Non-EU family member travelling alone to Spain
Upvote:1
As MJeffryes has noted in his answer, the prevailing interpretation of directive 2004/38/EC is that someone with a "Residence card of a family member of a Union citizen" may only use that card to benefit from the visa-free entry specified in Article 5(2) when they are traveling with or joining their EU family member. That condition is not explicit in the directive, and, as you note, it is an unreasonable or at least insurmountable barrier to the right of free movement for someone with a retained right of residence.
The directive, however, is not explicit on the question of whether a person enjoying a retained right of residence in one country continues to benefit from the other free movement provisions, such as a right of entry into another country. In other words, it provides that you retain a right of residence in the UK, but not necessarily that you retain a right of free movement throughout the EU.
To challenge the prevailing interpretation of the directive, you may have to go to court (I do not know whether the matter has already been decided by a court.) Before going to court, though, you might try lodging a complaint with SOLVIT, but they also link to the page that reflects the prevailing interpretation:
Your non-EU spouse, (grand)children or (grand)parents do not need to get a visa from the country they are travelling to if:
- They have an EU family member's residence card issued under EU rules by any EU country (except the country you are a national of), and they are travelling together with you or travelling to join you in another EU country. The residence card should clearly state that the holder is a family member of an EU national.
(emphasis added)
Upvote:3
Your retained right of residence allows you to reside in the UK. It does not grant you freedom of movement in the EU. That right is only afforded to EU citizens and their family members as long as the family member is traveling with, or reuniting with their EU family member. Furthermore, they may still be required to apply for a visa (but the visa has to be processed quickly, and for free). Note from this page:
Residence permits issued by countries outside the Schengen area do not allow non-EU family members to travel visa-free to a Schengen area country
Unfortunately, the check in staff were correct to deny you boarding, assuming you didn't have a Schengen visa.
More post
- 📝 Passport expiry for entry into US
- 📝 Am I eligible to travel to the Netherlands on a 6 month university exchange using the WHS?
- 📝 What's the maximum amount of luggage that can be carried on Qatar Airways?
- 📝 Can I apply for USA visa from another country rather than my own
- 📝 New application for UK visitor visa after previous refusal
- 📝 9hour layover in Paris. Can I go out of the airport?
- 📝 How can I find out if I need a visa to visit a certain country?
- 📝 What type of Schengen visa should I apply for when to visit Switzerland for a two-day Open House event?
- 📝 Which types of accommodations are affected by Lisbon's municipal tax?
- 📝 Linate airport (LIN, Milan, Italy): can I go the night before for an early morning flight?
- 📝 Flying AirAsia with an e-boarding pass requiring a documents check
- 📝 Transit visa for US permanent resident travelling thru Toronto
- 📝 How to get from Everett, WA to Vancouver, BC on public transit (on a Sunday)?
- 📝 When I swim near Malaga (Spain) what I should pay attention for?
- 📝 Can I access to the business lounges during the layover?
- 📝 How long can I stay in Israel after my student visa expires?
- 📝 Is there a difference between Italy and other Schengen countries when applying for a visa?
- 📝 Do I need a visa for Paris, if my connecting flight stops for 24 hours in Paris?
- 📝 Travelling to China
- 📝 Is it possible for a Canadian to live in Japan for a year or two while working remotely?
- 📝 Which Caltrain stations only have parking for Caltrain train customers only?
- 📝 I apply for a J-1 visa, can my wife apply for a B1 visa (instead of J2) to visit me?
- 📝 How are older drivers in the UK intended to learn about smart motorways?
- 📝 What am I supposed to do if pulled over by a police officer in the US and I can't roll down my car's windows?
- 📝 Do I need any additional insurance from the car rental?
- 📝 UK standard visit visa rejected from India for my wife and 2 kids
- 📝 Should I worry about being refused a ‘transit without visa concession’ in the UK?
- 📝 Etihad: Pre-clearance to US at Abu Dhabi
- 📝 Is opening an account in the USA still a viable option for a foreign traveler?
- 📝 AAA benefits as member of a European automobile club? (IHG rates)
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Non-EU family member travelling alone to Spain
- 📝 Non Eu family member travelling to Ireland
- 📝 What are the rules for a non-EU family member travelling with an EU national?
- 📝 Can my partner travel to Hungary alone with an EU/EEA family member visa
- 📝 Civil Union Partner with Family Permit approved travelling with EEA member - Customs Queue
- 📝 Travelling alone to Schengen countries with EU Family Residence Card
- 📝 Travel on a Schengen visa stating EEA family member without spouse?
- 📝 Possible problems for British resident of Spain travelling in Schengen area?
- 📝 Travelling to Spain on an Irish Passport (I am a UK and Irish Citizen - my wife is UK only)
- 📝 Can a non-EU family member of an EU citizen travel within Schengen to Switzerland before obtaining a residence card?
- 📝 Minors travelling abroad alone from India
- 📝 Duration of Schengen visa while travelling to non Schengen areas which allow Schengen visa
- 📝 What if one family member doesn't have a photo ID for domestic air travel in India?
- 📝 Schengen visa documents for inviting unemployed family member
- 📝 Travelling with Prescription Medications Through both France AND Spain over a Year's time
- 📝 Non US or Canada citizen travelling to Windsor through Windsor/Detroit tunnel on tunnel bus
- 📝 Do I need to prove that my spouse is using their right of free movement in order to receive a family member Schengen visa?
- 📝 Re-visiting the UK alone with the EU national family visa
- 📝 Transitting in Dubai Terminal 3. Mother travelling alone with 4 year old child
- 📝 Is a UK visa needed for a UK citizen's non-EU spouse with EU Family Member Residence Card to visit the UK together?
- 📝 Is it compusory for a family member of EU citizen to provide information of accomodation in Irish visa application?
- 📝 Non-EU family member re-entering Schengen without residence card
- 📝 Teen child traveling with family member within US
- 📝 Do I need transit visa for travelling from India to Spain via Brussels with Spanish re-entry permit
- 📝 As a family member of EEA, do I still need a visa to go to Ireland?
- 📝 I want a UK Standard Visitor visa but I am travelling alone
- 📝 Travelling to Schengen area with Type-D national Visa of Spain
- 📝 How to retrieve the DS-160 application of a family member from the US embassy website?
- 📝 What is the difference between dependant and dependent family member
- 📝 Permanent Resident as Family member of European citizen