Are there any records of javelin throwing techniques from antiquity? For example, ancient Greece, such as peltasts?

score:5

Accepted answer

In terms of surviving records, it seems there are almost none. In the paper, Recreating the Ancient Greek Javelin Throw: How Far Was the Javelin Thrown?. The authors observe:

We have no direct records of how far the ancient Greeks could have thrown the javelin in their athletic festivals. To our knowledge ... the only reference to the distance that the javelin was thrown in antiquity is from Statius in the Thebaid, where the distance of a chariot racecourse at Nemea is described as being β€œthree times a bow shot and four times a javelin throw: "finem iacet inter utrumque quale quater iaculo spatium, ter harundine vincas" (6.353). However, we do not know the precise distance of the race course, but we can make an educated guess.

The paper cited by the authors above, Greek Javelin Throwing by H. A. Harris, is available to read online at JSTOR. This paper includes discussions of the Greek use of javelins in both war and at festivals which you might find helpful.

In the context of your question, one observation by Harris seems particularly apposite:

... there was one fundamental difference between Greek javelin throwing and our own: the Greeks, both in war and in the stadium always threw with the help of a thong ...

Although some caution in drawing too many conclusions is appropriate since he goes on to note that:

The evidence is very scanty indeed.

Harris may also be of some help in regard to your speculation about the differences between distance throwing and target throwing. On page 30 of the paper cited above, Harris makes the point that:

The purpose of the thong in warfare was undoubtedly to secure extra force and range. Its use involves some loss of accuracy in aim, but the function of the missile spear in post-Homeric ancient warfare was probably that of the machine gun rather than the sniper's bullet.

  • (my emphasis)

As regards experimental archaeology, there has been a great deal of research over the years. One paper that is available online as a pdf that might be of particular interest in this context is Efficacy of the Ankyle in Increasing the Distance of the Ancient Greek Javelin Throw, by Steven Ross Murray, William A. Sands, Nathan A. Keck, and Douglas A. O'Roark.

To identify other resources (including many that are not available online, but which may be available to you at a local library), Id suggest running a search on Google Scholar using the terms Greek "javelin" experimental archaeology

Upvote:3

The atlatl is a Mesoamerican tool for spear throwing that has been used in war, hunting, and fishing alike. The use and effectiveness of thrown spears were attested by the chronicler of Mexico's conquest, Bernal Diaz del Castillo. An article from 1891 which I have not obtained, The Mexican Atlatl or Spear-Thrower, includes "several descriptions of the manner of hurling the weapon, cited from old Spanish writers". Atlatls appear in codices Zouche-Nuttall and Borgia:

enter image description here

Experimental archaeology is very interested in the atlatl. The 27th Annual World Atlatl Competition happened earlier this year. Some relevant papers include:

  • Experiments in the function and performance of the weighted atlatl (1986)
  • Spearthrower performance: ethnographic and experimental research (1997)
  • Weapon trials: the atlatl and experiments in hunting technology (2010)
  • How atlatl darts behave: beveled points and the relevance of controlled experiments (2015)
  • Atlatl Dart Velocity: Accurate Measurements and Implications for Paleoindian and Archaic Archaeology (2017)

As we know, velocity kills, so extra leverage to increase projectile velocity increases range and deadliness, if at the cost of some precision. However, atlatls' use in hunting suggests that the spear throws can still be well aimed.

More post

Search Posts

Related post