If teacher punishing student is also supposed bad karma?
score:2
Buddha did not do any violence. The suttas say:
it is true, Kesi, that it's not proper for a Tathagata to take life. But if a tamable person doesn't submit either to a mild training or to a harsh training or to a mild & harsh training, then the Tathagata doesn't regard him as being worth speaking to or admonishing.
Upvote:-1
Once a general asked buddha shouldnt criminals be punished The Buddha replied: "He who deserves punishment must be punished, and he who is worthy of favor must be favored. Yet at the same time he teaches to do no injury to any living being but to be full of love and kindness. These injunctions are not contradictory, for whosoever must be punished for the crimes which he has committed, suffers his injury not through the ill-will of the judge but on account of his evil-doing. His own acts have brought upon him the injury that the executer of the law inflicts. When a magistrate punishes, let him not harbor hatred in his breast, yet a murderer, when put do death, should consider that this is the fruit of his own act. As soon as he will understand that the punishment will purify his soul, he will no longer lament his fate but rejoice at it."
Upvote:0
If teacher punishing student is also supposed bad karma?
It depends on thoughts Chethanaham bikkawe kamman wadami (question on this can be found here). And only teacher knows what kind of thoughts were on his mind at that time.
Either school teacher or Buddhist teacher in monastery, if they would punish their students is also supposed bad karma even if it cause of bad behavior of students?
As said above, it doesn't matter from the student's side, it matters from teacher's side, because he owns his karma as a return to his own actions.
Upvote:0
We donot know karma and it's fruit. We aren't buddha. So this question is not right . If I give any answer for this question. I will give wrong answer beacuse I do not know karma.. I gave answer from memory. Book memory . Buddha memory.. Memory can not give right answer. My experience not book answer . If I punish any student..if I feel guilt for punishment. This is Not right. This is my anger. Angry man can't kind speech. This is voilence both inner voilence and outer voilence for students.
Upvote:1
It depends on how you punish. Buddha also punished.
=============
"If a tamable person doesn't submit either to a mild training or to a harsh training or to a mild & harsh training, then I kill him, Kesi."
https://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/an/an04/an04.111.than.html
More post
- 📝 How does the Nimitta occur?
- 📝 A path without long meditations?
- 📝 Devas and Asura?
- 📝 Who is the laughing Buddha?
- 📝 What is doctrine on ordinary daily posture?
- 📝 Is insisting on calling “consciousness” a real thing appropriate?
- 📝 Teachings on truthfulness
- 📝 Which discourses list the factors needed for becoming successful?
- 📝 How was my performance in the Fifth precept
- 📝 What is the difference between approaching the idea 'no-self' and the act to 'depersonalize'?
- 📝 How can I overcome the breathing trouble while meditating and increase concentration?
- 📝 To ordain in the west or in Asia?
- 📝 Is the space between thoughts an indicator of meditative calmness?
- 📝 Why is meditation pleasurable?
- 📝 How to chant the mantra Nam Myoho Renge Kyo?
- 📝 How should a married person get ordained in Theravada Buddhism?
- 📝 When did the Buddha get surrounded by lots of animals?
- 📝 Practice of my meditation
- 📝 Gratitude, Movement and Compassion
- 📝 Which Buddhist schools give importance to cultivation of Jhanas?
- 📝 Buddhism and theory of relativity
- 📝 In the Anapanasati Sutta what is meant by 'sensitive to rapture/bliss'?
- 📝 "Creativity Attacks" during meditation
- 📝 Has lord Buddha ever told something like this?
- 📝 Theravada buddhism and Mahayana buddhism
- 📝 Regarding Nicca and Anicca natures of Avidya and Prajna
- 📝 Is meditating when tired a waste of time?
- 📝 The Four Great References (AN 4.180)
- 📝 What do Birth, Age, and Death mean in the first noble truth?
- 📝 How does upaya (skillful means) feature in Tibetan Buddhism?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 If teacher punishing student is also supposed bad karma?
- 📝 How to deal with bad past karma that makes my current life miserable?
- 📝 What Bad Karma Awaits Adulterers?
- 📝 Won't bad karma cause a chain reaction?
- 📝 Is the only way to deal with the effects of your bad karma endurance?
- 📝 Killing a bigger animal causes more bad karma than killing a smaller animal?
- 📝 Can somebody remove their bad karma by believing that it doesn't exist?
- 📝 How can you use Q&A to gain good Karma and also aid to realize liberation
- 📝 If our present suffering is the result of bad karma from a prior life, what is the real present remedy for suffering in this life?
- 📝 Buddhism on paying for previous bad Karma
- 📝 Is it a bad heavy karma to criticize or give up your guru?
- 📝 Can a bad karma happen just only with a thought without any physical or verbal action?
- 📝 Is it bad karma if you are waiting for someone to die?
- 📝 Computers and Buddhist monks, offering computer to monk makes bad karma to both monk and donor?
- 📝 If someone constrain me to build my bad Karma or it wouln't be Karma?
- 📝 Proper way to ask a teacher to become their student
- 📝 Is it bad karma to think but not claim that one is enlightened, or just bad for your practice?
- 📝 Can bad karma be created and paid back in the same lifetime
- 📝 How bad is the karma of feeding meat to your children?
- 📝 I believe I have done bad things in a past life can I fix my curse that causes people to turn against me what kind of Karma is this?
- 📝 Is it bad karma if you say something that turns out to be false?
- 📝 Looking for a letter exchange between Zen Teacher and (female?) student
- 📝 Can good karma, bad karma or neither good and bad karma arise or not arise from not doing?
- 📝 Is the continuous effect of karma also sustained by karma?
- 📝 What we have to do for bad karma from a prior life?
- 📝 Relationship with bad parents (kamma and issues)
- 📝 Are actions in computer games bad for karma?
- 📝 Giving up bad friends
- 📝 Is there any such thing as a bad meditation?
- 📝 Doubts about Karma and/or Rebirth