Which Confederate State provided the most troops in the American Civil War?
score:4
One would think that the answer was Virginia (the most populous Confederate state), but the answer apparently was North Carolina on both counts (contribution and casualties).
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090929211811AA1fKYQ
Upvote:-2
Battle of Gettysburg saw new York regiments as most plentiful on union side.virginia regiments most plentiful on confederate side.there is your answer simple Virginia.
Upvote:1
Virginia acknowledges in its records that it provided over 155,000 troops for confederate armies while North Carolina acknowledges over 133,000. Interestingly, Virginia also provided over 32,000 soldiers for the northern armies, among them General George Thomas.
Upvote:3
"Which Confederate state supplied the most troops" and "fought for the Confederacy" are slightly different questions. Tennessee actually supplied the second largest total of troops--more than North Carolina--from any Confederate state. But more than 30,000 of those fought on the Union side. (And not including 20,000 African-Americans.)
An issue which may be particular to East Tennessee is that many men served both sides. In my research on Hawkins County, Tennessee, I have so far found that nearly 8% of the men who served in Confederate regiments at first later served in Union regiments. While a few joined US Volunteer regiments for frontier duty, most deserted their Confederate TN regiment and enlisted in a Union TN regiment.
Upvote:5
Just to back up Wladimir's post of the inaccuracy of the numbers. Josh Howard a North Carolina Historian stated in this article
"The time has come to get it right," said Josh Howard, a research historian with the Office of Archives and History in Raleigh. "Nobody has gone through man by man looking for the deaths."
North Carolina is only believed to have sacrificed the most men to the war. The article linked above is from 2010 where he set out to figure out if this was true or not. However as of now he has completed a study that attempts to put the myth to rest.
Additional Info:
Josh Howard's Study Page (No results listed)
After a year+ of work it looks like he came to a conclusion. He states that the North Carolina death toll would be closer to 32000-35000. Also when taking into account the inaccuracy of other military records from other states it looks like North Carolina still comes out on top.
From this article
In all likelihood, North Carolina still ranks first in fallen Confederates. If records in Raleigh are wrong, it’s a good bet the rest of the Southern states have inaccurate counts, too. Second-place Virginia, also reviewing its count, is moving much closer to North Carolina in the number of dead.
He also concludes that:
But both Howard and Purser admit the numbers will never be 100 percent accurate.
Extra Interesting Info:
He did debunk the myth that the first casuality for the south was that of soldier from North Carolina.
A Virginia captain beat Pvt. Henry Lawson Wyatt, a 19-year-old from Tarboro, to the grave by nine days;
Upvote:38
As far as Union states go, this table seems to provide accurate information. However, the info on Confederate army is very incomplete. You can find statements that North Carolina supplied the most soldiers (125,000) to the Confederate army all over the Internet. The original source seems to be a speech from 1904 by Hon. Theodore F. Davidson in Raleigh:
She [North Carolina] was next to the last state to secede from the Union, and in February, 1861 she voted against secession by 30,000 majority; yet, with a military population of 115,365, the State of North Carolina furnished to the Confederate army 125,000 men. . .Of the ten regiments on either side which sustained the heaviest loss in any one engagement during the war, Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee, Illinois, New York, Pennsylvania and New Jersey furnished one each, and North Carolina furnished three. North Carolina furnished from first to last one fifth of the entire Confederate army, and at the surrender at Appomattox, one-half of the muskets stacked were from North Carolina.
Given the nature of this speech, it is probably not the most reliable source of information - and it doesn't actually claim directly that North Carolina supplied more soldiers than any other state. In fact, if you search hard enough you will also find statements about Tennessee and Texas as the states that contributed the most soldiers to the Confederate army (not backed by numbers). For comparison one would need to at least look at the number of soldiers supplied by Virginia but that number is very hard to find.
I finally found the book The numerical strength of the Confederate army from 1912 which lists the stated numbers of enrollment into the Confederate army:
- Virginia: 175,000
- Florida: 15,000
- Georgia: 120,000
- North Carolina: 129,000
- South Carolina: 75,000
- Mississippi: 70,000
- Alabama: 90,000
- Tennessee: 115,000
The book goes on to compare these numbers with the actual population and comes to the following conclusion:
In the light of the facts just stated we must conclude that the Southern writers quoted by General Adams have, in their zeal for the honor and glory of their several States, greatly overestimated the number of men contributed by the same to the Confederate armies. This would be more probable a priori, than that the leading men in the Confederate army and Government who were at the sources of information, and who ought to have been well informed, should have so enormously underestimated the strength of the armies of the South; but the tests to which we have now submitted the figures given by these State historians demonstrate their error beyond the possibility of doubt. They must be cut down by several hundred thousand. A large element of this error is to be found, as I have suggested, in the failure to observe the great number of re-enlistments that undoubtedly took place, especially in 1862, when the terms of service of nearly all the Confederate regiments expired.[Pg 61] This duplication, in the opinion of the military Secretary of the United States, reduces the total by twenty per cent.
For us this means: If you look at the "official" numbers then the state that supplied the most soldiers was Virginia. The sources claiming otherwise apparently took the statement "North Carolina supplied many soldiers" and turned it into a superlative. As to the real numbers: I'm not sure whether they are known by now, I couldn't find anything resembling a reliable source.
More post
- 📝 Why did the Hungarians protest and react so much about Khrushchevs secret speech?
- 📝 In the Nuremberg Laws, What did "Approved for Citizenship" is half Jewish mean in practice?
- 📝 What metallurgy advancement allowed the transition from mail hauberk to plate armor?
- 📝 What was the longest a World War II submarine stayed at sea without being resupplied at a port?
- 📝 How were 19th century American diplomats paid?
- 📝 Would the original readers of Lewis Carroll's books have made connections between the experiences in the books and drug use?
- 📝 Since when were the US the strongest military power?
- 📝 Was Mimar Sinan of Greek Christian origin?
- 📝 What was the reason of extreme anti-Communism in the first half of 20th century?
- 📝 How can I identify this RAF pin badge?
- 📝 How many non-partisan (independent) legislature members were in the USA compared to the USSR?
- 📝 What benefit was there in executing Anne Boleyn instead of poisoning her and pretending she was ill?
- 📝 Was Ireland really England's first colony?
- 📝 Did the syphilis epidemic start the 16th and 17th century wig craze?
- 📝 Why wasn't Monaco unified with France?
- 📝 When was the temple of Artemis at Ephesus destroyed?
- 📝 Were the Nazis the first to use phenol as a means of execution?
- 📝 Who owned Franz Josef islands between 1918-1926?
- 📝 Do any Egyptian hieroglyphics mention the ten plagues?
- 📝 Who owns the Saudi-Iraqi neutral zone after the 1991 Gulf War?
- 📝 What historical reasons did the Nazis give for hating the Jews? How did they identify non-practicing Jews?
- 📝 Have American urban rioters ever looted residences?
- 📝 What was the reason that Poland wanted a part of Germany north of Stettin/Szczecin and west of the Oder?
- 📝 What was the dominant government system in the 1600s~1800s?
- 📝 In the election of 1800, why did Burr end up with as many electoral votes as Jefferson, rather than one fewer?
- 📝 In the Bakumatsu period, was there any way to identify which clan a person belonged to?
- 📝 Why did Argentina seize South Georgia immediately prior to the Falklands invasion?
- 📝 What did Cyrus the great look like?
- 📝 Are these remarks by Napoleon on Jesus genuine?
- 📝 Why you must wait before claiming "historical knowledge"
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Which Confederate State provided the most troops in the American Civil War?
- 📝 After the American Civil War, which states had the most problems with rejoining the Union?
- 📝 Which American Civil War admiral said he would not punish people for getting their ship close to the enemy?
- 📝 How did the American Civil War help the U.S economy recover from the Panic of 1857 given that civil wars are extremely destructive?
- 📝 Was the American Civil War the “bloodiest civil war in history”?
- 📝 Founding Fathers and the American Civil War
- 📝 Why did the Union army favor a "western" route to approaching Richmond during the American Civil War
- 📝 How did the English Civil War affect the American Colonies policy-wise?
- 📝 Have American writing styles changed between the Civil War and Today?
- 📝 What uniforms did each of the American Civil War regiment wear during First Bull Run / First Manassas
- 📝 Was the American Civil War the first to include multiple multi-day battles?
- 📝 Has the American Civil War led to any significant innovations in 19th-century warfare?
- 📝 In American Civil War era paper cartridges, what was taking up the space between powder and bullet?
- 📝 Did any of the US States ever attempt to secede, aside from American Civil War times?
- 📝 Are any civil wars -- other than the American Civil War -- commonly reenacted?
- 📝 Were any of the historical figures of the American Civil War close at West Point?
- 📝 Which head of state had the most gaps in their rule?
- 📝 What capabilities did Southern soldiers in the American Civil War have to get news about the North?
- 📝 During the American Civil war did gunboats range far into enemy territory?
- 📝 Why wasn't the American civil war fought between slaves and masters?
- 📝 How detailed were American Civil War medical records of the types of diseases that various soldiers had?
- 📝 Did the rebels in the American War of Independence acknowledge English Civil War rebel groups as an influence on their thinking?
- 📝 How many troops did the Confederate and Union army have in each year of the Civil War?
- 📝 Why did the Confederacy think they could win the American Civil War?
- 📝 Did the King of Siam offer war elephants to the Union during the Civil War?
- 📝 Why did the German army execute so few soldiers in World War I compared to most other armies?
- 📝 What led to the first fight in the American Civil War?
- 📝 What was the reason for Soviet troops to withdraw from Yugoslavia in World War II?
- 📝 Which battle was the most lopsided result in terms of casualties?
- 📝 Why were Civil War battle techniques so bloody, if the US had learned guerrilla fighting in the Revolutionary War?