediately panicked, and made matters far worse.
More post
- 📝 Whatever happened to Turing's friend Arnold Murray?
- 📝 Were the living standards in Medieval Europe a lot worse than in the Muslim world?
- 📝 Did people from the cities of Uruk, Ur and Sumer have knowledge/recollection of how old their cities were (say, recollection after 2000 BCE)?
- 📝 Ratio of population to military size throughout European history?
- 📝 Has any U.S. Vice President not been nominated as presidential candiate although he ran as candiate?
- 📝 Was the house of representatives really as rowdy a place as it is portrayed in the 2012 film Lincoln?
- 📝 Why does the first decade of the 21st century start with 2000?
- 📝 Is Caesar's birth year more certain now than it was when disputed by Mommsen?
- 📝 How did the USS Reprisal sink?
- 📝 Why were "holding out" outposts a feature of the European war in 1944-5 but not 1940-1?
- 📝 Did any Chinese scholars propose a heliocentric model?
- 📝 Evidence of diets that were exclusively vegetarian
- 📝 Can you identify this military uniform?
- 📝 Which Luftwaffe units participated in the raid on Manchester on 11 March 1941?
- 📝 Explain the symbols in the relief of Thoth raising Seti I in the Temple of Seti I at Abydos
- 📝 Has any music act ever topped the Beatles in sales?
- 📝 Help identify this poster of early 1900's movie with a woman sitting on a bench and a man behind holding her arm
- 📝 Historical examples of advanced societies that abruptly abandoned or changed religions?
- 📝 How did Nazi Germany produce such an impressive portfolio of officers for WW2?
- 📝 Did iron age Britons still use the "ritual" sites built by their neolithic predecessors?
- 📝 Was there a King of England, or an heir to the throne, in 1831 who idolized Michael Faraday?
- 📝 On 15 October 1810 the 92nd Regiment were billeted in ruined houses at Crozendera, Portugal. Can anyone pinpoint this location?
- 📝 What was this building and what happend to it?
- 📝 Liking and disliking among the Napoleonic Marshalls of the Empire
- 📝 Why didn't North American tribes use bog iron?
- 📝 Are the Samaritans descendants of Israel's lost tribes, and so rightfully considered Israelites?
- 📝 Why Europe became more developed although metal was first discovered and used in Asia/Africa?
- 📝 History of calendar of different culture
- 📝 Were dissident KPD members ratted out to the Gestapo?
- 📝 The fate of children fathered by US Soldiers in the UK during WW2
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How culpable was Captain Smith for the Titanic disaster?
- 📝 In the first half of 20th century, how was gold inspected for authenticity?
- 📝 How profitable was India for the British Empire in the 1800s?
- 📝 How common was it for people to live 80+ years in the 17th century?
- 📝 How common was it for un-documented ships to bring settlers to the American colonies 1700-1750
- 📝 What was the actual cause of the disaster for the Royal Navy’s battlecruisers in the Battle of Jutland?
- 📝 In the Soviet Union, how was payment enforced for public transportation?
- 📝 How common was it for Americans to visit Europe in the late 19th century?
- 📝 How was the safety of allied leaders ensured in transportation for conferences during WW2?
- 📝 How common was the German desire for revenge for the humiliation of 1918 armistice?
- 📝 How difficult was Muraviev's amassing of troops for the forcing of the Treaty of Aigun, and what effects on development did it have?
- 📝 In Montgomery, Alabama, how common was it to be arrested for sitting in the incorrect section of the bus?
- 📝 How was the Karwendel railway important to Germany's plans for WW1?
- 📝 How common among Abolitionists was the goal of complete civil equality for Blacks?
- 📝 How possible was it for colonizers to sail up the Paraná River to today's states of Paraná and São Paulo?
- 📝 How was it possible for the Ukrainian SSR to be one of the founding members of the UN if it was basically a Province of the USSR?
- 📝 Credible historic description of how the daily life was for the middle-class during the financial crisis of 1929
- 📝 How was Hoche and Binding's text, arguing for the murder of certain disabled people, received within eugenics movements worldwide?
- 📝 How successful was Bismarck in winning support for his domestic policies in the years 1878 to 1890?
- 📝 During the breakup of the Soviet Union, on what basis was citizenship granted or withheld for each of the fifteen new republics?
- 📝 Was it militarily possible to "island hop" the Philippines if not for MacArthur?
- 📝 How serious was Fermat's statement about the ancients?
- 📝 How and when was the modern company ownership structure invented?
- 📝 What was the reason for Soviet troops to withdraw from Yugoslavia in World War II?
- 📝 How was the United States able to produce excellent tanks in 1942?
- 📝 If the Ch’in dynasty was so short-lived, why was China named for it?
- 📝 Is there evidence to suggest the "war on drugs" was a cover for class warfare?
- 📝 What was the plan for an abort of the Enola Gay's mission to drop the atomic bomb?
- 📝 What was the economic basis for West Berlin?
- 📝 How did medieval manors handle population growth? Was there room for more fields to be ploughed?