Does SN44.9 imply an intermediate state between births?
score:4
Piya Tan has an essay on the topic here: Is Rebirth Immediate? (SD 2.17)
And a commentary and translation of the sutta here, Kutūhala,sālā Sutta, which includes "To Vaccha’s second and final question, the Buddha makes his famous statement on the intermediate state."
My paraphrase of the essay (if I've read it correctly) is that:
- The Abhidhamma and commentaries denies an intermediate state, on not very strong grounds (e.g. that the Buddha didn't teach explicitly that there is such a thing)
- Many people (Theravada and other schools) believe in such a state anyway
- There are suttas (which it quotes) which may be describing an intermediate state
- Other sources include the Chinese Agamas, and the Sanskrit, the Milinda Panha
That essay totals about 15 pages -- you can read the details.
It quotes Ven. Sujato's commentary on The Kutūhala,sāla Sutta:
From this we can conclude that the Buddha, following ideas current in his time—for Vacchagotta was a non-Buddhist wanderer (paribbājaka)—accepted that there was some kind of interval between one life and the next. During this time, when one has “laid down” this body, but is not yet reborn in another, one is sustained by craving, like a flame tossed by the wind is sustained by air. The simile suggests, perhaps, that the interval is a short one; but the purpose of the simile is to illustrate the dependent nature of the period, not the length of time it takes. While a fire is burning normally, it is sustained by a complex of factors, such as fuel, oxygen, and heat. But when a tongue of flame is momentarily tossed away from the source fire, it can last only a short while, and in that time it is tenuously sustained by the continued supply of oxygen. Similarly in our lives, we are sustained by food, sense stimulus, and so on, but in the in-between, it is only the slender thread of craving that propels us forward. The difference is, of course, that the flame will easily go out, while the fuel of craving propels the unawakened inexorably into future rebirth.
More post
- 📝 Which Buddhists denominations agree with the difference between pain and suffering as in many DBT texts? Which disagree?
- 📝 If a substance enhanced the ability to stay mindful, and didnt cause intoxication or carelessness, would it still violate the fifth precept?
- 📝 How does one Practice Sila?
- 📝 Wrong meanings commonly associated with the notion of Gratitude
- 📝 What is called a promise in Buddhism?
- 📝 The Nature of Viññāṇa as a Nidāna in the Cycle of Paṭiccasamuppāda
- 📝 Spinning sensation during meditation?
- 📝 Has anybody tried meditating forehead to forehead? Or communicated with others via meditation?
- 📝 Accuracy of suttas
- 📝 Is there any online serious community of Dhamma practitioners to join?
- 📝 When it comes to commercial products, is there harm to choosing a more beautiful and well-designed option?
- 📝 Pali question: "seven more life times at most"
- 📝 Sutta request: One should be fed before being able to listen to a Dhamma talk
- 📝 Does evolution contradict Buddhism?
- 📝 In Buddhism, is the effect ontologically independent of the cause?
- 📝 Sanskrit and Pali roots
- 📝 Losing enlightenment
- 📝 Looking for mentions of karma related to actions taken while dreaming
- 📝 What is yoniso manasikara and ayoniso manasikara?
- 📝 What's the Jataka tale about a previous life of the Buddha sacrificing himself to get a dharma teaching (because dharma was so scarce and rare then)?
- 📝 What is meant by "possessed by spirits" in Buddhism?
- 📝 How does Buddhist (supra-mundane) Happiness differ from ‘mundane’ happiness?
- 📝 Finding Authentic Suttas
- 📝 Looking for a Buddhist story about trust
- 📝 Did Buddha had issues in meditation?
- 📝 Criticism of atman and the vessel analogy
- 📝 Are there any alternative formulations of the five skandas?
- 📝 How long does it take for one to remember a previous life in a sitting?
- 📝 Discrepancy between quality and consistency
- 📝 What is the purpose of the Mahayana 'emptiness' doctrine?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Does SN44.9 imply an intermediate state between births?
- 📝 Is there an intermediate state between death and rebirth in Theravada tradition?
- 📝 Does Zen distinguish between concentration and insight meditation?
- 📝 What is the intermediate state before birth (Gandhabba)?
- 📝 Does memory persist across different births of an individual?
- 📝 How does the buddhist teachings differentiate between reality and perception?
- 📝 State between Equanimity and 1st or 2nd or further path
- 📝 Does Jukai imply a student commitment to the preceptor?
- 📝 How does one know the difference between aversion and danger?
- 📝 Is it possible to exercise Metta to all or is Metta only a mental state only? If so how does one act to remain dispassionate?
- 📝 What kind of mental state does the meditation on four elements generate?
- 📝 Does truth of emptiness imply that nothing existent ever ends?
- 📝 How does the Bhavanga State relate to the Jhanas?
- 📝 Does MN9 imply a cyclic causation? How does it work?
- 📝 What is the difference between transcendental state of mind and Nirvana?
- 📝 Does the Samajivina Sutta imply that a Buddhist should only marry another Buddhist?
- 📝 Does illegal downloading or viewing of copyright material violate the second precept?
- 📝 How does stream entry occur?
- 📝 Masturbation: Does it break the 3rd precept?
- 📝 What are the differences between vipassana and mindfulness meditation?
- 📝 Where does a person go after attaining Nirvana?
- 📝 Does Zen Buddhism have canonical texts?
- 📝 Caught between two worlds
- 📝 Does studying mathematics or science lead to a practitioner of Buddhism acquiring wrong philosophical views and mental afflictions?
- 📝 What is the difference between craving and clinging?
- 📝 How does one practice mindfulness during thinking - e.g. thinking about how to solve a problem?
- 📝 How to disambiguate between various meditation practices?
- 📝 What exactly is the logical relation between the links in the twelvefold chain of Pratītyasamutpāda?
- 📝 Why does the Buddha call himself the Tathāgata?
- 📝 Does meditation increase productivity for software developers and related professions?