"I want Happiness" / "Remove `I` and `want`" story
Upvote:0
I happen to think that short story is a good one, in a very Buddhist way, even if it is a very recent invention. Even the quote was originally authored in English, and not translated from an authentic Sanskrit or Chinese text... and it probably wasn't.
It is important to note that most "Buddhist" sutras, even those describing conversations with the Buddha, are not actually historical, biographical records of the historical Buddha Shakyamuni. Generally speaking, most sutras were written by monks centuries later, after coming out of a deep meditative trance. The Mahayana texts are extremely obvious about this; but even with the Theravada texts, and even the Pali Canon itself, it is it not clear how much was authored directly by Shakyamuni and his contemporaries.
And that's okay. The entire reason the Buddha taught was so that his disciples could meditate and achieve serenity and insight independently of Shakyamuni himself.
TLDR: Most historical Buddhist texts are "fake Buddha quotes" because that is the whole reason why Buddha founded the religion.
Upvote:1
If the story given above true? If not why not?
It's not canonical -- A man said to the Buddha, βI want Happiness.β is listed as one of the "fake Buddha quotes".
As for whether it's true, yes and no.
Yes to the extent that "wanting" is associated with unhappiness, though even there you might have to split hairs to distinguish between "unwholesome craving" versus a "wholesome desire for enlightenment" -- though even the wholesome desire is allayed once the goal is attained.
And no I guess it's not as simple as that -- it's like going to a doctor and saying, "I have cancer", and the doctor saying, "well take away the cancer then, problem solved" -- the Buddha was more helpful/detailed than that.
Also no because its "truth" depends on the definitions of various words, like "happiness", which are maybe just empty words.
More post
- π Should a Monk speak out in favor of doing good?
- π The Four Nutriments: what do the metaphors in SN 12.63 mean?
- π Why is my head going all Poltergeist on me
- π if rebirth/reincarnation is true then what is your first birth/incarnation?
- π Personal practice regarding stream entry
- π What is the most βgenuinely Buddhistβ kind of mindfulness?
- π When were Buddhist suttas written?
- π In the Anapanasati Sutta, what is the difference between mind and mental processes?
- π There is no benefit and there is no intrinsic positive nature in a pleasant sensation
- π Why is in the budda days, jhana seem so easily attainable but so hard now?
- π Sitting Meditation: not able to notice rise and fall of abdomen
- π Studying in nepal
- π Are learning signs and counterpart signs a must to enter jhana?
- π How do the VijΓ±Δna (Vinyana) get created?
- π Do Chinese-language publications about Zen Buddhism usually use Simplified or Traditional Chinese?
- π Samatha vs Vipassana. What are the mechanics?
- π Meditation outdoors
- π Was Devadaha a Sakyan town and were the Buddha's maternal relatives Sakyans?
- π Why are plants not sentient beings?
- π Sudden enlightenment & knowledge of the Abhidhamma
- π Does Buddhism accept Existence?
- π Is Buddhism "opposed" to striving, or working towards a goal that you really want
- π Working with hallucinogenic images during meditation
- π what is MahaggataαΉ citam? is it related to out of body experience?
- π How similar or different is Tantric Buddhism from Vijnana Bhairava of Kashmir Shaivism?
- π Metta's Intensity and Concentration
- π Questions about Chogyam Trungpa's unique presentation of the five skandhas?
- π Theravada and Mahayana - The Crucial Differences
- π What are the occasions did Panchasika or Pansilu meet the Buddha
- π What are the major Buddhist critiques of Christianity?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π "I want Happiness" / "Remove `I` and `want`" story
- π I want to understand the technicality of rebirth and what happens to conditioned self
- π Why does the mind always want to 'do something' and how to cultivate 'non-doing'?
- π Queen Mallika story and stream entry
- π The Buddha And The Beggar Story
- π Jataka Story Request: Mindfulness, Radiant Complexion and Grass Simile
- π Reference request: Where is this this story about a pair of shoes, a stupa, and virtuous actions?
- π I love life and I don't want to die. How to let go?
- π I want to pray and meditate like a Buddhist, but I do not know how because I am Arab and I have not found sources in Arabic so can you guide me
- π Looking for the source of a story about the Buddha and a lady who looked the other way
- π Is killing vermin and insects justifiable?
- π What are the differences between vipassana and mindfulness meditation?
- π Relationship with bad parents (kamma and issues)
- π Are Vajrayana and Tibetan Buddhism the same thing?
- π Comparison of Nirvana, Tao and Brahman/Atma
- π How to deal with people and handle rude language?
- π As a Buddhist with a Muslim family, community, and background... how do you integrate/cope?
- π How concentrated is access concentration and how would one recognise it?
- π How are 'conceit' and 'identity-view' not the same?
- π Meditation and 'not trying to change anything'
- π How do I slow down and start living according to my values? How do I change the direction of my life?
- π Does studying mathematics or science lead to a practitioner of Buddhism acquiring wrong philosophical views and mental afflictions?
- π How compatible are the beliefs of atheists and Buddhism?
- π Strange feelings after meditation and mindfulness practice?
- π What is the difference between craving and clinging?
- π Is Buddhism "opposed" to striving, or working towards a goal that you really want
- π What are the differences/similarities in the concept of faith as used in Buddhism and Christianity?
- π What's Buddhism view on choice, choicelesness and causality?
- π Is there a story or a mentioning about masturbation in the Buddhist teachings?
- π Does meditation increase productivity for software developers and related professions?