Which of Luther's 95 Theses are still potentially valid critiques of Roman Catholicism?

Upvote:1

The reason indulgences are granted has more to do with the spiritual disciplines in the repentant sinner's relationship with Christ than with any ability of the Church to promise release from purgatory. If a person concerns himself with choosing rightly, prayer, scripture study, participation in the Church and the sacraments, he will become detached from sin and therefore require no further purging at the time of his death. The grace of God is available through spiritual disciplines and right actions and that grace is enough to keep us from sinning if we are continually walking with the Lord. The actions required to receive an indulgence are designed to help one develop habits that dispose the child of God to intimacy with Him. Luther's statementthat few are completely detached from sin is an observation, not an argument. It does not follow that one should not strive for such detachment from sin, and conversely attachment to Christ.

Upvote:2

Well, it was worth it to finally read those in their entirety and not try to pick apart individual portions. It would seem that you're correct in saying that the church has changed her position on indulgences. However, the church has not changed her position on papal supremacy, only refined it.

Today a plenary indulgence is granted for some prayers, bible reading, and other timely things (like visiting a cemetery during November). The normal requirements must also be met confession, reception of the Eucharist and prayer for the Pope's intentions. One must also have a complete detachment from sin, that's not easy. Luther says there's very few (23), he's probably right.

Upvote:8

The 95 These are not 95 points of criticism of Catholic doctrine. That is, Luther was not identitifying 95 different doctrines and/or practices of the Catholic church that he disapproved of. Really there are all about one practice of the Catholic church: the selling of indulgences, i.e. telling people that they could buy a "reduced sentence" in purgatory by giving money to the church.

I don't claim to be any sort of expert on the practices of the Catholic Church today, but to the best of my knowledge they are no longer selling indulgences, directly or indirectly. You might find individual cases where a priest or other representative of the church says or implies that someone can win some favor with God by making a big donation, but these are individual mistakes or abuses and not Catholic policy. Therefore, I think pretty much none of the criticisms in the 95 Theses apply today.

BTW, many of the 95 Theses are not, of themselves, criticisms of the Catholic church. For example #1, "Our Lord and Master Jesus Christ, when He said Poenitentiam agite, willed that the whole life of believers should be repentance." Or #94, "Christians are to be exhorted that they be diligent in following Christ, their Head, through penalties, deaths, and hell;" I haven't counted how many are criticisms of church practice and how many are points Luther is trying to establish along the way.

Also note that Luther carefully worded many to avoid overtly criticizing the Catholic church and especially the pope. For example #48, "Christians are to be taught that the pope, in granting pardons, needs, and therefore desires, their devout prayer for him more than the money they bring."

More post

Search Posts

Related post