WWI trench tactics using shields?
score:24
Shields for soldiers were tried during the First World War. In order to stop high power rifle rounds, they had to be rather heavy weight steel plate. This made them difficult to move and carry.
One French design made a wheeled shield known as the Mobile Personnel Shield. This proved too heavy and cumbersome to use in combat. However, it may have played a role in inspiring the first tanks.
The Canadians also developed the MacAdam Shield Shovel which doubled both as a digging tool and as protection when firing. It was made of three-sixteenths of an inch thick steel. There was a hole in the blade for sighting when used as a shield and the handle was detachable. Some 25,000 were produced but soldiers found them to be poor for digging, being to heavy, and ineffective at stopping bullets.
An additional problem for shields was that protection was not only required to the front. Shells and shrapnel would come from all directions when out of the trench. Thus a shield would be of little use unless completely covering the whole body. If so done, it would be to heavy to move by one soldier. Mechanising the shield would lead directly to the tank.
Not all shields proved useless. During WWI, shields were mounted on machine guns to protect the operator, who is generally more exposed than other soldiers and less required to move at speed. Such shields continue to be used to this day. Look at USA troops in Iraq or Afghanistan who are manning machine gun positions or using the mobile machine guns on the back of a truck, and you will see they have a shield in front of them that can turn with the gun.
Upvote:10
I strongly suspect that it is due to technical limitations: Rifle bullets travel at very, very high velocity, and thus even a steel shield would be unlikely to stop them. I recall hearing that the metal helmets they wore would not stop a direct hit, so I don't think a shield would either, at least not when limited by the amount a human can support. If you think about it, a tank or APC is really just a mechanical phalanx, providing armour on all sides. Also supporting this is an issue that the Canadian's had: A rather incompetent defence minister spent a ton of money on shovels with a hole in them, so you could peek up over the edge of a trench. The problem was bullets would go right through the shovel.
Even if you had a magic shield that stopped rifle and machine gun bullets you'd quickly lose formation as you walked over shell craters and whatnot: WWI battlefeilds were notorious for chopped up ground. Couple this with the fact that such a formation would quickly attract huge volumes of rife and machine gun fire, any hole in it would quickly be filled with bullets, and as soon as one person fell the whole formation would be chopped apart, as that would provide the machine guns with an opening. Mines could also be used to open up this type of hole.
Finally: Artillery and explosives: Even if you got around the first two issues, such a formation would have to move rather slowly, leaving it open to artillery fire. You'd also need a giant gap in barbed wire to move it through, so the enemy could just set up a large row of barbed wire, several layers deep, and aim their artillary at that. When you stop to cut through it, boom.
More post
- 📝 Could Japan have won WW2 without interservice rivalry?
- 📝 Why did the Byzantines not try to recover Syria during the war between Ali and Muawiya?
- 📝 How were the borders of the Holy Roman Empire established?
- 📝 Why was East Pakistan never divided into multiple provinces?
- 📝 Did more Jews live in Poland than any other country, prior to the Holocaust, because of how Polish laws and people regarded Jews?
- 📝 When did Europeans realize Native Americans had weaker immunity to Old World diseases?
- 📝 Why is Lal Bahadur Shastri's death in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, still a mystery?
- 📝 Was the French philosopher Pierre Bayle a Calvinist believer or an atheist?
- 📝 How Likely Was a French Alliance with Italy or Japan in World War I?
- 📝 Did the University of California and University of Geneva award honorary degrees to Inazo Nitobe?
- 📝 What was a "census" (some sort of compensation) in early medieval Europe?
- 📝 Pre civil-war, did the north ever make any attempts to stop the underground railroad?
- 📝 Chronological plausibility of "liars don’t make good martyrs?"
- 📝 Why did not US use solely (more) aviation and artillery when taking Okinawa during ww2?
- 📝 What is the origin of Rap?
- 📝 Are there records of animal "blood lust"?
- 📝 Is it true that Spartan soldiers fought naked?
- 📝 Was it ever possible for Germany to win WWII?
- 📝 When was the testudo / tortoise formation first used by the Romans?
- 📝 Is there any evidence of heterosexual men being sexually attracted to women breasts pre-Victorian history?
- 📝 Did an Irishman talk a German unit out of a bridge in World War 2?
- 📝 Examples of censorship causing economic decline
- 📝 Who was 'Viscount Yi' and what did he do to survive in the court of a madman?
- 📝 Could German citizens visit Japan during the Nazi era? And if so what would the locals think of them?
- 📝 How many languages did Leibniz speak?
- 📝 Who were the Bishops of Irkutsk after St. Innocent?
- 📝 What did the Emancipation Proclamation exactly do?
- 📝 What was this 1917 shell casing used for?
- 📝 Why did Charles I not borrow abroad?
- 📝 What is the difference between an extensive revolution and an intensive revolution?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 WWI trench tactics using shields?
- 📝 Which kingdoms were using WWI weapons at the time of the second world war?
- 📝 If WW2 trench warfare really was a poor use of outdated tactics then what what would have been more appropriate tactics to employ?
- 📝 Why does the United States keep using "old" date representations and imperial system, while being in the minority?
- 📝 Why bother to attack in trench warfare?
- 📝 Why didn't line infantry tactics try to keep up a constant volley of fire?
- 📝 Are tanks the only reason for the abandonment of trench warfare?
- 📝 Why did trench warfare accept deadlocks?
- 📝 How true is the statement "Soviet troops got into Berlin riding American trucks, walking in American boots and using American trains"?
- 📝 Did viking longboats in fact have shields on the side of the ships?
- 📝 The WWI Christmas truce of 1914 resulted in no consequences, in spite of clear warnings against such beforehand - why were there no courts-martial?
- 📝 When did the Romans begin using the sword, as opposed to the axe, for decapitation?
- 📝 What was the tactical benefit of using flamethrowers as weapons?
- 📝 Were British fears of Russia using Afghanistan as a staging post for an invasion of India unfounded?
- 📝 What was the reaction to English monarchs using the title "King of France"?
- 📝 What was the device that general Birdwood was using in the "Gallipoli" TV series?
- 📝 Was it not clear to the WWI allies that they were over-reaching with the treaty of Sevres?
- 📝 Can anyone identify the regiment and rank from this WWI photograph?
- 📝 In Viking combat, how much damage was done using the shield?
- 📝 Is there a confirmed historic record of using "non-standard" live animals for military purposes?
- 📝 How did societies adapt to using alcohol to make water safer?
- 📝 Was Donald Knuth the first person to typeset a book using a computer?
- 📝 Why did WWI include Japan?
- 📝 Did the Weimar governments publish revelatory WWI documents?
- 📝 Why didn’t Herbert Hoover’s residency in London during and after WWI disqualify him from becoming President?
- 📝 Were railway guns ever critical in any battle during WWI and WWII?
- 📝 Were union disputes the only reason for low female employment in WWI German factories?
- 📝 When did we begin using metal mesh platforms?
- 📝 Conscientious objectors in Germany during WWI
- 📝 Treatment of Jewish WWI Veterans