How can I do G-d's will if I don't believe in divine command theory?

score:2

Accepted answer

There is a simplicity in God such that all His attributes work together harmoniously. By creating us in His image, there is in us a corresponding integrity (to the extent that such integrity has not been violated by sin).

Thus God's nature, words, actions, commands and all the rest are in harmony. Goodness in essence, nature, commands and such are all connected. Most theories of causality break down when speaking of the Godhead because God created time. There is no before and after in His "history" so no action can cause a subsequent action in the way we normally think of causation. A static causation is more like a blueprint showing how the pieces are assembled.

So God has created us with a conscience. An intact, properly functioning conscience or one restored by the Holy Spirit delights in doing what is good. God's commands are written on our hearts. Thus the conscience produces joy when we follow God's will or guilt when we oppose that will. Human Conscience and God's will are prepared in parallel to work together, as well as every other part of the moral and volitional apparatus that He has built into us.

Upvote:1

Not only does this seem backwards, but its very backwardness suggests the answer.

I don't believe that something becomes Good because God wills it. I believe that God's nature is such that what He wills is Good. Now, one has to be careful here with cause and effect as there is a clear possibility of heresy, but at risk of oversimplifying, I would assert that the proper relation is closer to one of intertwined cause. More practically, we learn that something is Good through knowing that God wills that thing.

More to the question... there is no such thing as a universe where God wills something that is not Good, because that would violate God's nature. (Keep in mind that we're in "can God make a rock so large He can't lift it" territory. "Omnipotence" doesn't mean God can violate fundamental truths, but this is not a limitation on omnipotence.) One might argue whether these unalterable truths themselves result from God's nature, but the point is that they do not arise from any volitional cause. They simply are.

IIUC, that makes me a "non-believers in divine command theories", and therefore qualified to answer?

It should also, however, make the answer obvious. Doing God's Will is beneficial because that Will is Good... but, while being united with God's Will may (and I would argue, does) have its own benefits, doing Good is inherently beneficial.

To give a more specific example, could God will that people commit adultery? Perhaps, although such a universe would necessarily be one in which adultery is Good, and thus would probably be quite different from our own.

More post

Search Posts

Related post