Was the Buddha harsh?
score:8
This question is addressed in the Abhaya Sutta from the Buddha himself, on the topic of Right Speech.
Your question should fall under "In the case of words that the Tathagata knows to be factual, true, beneficial, but unendearing & disagreeable to others, he has a sense of the proper time for saying them." (Abhaya Sutta).
From your same link on the Mahatanhasankhaya Sutta, you can read the commentary by Thanissaro Bhikkhu:
The Buddha calls Sāti into his presence, and after ascertaining that Sāti will not abandon his view even when reprimanded by the Buddha himself, he abandons Sāti as too recalcitrant to teach, and turns to cross-question the monks as to the relevant right view of how consciousness functions in the process leading to repeated birth.
The Buddha's treatment of Sāti might seem harsh, but he is actually acting out of compassion for the monks in the assembly, in case any of them might be swayed by Sāti's position. Seeing Sāti as a lost cause, the Buddha doesn't want this lost cause to cause further losses among the other monks. We have to remember that during the Buddha's lifetime there were no written accounts of his teachings; the monks and nuns all had to rely on their memory of what they had heard directly from him or through word-of-mouth from fellow members of the Saṅgha. Thus the Buddha saw the need to establish orthodoxy whenever a member of the Saṅgha was espousing false interpretations of his teaching.
The Buddha also discusses this in the Kesi Sutta which is summarized here by Thanissaro Bhikku:
Once, when a horse trainer came to see the Buddha, the Buddha asked him how he trained his horses. The trainer said that some horses responded to gentle training, others to harsh training, others required both harsh and gentle training, but if a horse didn't respond to either type of training, he'd kill the horse to maintain the reputation of his teachers' lineage. Then the trainer asked the Buddha how he trained his students, and the Buddha replied, "In the same way." Some students responded to gentle criticism, others to harsh criticism, others to a mixture of the two, but if a student didn't respond to either type of criticism, he'd kill the student. This shocked the horse trainer, but then the Buddha explained what he meant by "killing": He wouldn't train the student any further, which essentially killed the student's opportunity to grow in the practice.
Upvote:4
Here is a case of the Buddha himself justifying his speaking harsh words with a for-their-own-good type explanation from the Abhaya Sutta:
Just yesterday, lord, I went to Nigantha Nataputta and... he said to me...'Come now, prince. Go to Gotama the contemplative and on arrival say this: "Lord, would the Tathagata say words that are unendearing & disagreeable to others?"... Just as if a two-horned chestnut were stuck in a man's throat: he would not be able to swallow it down or spit it up. In the same way, when Gotama the contemplative is asked this two-pronged question by you, he won't be able to swallow it down or spit it up.'
Now at that time a baby boy was lying face-up on the prince's lap. So the Blessed One said to the prince, "What do you think, prince: If this young boy, through your own negligence or that of the nurse, were to take a stick or a piece of gravel into its mouth, what would you do?"
"I would take it out, lord. If I couldn't get it out right away, then holding its head in my left hand and crooking a finger of my right, I would take it out, even if it meant drawing blood. Why is that? Because I have sympathy for the young boy."
"In the same way, prince:
(1) In the case of words that the Tathagata knows to be unfactual, untrue, unbeneficial (or: not connected with the goal), unendearing & disagreeable to others, he does not say them.
(2) In the case of words that the Tathagata knows to be factual, true, unbeneficial, unendearing & disagreeable to others, he does not say them.
(3) In the case of words that the Tathagata knows to be factual, true, beneficial, but unendearing & disagreeable to others, he has a sense of the proper time for saying them.
(4) In the case of words that the Tathagata knows to be unfactual, untrue, unbeneficial, but endearing & agreeable to others, he does not say them.
(5) In the case of words that the Tathagata knows to be factual, true, unbeneficial, but endearing & agreeable to others, he does not say them.
(6) In the case of words that the Tathagata knows to be factual, true, beneficial, and endearing & agreeable to others, he has a sense of the proper time for saying them. Why is that? Because the Tathagata has sympathy for living beings.1
More post
- 📝 How to explain to someone with no knowledge about Buddhism what is meant by "extinguishing" the self?
- 📝 How to get to Nirvana?
- 📝 Pleasure in Shower
- 📝 Is there a way to wipe out ones Karma?
- 📝 Upostha Sila in normal daily life
- 📝 Does pasteurization count as cooking in prep of juices for after noon?
- 📝 Serious asthma and meditation, how much should I struggle? Is anxiety at night ok?
- 📝 What does one need to give, for liberation?
- 📝 MN 38: How do aging-&-death cease when the eye sees a form?
- 📝 How can Name-and-form be the cause and condition for the manifestation of the consciousness aggregate?
- 📝 How do Buddhists who believe in a non momentary conventional self during life account for karma without enlightenment?
- 📝 What did Buddha mean by the words "tranquillising the bodily formation" in the Anapanasati Sutta?
- 📝 Is the experience of suffering or enjoyment completely reducible to physics e.g. such as in materialist views i.e. materialism?
- 📝 Is there a source that Dalai Lama wants scientists to invent a "meditation machine"?
- 📝 What does,'I establish mindfulness in front of me' mean?
- 📝 Why do we need to work?
- 📝 Online Funeral vs Actual Funeral (Buddhism)
- 📝 Dhammapada – What is the "beyond"?
- 📝 Is insecticide treated mosquito nets against 1st precept?
- 📝 Are "Saya Asadharana Nana" part of Nibbana?
- 📝 Awakening into meditative state
- 📝 Is this considered wrong? (Related to art)
- 📝 Can the elements of Buddhist Cosmology be confirmed?
- 📝 Literal translation of Aṣṭasāhasrikā Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra
- 📝 What is the view of Buddhism in correcting others' view in spite of their willingness to accept it?
- 📝 Danger of Body Scan Meditation
- 📝 Where in the Pali Canon does it give examples of right livelihood and it's opposite
- 📝 If a Buddha exists then can a private buddha arise or exist somewhere in the same world system without having learned from the current Buddha?
- 📝 Why is contributing to the market demand for meat not wrong?
- 📝 Animisa Locana Pooja. Is it really what it is?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Was Vipassana discovered by the Buddha (Siddhartha)?
- 📝 How was the Buddha Jayanti edition of the Tripitaka derived?
- 📝 Was the Buddha harsh?
- 📝 Why do Buddhists believe that the Buddha was enlightened, despite that he claimed it himself?
- 📝 Where is the story that Buddha was worried about a monk who meditated with a straight back?
- 📝 Was the Buddha known to chant during his meditation?
- 📝 Was the Buddha an arahant?
- 📝 Was Gautama Buddha a believer of the religious beliefs prevalent in his time and in his cultural context?
- 📝 Did the Buddha state that there is only one way, and state/imply that any other path (such as those practiced by yogis) was futile?
- 📝 The Buddha is said to have rediscovered the ancient path. Why was it lost to begin with?
- 📝 How can the Buddha (after he was enlightened) reflect that he was not at ease and then became at ease in seclusion?
- 📝 Did the Buddha approved the idea of a council or was it a decision made after he passed away?
- 📝 What's the role of the detailed descriptions of the other planes of existence? Why it was important for the Buddha to tell them?
- 📝 Was the historical Buddha infallible?
- 📝 Was Buddha deceiving others to get them on the path?
- 📝 Was the Buddha a bodhisattva (for the benefit of all) before his awakening?
- 📝 How do I refute the claim that the Buddha was actually preaching Vedanta?
- 📝 Was the Buddha a pessimist?
- 📝 Was The Buddha only human, or was he super-human?
- 📝 The Buddha was male, so was he an "alpha male"?
- 📝 What's the Jataka tale about a previous life of the Buddha sacrificing himself to get a dharma teaching (because dharma was so scarce and rare then)?
- 📝 Was the Buddha against violence in all situations?
- 📝 What was the time gap between the previous Buddha and Gautama Buddha?
- 📝 Was the Buddha a vegetarian?
- 📝 Was Buddhism during the life of the Buddha unique in the history of religion per Huston Smith?
- 📝 What was the name of the great compassion meditation the Buddha did for a significant part of his daily routine?
- 📝 MN 122: Was the Buddha unsociable?
- 📝 Was the Buddha Humanist?
- 📝 What was the reason why Buddha taught reincarnation?
- 📝 How to refute the claim that the Buddha was an "avatar" of Vishnu?