Did Gorbachev say that his intention was to destroy Communism?
score:11
As I see it, there are two different aspects here:
- Is the speech itself authentic?
- Are its contents true?
To answer 1 negatively, one could demonstrate, for example, that there is no American University in Turkey or that Gorbachev never visited Turkey in 1999.
To show why 2 is different from 1 even if 1 happens to be true, consider the option that Gorbachev, a consummate career politician, could have been describing in 1999 his own past thought and actions in terms and ways he thought his audience there and then would appreciate, not necessarily giving a true representation.
For now let me focus on 1, which is the easier question. This answer is not final yet so I'll be updating it as I find out more. For now:
- First of all, it's not clear that USVIT, the alleged source, exists. We are told that it's a Slovak newspaper. Immediately one wonders: why would a Slovak newspaper be reporting on this? And if the event were newsworthy enough to reach Slovakia, can mention of it be found in other sources?
The Wikipedia list of Slovak papers does not mention an Usvit but this is not conclusive at all, of course (wiki is not 100% reliable, the paper could have been closed or renamed since) but nevertheless it does give some pause.
Also, there is a Czech political party called Usvit - Czech, not Slovak.
On the balance, the Usvit source is really fishy.
So I googled it a bit in English and found a translation of the alleged speech to English - and there its credited to "the 'Dialog' newspaper in the Czech Republic".
To sum up, unless somebody finds an actual copy of N.24 of the Slovak Usvit newspaper, I tend to think that it never existed as such and makes the whole text quite suspect.
- Is there an American University in Turkey?
Once again, wikipedia has a helpful list and according to it there is no such institution! We still cannot rule out closure or renaming since 1999 but it does seem likely that the whole thing is made up at this stage.
There is however, an American University in Northern Cyprus which is a Turkish fief. But it does not seem to have a branch in Ankara or anything.
So, the venue seems to be made up as well.
- I am not qualified to perform a proper lexical or philological analysis of the alleged speech or even an ngram search (like we did here), but one point sticks out as a sore thumb: the mention of Gorbachev's wife as the propelling power for his rise in the party. Is it a sensible thing for a politician to say in a speech? Does it make sense for him to say that his actions and his very ideas were actually his wife's?
If on the other hand, we recall that Gorbachev's late wife is particularly reviled in certain communist/nationalist/antisemitic circles in Russia, then her inclusion makes sense: the forgers could not help including a shot at their favourite target, even at the expense of the whole thing's veracity.
To sum up: the "speech" is with %99.9 probability fake.
Upvote:6
There are several questions in here. I'll try to address each one:
Q1: Did Gorbachev betray his voters who voted for a return to Leninist ideals?
No. The reason he didn't do that is twofold.
He didn't have any voters. Gorbachev came to power in a totalitarian dictatorship. His assumption to power was completely undemocratic. Nobody hence voted for any return to Leninist ideals. (There was an election in 1989, and this election served both to legitimize Gorbachev and take steps towards democracy, but it did not bring him to power, and the election would not have been able to bring him down from power either).
A "return to Leninist ideals" means primarily things like equality, and the people being in control. This means democracy, and this was what Gorbachev was working for. His aim was a socialist democracy. He believed in Marx and Lenin's ideals, but he had realized that the so called "dictatorship of the proletariat" was not the way forward. Hence he retained the ideals, but rejected the methods. Therefore it was not a betrayal of the ideals.
There therefore was no voters to betray, and he also did not betray his supporters or Leninist ideals. What he did was simply to fail. Instead of succeeding in his aim to bring democracy to the Soviet Union, his steps towards democracy instead led the Soviet Union to collapse. To his credit though, this has led to democracy in Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia, so his efforts wasn't a complete failure.
Q2: Is the sources for the text reliable?
No. Felix Goldberg in his answer explains well why it isn't reliable. In fact the claimed sources generally don't seem to exist. Also in one case it's claimed to be a speech, in another an interview, which casts further doubt on the text.
There is today a publication in Slovakia called "Usvit" but it's doubtful it existed in 1999, and if it did it's a one-man show by a local fringe politician. It seems highly unlikely that this guy had secured an interview with Gorbachev.
The text is variously claimed to be from the American University in Turkey. That University does not exist. There is an American University in Cyprus, though. However, the text is otherwise claimed to be from an interview in Ankara. The only reference I can find to Gorbachev and Ankara is from a 1997 publication in Turkish. The source is not reliable.
Q3: Did Gorbachev say that his intention was to destroy Communism?
No. I can't find any reliable sources on Gorbachev himself saying that he wanted to destroy communism. The text in this question seems to be the only case, and as we have seen, these texts are not reliable.
During the cold war, the word "communism" was generally associated with socialist dictatorships, while the word "socialism" was wider and included those who wanted both socialism and democracy. With that usage of the word it could therefore be claimed that he indeed wanted to destroy communism, as he wanted to make the USSR democratic. But he himself seems not to have made such a claim.
Q4: Is the text authentic?
No. Most of the things in the interview seem rather unremarkable. Gorbachev claims to want a social democracy, something he has said otherwise. He said even before the fall of USSR that he wanted a more open market. There is no mention of a conspiracy at all, that seems to be Anixx own invention.
In fact, the only remarkable statement is "The purpose of my life was the destruction of communism, unbearable dictatorship over the people". Nowhere else do we find Gorbachev claiming that he wanted to destroy communism.
We do however find him saying that he wanted democracy. As such this quote is probably an intentional distortion of what he said. He most likely said that he wanted to destroy the unbearable dictatorship over the people.
So whoever decided to wrote the original article was probably a dedicated anti-democratic communist, and decided to change the headline to something more controversial. Therefore, at a minimum we can conclude that the article as a whole isn't reliable, and that the claim that he wanted to destroy communism probably is falsified.
As the sources seem to made up, and also Gorbachev's visit to Turkey seems made up, it's likely that the whole text is made up. But it's probably largely made up from things he actually have said in other interviews and in his 1995 autobiography. The claim that he wanted to destroy communism is however most likely completely invented.
Upvote:12
I trust David Remnick's Lenins's Tomb: The Last Days of the Soviet Empire as a source, which includes this passage:
To begin with, Gorbachev himself was still convinced of what he called the "rightness of socialist choice." He continued to see Lenin as his guiding intellectual and historical model. There is absolutely no evidence to suggest that Gorbachev was out to undermine, much less destroy, the basic tenets of ideology or statehood of the Soviet Union. Certainly not in 1987.
It may be relevant that 1987 is closer in time to the main transformative events affecting Soviet Communism than is 1999. I personally don't think the quoted "admission" is authentic in an objective sense.
More post
- 📝 How Much Did World War Two Cost Financially?
- 📝 What's this flag flying on a fort at Kodiak, Alaska?
- 📝 Which battle was the most lopsided result in terms of casualties?
- 📝 Why did Native Americans die from European diseases while Europeans didn't catch serious diseases from the New World?
- 📝 GDP per capita of major combatants before and after WWII?
- 📝 What is the explanation of president Gen. Yahya Khan's role in the general election of 1970?
- 📝 How can scholarly non-historians locate and properly use scholarly histories?
- 📝 Did the Reformation have any impact in Orthodox countries?
- 📝 What types of weapons did the British army use in the late 1890's?
- 📝 Why was Japanese Unit 731 immune from War Crime trials?
- 📝 Health precautions before going into Battle of Trafalgar and other battles
- 📝 Why did Roosevelt and Churchill use voice-based telecommunication, instead of simpler text-based options which were easier to encrypt?
- 📝 Why wasn't sauerkraut used to combat scurvy?
- 📝 Did the biblical apostle James visit Ireland?
- 📝 Why did pastorial people from central Asia migrate to Europe?
- 📝 Did the Germans have a team equivalent to the one from Bletchey Park in the UK during WWII?
- 📝 Was there a social stigma for British born/living in India prior to WW2/Indian independence?
- 📝 Mnemonics for centures or any other longer periods, like Zodiac signs other than Chinese?
- 📝 Identifying a military uniform from the early 19th century
- 📝 What is the evidence to repudiate this version of the "stab in the back" myth?
- 📝 How did historians sync up historical dates of different cultures?
- 📝 Did Jiang Baili receive a sword from Emperor Meiji for graduating first of his class?
- 📝 Ports with ships in the commercial Halifax trade, late 18th Century
- 📝 How did the United States penal system evolve?
- 📝 How did the maximum strengths of alcoholic beverages in Western Europe increase from wine which Romans watered to 80 proof to absinthe?
- 📝 Are there ways to measure "how much power did "Russia" lose when the Soviet Union broke up?"
- 📝 How do we compare historical empires on these statistics?
- 📝 Why do many Indian Languages have different alphabets?
- 📝 Is there a link between the Sea people and the Trojan War?
- 📝 Are there ancient Greek historians who wrote about Mycenae?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Did Gorbachev say that his intention was to destroy Communism?
- 📝 Did Adolf Hitler ever address the fact that his own appearance was almost an exact opposite of what he considered the ideal Aryan appearance?
- 📝 Did Sir Isaac Newton ever claim that his mind in 1666 was "remarkably fit for invention"?
- 📝 Did Theodore Roosevelt ever say the "things that will destroy America" quote?
- 📝 Why did Robert E. Lee say that George McClellan was the best general he ever faced?
- 📝 Is there any evidence to support the claim that the United States was "suckered into WW1" by Zionists, made by Benjamin Freedman in his 1961 speech?
- 📝 What did Zhang Zuolin say after his train blew up?
- 📝 How did people realize that America was a different continent?
- 📝 Did Truman really believe that Hiroshima was a military base?
- 📝 Did the Tamil People discover that the earth was round 2000 years ago?
- 📝 Did any ancient polytheistic religion hold that theirs was the only pantheon?
- 📝 If Bill Clinton was impeached, why did he finish his second term?
- 📝 Did Alexander the Great destroy a city to demonstrate his ability to reign?
- 📝 Did Goebbels realize that his wife used to know Arlozorov?
- 📝 Did Mussolini know that Hitler was going to attack Poland?
- 📝 Did JFK really say "Hitler is one of the greatest men…one of the most significant figures that ever lived"?
- 📝 Was it widely known during his reign that Kaiser Wilhelm II had a deformed arm?
- 📝 When did we figure out that Venus was too hot for humans?
- 📝 Did Radio Free Europe say that the Allies would come to the rescue during the Hungarian Revolution?
- 📝 When and where did Louis Blanc say the famous "from each according to his abilities..."?
- 📝 Why did Winston Churchill say "perverted science" in his Finest Hour speech?
- 📝 How did people ensure that renaissance Papal election bribery was honored?
- 📝 Why and how did George V give titles to his generals over lands that he did not possess?
- 📝 How did the helmsman know what he was sailing towards with a big mast in his face?
- 📝 Did Averroes really try to bury light in an attempt to create gold, or was that invented by Victor Hugo?
- 📝 Was Frederick Douglass right that in his day 'religious slaveholders are the worst'? If so why would this be?
- 📝 How did Isaac Newton support himself in the period of self-study that he conducted at 23?(after he received his B.A.)
- 📝 Why did the Australian IOC deny that Peter Norman was excluded from the 1972 Olympics for supporting racial equality?
- 📝 When did Walter Benjamin say "We collect books in the belief that we are preserving them when in fact it is the books that preserve their collector"?
- 📝 Does any evidence exist that suggests Hitler’s primary reason for declaring war on America was an attempt to draw Japan into his war with Russia?