Did the Pope's crossbow and archery bans have any effect?
score:18
Concerning the question
-Did any contemporaries actually take note of the ruling?
An article cited by the OP brings up a couple of possible groups which may have complied with this, The Holy Roman Empire under Conrad III and the region referred to as Flanders. So we can look at the extent of any ranged weapon bans in those locations.
- Conrad III
This source, International Encyclopedia of Military History edited by James C. Bradford, while discussing crossbows, confirms the information that Conrad III, (Holy Roman Emperor from 1138-1152),
condemned their use in his domains.
(The same source mentions that the Magna Carta in 1215 banned the use of crossbows specifically.)
Conrad III is also mentioned in an article which appeared in The Nation, (in 1961), entitled 'UNILATERAL DISARMAMENT: 1139 A.D. - - by Jack Rothman',
"So, moved by humane considerations, the Lateran Council, which advised the Pope on secular affairs, in 1139 declared the crossbow 'a weapon hateful to God.' The ban was observed unilaterally by Conrad III of Germany, who forbade its use in his armies for thirteen years, meanwhile trying to persuade other powers to do likewise. He failed, and by 1152 Conrad's soldiers were again using the crossbow."
So it appears that Conrad made some attempt at abiding by the Popes wishes (at least concerning the use of crossbows),but was only was able to uphold this ban for 13 years, and then resumed the use of crossbows as well. No information here concerning the inclusion or not of long bows in this , and this article,as most that I found, seems to also interpret the papal ruling as mainly directed at crossbows.
- Flanders
Concerning Flanders, which was another area mentioned as banning ranged weapons, this ban is brought up in the book Archery and Crossbow Guilds in Medieval Flanders, 1300-1500 By Laura Crombie. In this text,it states:
In England all men were required, from 1363, to practice archery at the local butts each week. In contrast, Flemish towns passed laws against anyone using bows or crossbows, and later guns, within their walls...
It later mentions that shooting outside the city walls was allowed, so it seems this was not a ban on the use of these weapons in war such as canon 29 seems to indicate, but just local ordinances to make it safer in the city limits. (The presence of archery and crossbow related guilds there would also seem to agree that military use was still allowed). So the above Flanders reference, though it did actually specifically include bows, seems to have little relation to the ban from the Second Council of the Lateran.
So some sources indicate that the Holy Roman Empire under Conrad III, (who took power in 1138) did try to follow the ruling (which was in in April 1139), it was for only a limited time at best, while others (apparently everyone else) 'skirted the rules'. Most information I find seems to be treating this as a crossbow ban, regardless of our interpretation of the actual text of the Canon. (I have seen several sources listing it as slingers and archers). I have not found any mention of an actual ban of the use of bows (beside the later Flemish cities reference).
Upvote:8
In the book War and Chivalry: The Conduct and Perception of War in England and Normandy, the author claims that the ban was simply ignored everywhere.
Clerics were indeed correct in recognizing the lethal qualities of the crossbow, which claimed many knightly an even royal victims in the eleventh and welgth centuries. Yet the crossbow was far from an innovation at the time of its ban by the Second Lateran Council, and it is important to note that the canon also forbids the user of ordinary bows. Churchmen were not outlawing the crossbow as a deadly novelty, but, as an extension of the Peace and Truce, they were seeking to prohibit all missile weapons which could inflict such casualties among Christian warriors. It was, however, this very effectivneess that caused commanders utterly to ignore this ban. Archers and crossbowmen continued to form an integral element of Anglo-Norman and Angevin armies, playing a key role in both battle and siege warfare.
The author also lists Richard of England and Philip Augustus of France as examples of commanders who used large numbers of crossbows. On Richard however, I did also find an excerpt on Google books which says:
In the reign of Stephen, in 1139, the second council of Lateran prohibited their use; and some historians assert, that they were not again used in this country till the reign of Richard I., whose death, occasioned by one at Chaluz, was considered as a judgment on his impiety.
So perhaps the ban on crossbows was "obeyed", but only until people went to war against other Christians and found crossbows useful. Meanwhile archers were so important and ingrained no one ever gave them up despite what the church said.
More post
- 📝 Can you identify this Soviet uniform from the 1970s to ~90s
- 📝 How was iron obtained in ancient times?
- 📝 What were the regimental colors of the 18th NY Infantry Regiment?
- 📝 What did the Nazis do with proselytes to Judaism?
- 📝 What is the historical accuracy of birth of lord Sri Krishna
- 📝 How did Medieval armies survive the use of mail armor in the deserts of the Middle East?
- 📝 What factors contributed to the popularity of Eastern cultures in the USA in late 20th century?
- 📝 How effective were archers/ slingers / skirmishers in Greek, Roman and Medieval Period?
- 📝 What uniform is this?
- 📝 Did Albert Einstein really receive this rejection letter from the University of Bern?
- 📝 In England in 1700, would defending property with lethal force be illegal at all?
- 📝 Is taking away decorations of traitors a normal modus operandi?
- 📝 "More Frenchmen bore arms for the Axis than for the Allies during the Second World War"?
- 📝 Why is communism hated by some ppl?
- 📝 Why is USS Saratoga (CV3) nicknamed "Sara Maru"?
- 📝 Was Eumenes really a non Greek by birth?
- 📝 In WWI, which countries used prisoners as soldiers?
- 📝 Why did the Western Roman Empire collapse but not the Eastern Roman Empire?
- 📝 Are there any historically significant volcanic eruptions that predate Akrotiri?
- 📝 Were people buried in the 19th century with a cloth around their head if so why?
- 📝 Was Switzerland pressured either by Allies or Axis to take part in World War 2 at any time?
- 📝 Why doesn’t Cuba's flag have any communist symbolism?
- 📝 Why did the Federalist Party collapse?
- 📝 Have there been any joint US-Russia/Soviet military engagements post WW II?
- 📝 What was the typical error with dead reckoning navigation?
- 📝 Why did the United States drop a uranium bomb instead of a plutonium bomb on Hiroshima?
- 📝 How did Gothic differ from Baroque architecture?
- 📝 Power of Prussian artillery pieces during the Napoleonic Wars
- 📝 Were British officers able to return home after the American Revolution?
- 📝 Was the Dargah Shrine at Ajmer built over a Hindu temple?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Did the Pope's crossbow and archery bans have any effect?
- 📝 Did any nation have a demonstrable qualitative advantage in their soldiers of the 18th century, and how did they achieve this?
- 📝 Did any British working class men have the vote before 1918?
- 📝 Did the U.S. and Soviet Union have a submarine battle in 1968?
- 📝 Why did Stalin and the Soviet leadership have Leon Trotsky assassinated?
- 📝 Did the Soviet Union or its satellite states have any broadcast propaganda media for an international audience?
- 📝 Why did the Chinese Nationalist party members go to the island of Taiwan and not to any other island?
- 📝 Why did the Monitor and Merrimac (aka Virginia) have such radically different designs?
- 📝 What effect did the Attack on Mers-el-Kébir have on Great Britain's international relations during WW2?
- 📝 Did any leader say "We may have lost the battle, but not the war"?
- 📝 Before European influence circa 1600, did any Chinese believe the Earth was spherical, and did they ever try to measure it?
- 📝 How did people say “I have to go to the bathroom” before the bathroom and pipes were common?
- 📝 Apart from the Inuit, and candlefish on the northwest coast, did pre-Columbian America have lamps or candles?
- 📝 What effect did the Bronze Age collapse have on India?
- 📝 Which European countries did not have a revolution in the aftermath of the French Revolution and why?
- 📝 Did more Jews live in Poland than any other country, prior to the Holocaust, because of how Polish laws and people regarded Jews?
- 📝 Did the Reformation have any impact in Orthodox countries?
- 📝 Did Spain and the Republic of China (Kuomintang) have diplomatic relations between 1931 and 1939? Were they friendly or unfriendly?
- 📝 What effect did awareness of devastating bombing at home have on the fighting spirit of German troops on the Eastern front?
- 📝 How many trucks did Russia and Germany have at the start of Barbarossa?
- 📝 Between the 7 Years War and 1776, was there any effort to have the colonies represented in Parliament?
- 📝 Did the Nazis have any unique or especially effective economic policies?
- 📝 Did the Portuguese and the Spanish have slaves on European soil working for them?
- 📝 Why did Empress Elizabeth and Catherine the Great of Russia have such different policies toward Frederick the Great?
- 📝 What effect did the Mafia have during World War 2?
- 📝 What alternate north-south supply routes did the Soviet Union have when the Volga and Stalingrad were under attack?
- 📝 Did Viet Nam suffer a famine any time during the 1980s? And if not, how close was it to famine?
- 📝 What access did people in the Warsaw pact countries have to Western television and radio?
- 📝 Did either Chinese government (Beijing or Taipei) operate an administrative structure in the Kowloon Walled City at any time between 1898 and 1994?
- 📝 Why did Germany have so many important scientists and thinkers around the turn of the 20th century?