"More Frenchmen bore arms for the Axis than for the Allies during the Second World War"?
score:34
Many French may have borne arms for the Axis, but it was very soft support; not many of them never fired a shot in anger for the Axis. Even in October/November 1942 with the Axis at flood tide, Vichy North Africa rapidly switched allegiance after the Torch Landings at Casablanca, Oran and Algiers, despite some initial confused opposition.
Following the liberation of Paris in August 1944, Charles de Gaulle very effectively began mobilizing a French Army that number well over 1,000,000 men in the field by the following spring.
Update:
From Wikipedia for Operation Torch following the invasion on November 8, 1942
(and consistent with descriptions both by Churchill and Manchester & Reid):
Political Results
It quickly became clear that Giraud lacked the authority to take command of the French forces. He preferred to wait in Gibraltar for the results of the landing. However, Darlan in Algiers had such authority. Eisenhower, with the support of Roosevelt and Churchill, made an agreement with Darlan, recognizing him as French "High Commissioner" in North Africa. In return, Darlan ordered all French forces in North Africa to cease resistance to the Allies and cooperate instead. The deal was made on 10 November, and French resistance ceased almost at once.
Vichy Terms:
Under terms of the surrender, the Vichy government was only allowed to maintain an internal army of 95,000 (all ranks) plus a gendarmerie of 60,000 and an anti-aircraft force of 10,000. There were an additional 145,000 or so Vichy forces in Algeria, Morocco and the Levant, making a total force under arms of barely 300,000.
Since some 2,000,000 soldiers had been captured by the Germans in the spring 1940 campaign and retained under the treaty terms as forced labour, it is difficult to see how the Vichy forces were ever even comparable to the forces fielded by France in 1940.
Upvote:0
Not certain how true the statistical claim is, but it is quite possible. A number of French troops can be counted as having "born arms" for both the Axis and the Allies. For a good instance of this occurring, please see Edward Ellsberg's "No Banners, No Bugles," which briefly treats the capture of Oran, Algeria (connected with Operation Torch), and then treats at length the salvage operations after. The same French officers that fought against the Allies and scuttled dry docks and ships alike, nominally became Allies themselves and retained authority. Ellsberg recounts recurring incidents when the French officers appeared to continue to sabotage Allied operations, and also notes that Allied intelligence operations in Oran were adamantly discouraged (this is not the only claim that this occurred, nor the only location where it is claimed to have occurred). Willful blindness in this way deprives us of any accuracy for estimates of numbers of French persons who fought for the Axis.
Upvote:0
In a book about the history of Mothren, a village in the Alsace north of Strasbourg, there is a list of the soldiers who died in WWll and where they died. The number who died in Russia was about 3 times as great as those whose death was listed as a member of the Army of France. This area of course contained many German speaking people so they may have been "drafted" by the Germans but they may also have volunteered.
Upvote:7
It is absolutely ridiculous.
By the end of the war in 1945, the Free French army alone had almost one and half million men, making it the fourth largest Allied army in Europe.
The maximum strength of the 33rd Waffen-SS Division Charlemagne was 7000-8000 soon after it was raised from different volunteer outfits in 1944, and the grand total of French volunteers was around 20,000.
It is also not accurate to count the Vichy army (limited to less than 300,000 men by the 2nd Compiegne armistice). It did not wage war against the Allies, it just resisted armed incursions from both Allied and Axis (Japan and Thailand in French Indochina) belligerents, as is the duty of any country according to international law on armed neutrality.
Its most important military action was actually anti-Axis, the scuttling of the French navy in Toulon, preventing its fall into Axis hands.
Upvote:24
Pieter Geerkens answer is excellent and should be selected, but I want to add a few well-known facts which show that the "brutal statistic" is actually wrong by an order of magnitude.
Western Front 1940 More than 2,200,000 French soldiers fought on the Western Front in 1940. This alone dwarfs the total number of any kind of military personnel under Vichy-France, of which only a fraction fought for the Axis.
French Free Forces before Operation Torch It is not so easy to determine the relative size of the Forces Françaises Libres compared to Vichy-France in the Levant and Madagascar campaigns. About 100,000 troops from Vichy-France seem to have fought these campaigns. In late 1942, there were 60,000 Forces Françaises Libres.
French Liberation Army In 1943, after their fusion with the African Armies, the FFL became the French Liberation Army. 72,000 men fought in Tunisia, 100,000 in Italy and 267,000 in the liberation of France (mostly in Operation Dragoon). Again, these forces alone seem to outnumber the total number of military personnel of Vichy-France.
French Forces after the liberation In september 1944, so after the liberation of Paris, the French Liberation Army numbered 550,000. In december 1944, 1,000,000. At the end of the war, 1,300,000.
Conclusion At the beginning and the end of WWII, French forces fighting with the Allies outnumbered the maximum number of French forces fighting with the Axis by almost an order of magnitude. Frenchmen who "bore the arms" for the Axis were at most 300,000; and among them perhaps 100,000 or 150,000 actually fought.
Why there is some truth in the assertion Depending on the context of the quote, though, I think there might be some truth in the assertion. Indeed, among the hundred of thousands who fought for the Forces Françaises Libres and the Armée de Libération, most were from France then colonial empire. So it is conceivably true that more metropolitan French bore arms for Vichy-France on the soil of metropolitan France in the late 1940/early 1944 period than metropolitan French bore arms for the Allies during the same period. And indeed, this fact is not easily discussed in the historiography of France. So with the qualifications "metropolitan French" and "from late 1940 to early 1944", the assertion might be correct. Without the qualifications, it verges on the insult to the French soldiers of 1940 and of the Armée Française de Libération.
Update
@jwentig correctly remarks that the answer did not account for the French volunteers and conscripts who fought in the Waffen-SS and other Axis units. In fact, a number seem hard to track down (leading credence to the accusation of uneasiness in the original quote). Nevertheless, I found this book which aims at a complete listing. It arrives at a total of 40,000 French soldiers for the Axis, so maybe 2% of the numbers who fought with the Allies. Among these, 18,000 to 22,000 fought voluntarily in the Waffen-SS according to Wikipedia, which is in fact rather low (compared for instance to the 40,000 from Belgium or Hungary and the 50,000 from the Netherlands, which all had a fraction of France's population). Another point that wasn't discussed in any answers so far, I think, is the case of forced conscriptions of former French citizens in the annexed part of Alsace and Moselle. There were about 130,000 so that even including them (which would seem quite historically unfair as well as inaccurate), the total number of Frenchmen arguably bearing arms for the Axis (total Vichy-France army plus French in German units plus forced conscriptions) hardly reaches 500,000. About one sixth of those who indisputably fought with the Allies.
Sources
Any reference about WWII, starting with Wikipedia.
More post
- 📝 Would the gun crews have different responsibilities aboard a 17th century ship than on the USS Constitution?
- 📝 How rich were carpenters in Roman Galilee in the 1st century AD?
- 📝 What was the cost of buying Silk in the Roman Empire
- 📝 Who are reputable historians who study ancient Greece?
- 📝 Why did Icelandic begin to diverge from the Continental north Germanic languages specifically between 1050 and 1350?
- 📝 Why did the United States want to "make Europe prosperous once more" with the Marshall Plan?
- 📝 Are there any accounts of German junior enlisted soldiers surviving the siege of Stalingrad and subsequent captivity?
- 📝 What was a cistern to the Babylonians?
- 📝 Why did India release all Pakistani Soldiers captured during Indo Pak War 1965
- 📝 What was the earliest professional recording of "Happy Birthday to You"?
- 📝 How has Chinese GDP as a percentage of world GDP changed over time and why?
- 📝 Which European country sent the most slaves to the Americas?
- 📝 What is the main difference between an Emperor, a King, a Char, a Sultan, a Dictator, a Dynast and a Tyrant?
- 📝 What rectangular object would is this Boer War era officer carrying on his left hand side?
- 📝 Why was there a "workers' militia" in Eastern Europe but not in the USSR?
- 📝 What profession(s) would have used this folding 'ruler'?
- 📝 Why did the French Revolution bring secularism?
- 📝 How serious was Fermat's statement about the ancients?
- 📝 What was located at the site of Madison Square Garden in 1850?
- 📝 Has the existence of a matriarchal society really been discredited?
- 📝 Why did the Nazis invent videotelephony?
- 📝 What evidence do we have that disabled people became shamans in pre-historic times?
- 📝 Why was the Council of Nicea held in Nicea rather than Rome or Constantinople?
- 📝 More Scientific Discoveries Outside Academia Past 50 Years?
- 📝 Is this accusation in the Declaration of Independence factual?
- 📝 When did the Romans finally acknowledge that they were living in an empire?
- 📝 Why wasn’t Japan colonized by the European empires?
- 📝 How expensive were castles? And how were the costs distributed?
- 📝 Was FDR right that a garden hose was really $15 in 1940 (c.a. $300 today)?
- 📝 Visit of Greek philosophers to Rome in 155 BCE
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 "More Frenchmen bore arms for the Axis than for the Allies during the Second World War"?
- 📝 Did the Axis use Villa Cisneros during WW2 for contact with South America?
- 📝 What were conditions like for Chinese men subject to recruitment by the army during the Second Sino-Japanese War and Chinese Civil War?
- 📝 Why did the price of eggs in Britain increase much more than for other basic foods during WWI?
- 📝 When did the allies find out about the killing of Jews during WW2
- 📝 Why were so many more Jewish men than Jewish women killed during the Holocaust?
- 📝 During the breakup of the Soviet Union, on what basis was citizenship granted or withheld for each of the fifteen new republics?
- 📝 Were any German cities spared by the Allies for personal or idiosyncratic reasons?
- 📝 What caused the imposition of strict celibacy for Catholic priests during the 11th century?
- 📝 Were Shakespeare's plays written for "high culture" or "entertain the bawdy masses" during his time?
- 📝 What was the liquor that was based on petrol which was produced in the USSR during the Second World War?
- 📝 How did the Allies communicate during World War II?
- 📝 Did the Axis try to "bribe" Turkey into joining them during World War II?
- 📝 Was the act of servicemen exchanging their weapons for enemy weapons common during WWII?
- 📝 Were there any successful attempts by the Allies to "turn" groups of Axis soldiers?
- 📝 How did Allies secure southern flank during "Race to the Rhine"?
- 📝 Why did Argentina invade the Falklands when they did, rather than wait for the pending sale of the UK aircraft carriers to complete first?
- 📝 During feudalism in Europe, was one's allegiance to the lord more or less important than the allegiance to the king?
- 📝 Where and how did the allies scrounge enough food for the Soviets AND the British?
- 📝 Did any of the 50 Destroyers swapped for bases with Great Britain in 1940 sink any Axis military vessels?
- 📝 What were Chiang Kai-shek's biggest strategic blunders during the Second Sino-Japanese war?
- 📝 What documented criteria (if any) did the CIA use to determine targets for political assassination during the Cold War?
- 📝 Why didn't the Allies wait for the nuclear bomb before invading Normandy?
- 📝 How was the relation between the Ottoman Empire and Serbia, Greece, and Montenegro during the Second Balkan War?
- 📝 Did Radio Free Europe say that the Allies would come to the rescue during the Hungarian Revolution?
- 📝 How important was the Suez Canal to the Allies during WWII?
- 📝 What was the argument for the Japanese pursuing the Northern Expansion Doctrine during WWII?
- 📝 How was the safety of allied leaders ensured in transportation for conferences during WW2?
- 📝 Did the Allies benefit, by having Italy fight on Germany's side rather than remain neutral?
- 📝 Could besieged medieval cities develop a micro-economy during wars to endure the siege for long time?