Kamma and (psychiatric) delusions / madness
Upvote:0
I'm not sure I agree with jathin's answer. There was a case in my country a few years ago, where someone on a bus cut off someone else's head. They did that, because they thought that they were sitting next to a devil. The criminal justice trial found them "not guilty of murder by reason of diminished responsibility", they were remanded for psychiatric care, and later released (with anti-psychotic medication).
I'm not sure I know about kamma but I think that intention follows from view, and if your view is psychotic (e.g. if you think you're sitting next to a devil) then I'm not sure. I slightly doubt whether Buddhism would recommend you kill even a "devil" if you meet one: but still.
I think that the Vinaya (see page 74 through 86) identifies what constitutes murder:
- Object: the victim must have been human
- Intention and perception: the assailant must have intended to cause death
- Effort: the assailant must have done something to cause death
- Result: the victim had to actually die as a result
I'm not sure whether the Vinaya rule is the same as "kamma", but I'd argue that psychosis may prevent intention and/or perception.
In my country, an adult who is psychotic may be given a court-appointed legal guardian -- that is, if they're unable to make informed decisions, if they cannot give informed consent, because they are:
- Unable to understand the choices available to them
- Unable to understand the likely consequences of each choice.
The first story of the Dhammapada is about someone who couldn't see with their eyes. Maybe someone with psychosis cannot properly see with their mind (and cannot form criminal intent).
Upvote:2
"The Pali term Karma literally means action or doing. Any kind of intentional action whether mental, verbal, or physical, is regarded as Karma"
You have to look at the action (good or bad) and the consequence( Kamma & vipaka). whether one has a sound mind or unsound mind doesn't matter, without intention there is no action.
Even a person suffering from psychosis uses his mind to do things, so without thoughts nothing good or bad happens( the thoughts may be abnormal,incomplete,unclear or confusing) ,but a person with psychosis may not feel the consequences like a normal person ,so the magnitude of suffering may differ for the same actions committed by different people.
More post
- π Might be possible to gain highest bliss without a loyal relationship?
- π How does the experience of "realisation of Sunyata" differ from "realisation of Anatta"?
- π Within TheravΔda tradition, what are the differences in doctrine and practice between schools and sects around the world?
- π Is there a proper English word to call Brahmas?
- π Ambitions - Are they Real or just an Illusion
- π What is Metta-BhavanaΒ and how does one practice it?
- π What is a headman?
- π How to find specific lessons in Zen Buddhism?
- π Any advice for beginners about Vipassana traditions?
- π Can contemplation of the four noble truths lead to penetration of them?
- π Which of the five hindrance does 'comparison' fall in?
- π Anger management - How to manage bad temper?
- π Was the doctrine of 'Anatta', accepted as doctrine by modern Buddhism, actually taught by the Buddha?
- π Which case is "I am a professor" with identity view?
- π Lack of objective thinking in Buddhist practitionners
- π How to concentrate to suppress hindrances?
- π Did the Buddha state that there is only one way, and state/imply that any other path (such as those practiced by yogis) was futile?
- π What is arupa jhana (5th jhana)?
- π Anatta in Tibetan Buddhism (How can we reconcile it with the Tulku?)
- π Secular, Tradition or the pathway of the branches
- π Buddhism about the Big Bang and Science in general
- π Girimananda sutta
- π Was Buddha had a expected food poisoning?
- π Are there research based or scientific explanation on the working of AbhiΓ±Γ±Δ / Iddhi?
- π Can a lay person become an Arahant according to the Suttas?
- π How to deal with fixation towards an old relationship?
- π Where can I find video Dharma talks?
- π If Theravada doesn't posit the selflessness of phenomena, then how to interpret SN 22.95?
- π Happiness vs. Euphoria from a Buddhist's point of view
- π What is mind contain of?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- π Kamma and (psychiatric) delusions / madness
- π Kamma and right livelihood in a modern business environment
- π About mental diseases and kamma
- π Feelings and kamma and sankhara , am I bound for the rest of my life
- π The illusions and delusions of the world
- π Isn't giving to attain good Kamma "greedy" and therefore Unwholesome (akusala)?
- π What is this saying about the relationship between Kamma and Dana?
- π Kamma and sankharas
- π Hereditary illness and kamma
- π Can the same kamma cetana and action lead to somewhat different future physical consequences (the physical aspect of the kamma-vipaka)
- π Visual representation of mind and kamma
- π No more kamma and vipaka for Noble Ones?
- π Kamma and the Physical
- π Is killing vermin and insects justifiable?
- π What are the differences between vipassana and mindfulness meditation?
- π Relationship with bad parents (kamma and issues)
- π Are Vajrayana and Tibetan Buddhism the same thing?
- π Comparison of Nirvana, Tao and Brahman/Atma
- π How to deal with people and handle rude language?
- π As a Buddhist with a Muslim family, community, and background... how do you integrate/cope?
- π How concentrated is access concentration and how would one recognise it?
- π How are 'conceit' and 'identity-view' not the same?
- π Meditation and 'not trying to change anything'
- π How do I slow down and start living according to my values? How do I change the direction of my life?
- π Does studying mathematics or science lead to a practitioner of Buddhism acquiring wrong philosophical views and mental afflictions?
- π How compatible are the beliefs of atheists and Buddhism?
- π Strange feelings after meditation and mindfulness practice?
- π What is the difference between craving and clinging?
- π What are the differences/similarities in the concept of faith as used in Buddhism and Christianity?
- π What's Buddhism view on choice, choicelesness and causality?