Has there been a soldier who refused a direct illegal order and was not prosecuted for insubordination (post-1945)?
score:4
Yes
Per This article, it appears to have happened at least once. The article is about disobeying unlawful orders in general, but this particular section seems to best answer your question.
The defense of superior orders in cases of reprisal attacks is so weak that it is hardly ever attempted. In the spring of 2008, soldiers of Alpha Co, 1-18th Infantry lined four Iraqi prisoners up near a canal and executed them. The Iraqis were captured during a raid of a house found to contain weapons. They denied knowing anything about where the weapons came from, which was almost certainly a lie. The company’s first sergeant ordered that the Iraqis be transported to a nearby canal, where he instructed his men to shoot them, saying it was revenge for fallen comrades. Some of the men in the unit balked and refused [emphasis mine] , but others participated in the killings. When the incident was finally exposed, those involved in the killings were tried by court-martial....No one involved pretended that the first sergeant’s order excused their conduct because that defense had no realistic chance of success.
At no point in the article (or any related articles I could find on the matter) does it say the soldiers who "balked and refused" the order to execute the Iraqis were court-marshalled or otherwise punished for insubordination. Probably because the order was so egregious there even the First Sgt. who ordered it knew there could only be one reasonable outcome if their disobedience came to trial. In general the Manual of Courts-Martial for the US Armed forces lays out that any discipline/refusal of orders/insubordination matter is brought up by (or at least requires the support of in terms of affidavits etc) the person who issued the order. If your order was "Shoot these civilians" and somebody disobeys it, the odds seem pretty good you aren't going to go to your JAG office or superior officer and tell them "I ordered private Joe to shoot unarmed detainees and he refused so I want him charged with failure to obey a direct order."
More post
- 📝 In medieval England was heresy dealt with in the king's courts or church courts?
- 📝 How were years numbered on the Republican Calendar?
- 📝 If the heir to a Kingdom is called Crown Prince, what is the heir to a Duchy called?
- 📝 What caused Iranians to convert to Shiite Islam?
- 📝 What was the role of the mountain ranges surrounding India in developing India's civilization?
- 📝 Was slavery abolished in the Kingdom of Hungary, and if so, when?
- 📝 Did Abraham Lincoln have a duel with cannons?
- 📝 How well were the African soldiers equipped in the civil war?
- 📝 Was Caligula popular with the general Roman population?
- 📝 How were immigrant doctors and nurses sponsored in 1960/1970s?
- 📝 Has any country, other than Britain, given away its empire?
- 📝 Why didn't the Allies use a naval invasion to retake Norway?
- 📝 When did Rome recognize the Christian church as a judical person?
- 📝 Have there been ruthless rulers who held on to power despite being blinded?
- 📝 How long was the Treaty of Versailles intended to be in order?
- 📝 When was the last time there were border controls, customs, or border patrols inside what is now the contiguous US?
- 📝 Who is this young 'Prince'?
- 📝 Was Canónigo Fernández a traitor to Mexico?
- 📝 Why did textile mill owners during the industrial revolution keep their factory windows closed?
- 📝 What is the oldest graphic depiction of Attila?
- 📝 Why is Germany's history of colonialism and imperialism less prominent compared to other European nations?
- 📝 "Three Pines" as code for British Loyalists during the Revolutionary War
- 📝 Why did Prithvi Raj Chouhan allow Muhammad Ghori to flee?
- 📝 How long would it have taken to get to the Poconos in the early 1900s?
- 📝 How were the British and French Mandates in the Levantine area involved in WWII?
- 📝 When was the term for WW2 first used and was it more popular in, say, US before Europe?
- 📝 Did genocide occur in the Football War?
- 📝 Why were women excluded from the succession line in the Meiji constitution?
- 📝 What is the origin of Kula Devata or Family Deity?
- 📝 At the beginning of English Civil War, why did Parliament take a hard line with neutrals, thereby effectively helping Royalist recruitment?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Has there been a soldier who refused a direct illegal order and was not prosecuted for insubordination (post-1945)?
- 📝 Has there ever been a direct clash between NATO and Russia?
- 📝 Has there ever been a cold war other than between the U.S. and the U.S.S.R.?
- 📝 Has there been an occasion where ranged weapons were available but not used?
- 📝 Is there an edition of Gibbon's *Decline and Fall* that has been annotated by a modern historian?
- 📝 Has there ever been litigation over a salvaged shipwreck between a European country and a former ex-colony?
- 📝 The monumental/architectural sculptures of Petra - has there been any research on the likely craftsmen who executed them?
- 📝 Have there been known instances in history when a queen consort slept with someone other than her husband, and no one got hurt? How was that possible?
- 📝 Is there anywhere that has not been at war with Britain?
- 📝 Besides the US in 1958, has there been a post-WWII show of force by any military in the Taiwan Strait (excluding Taiwan and China)?
- 📝 Was there ever a single collection of the Corpus Juris Civilis and has it survived?
- 📝 Was there a time when George Washington discovered some of his soldiers absolutely refused to swear loyalty and obedience to the Continental Congress?
- 📝 Have there been any notable people that have claimed that classism and not racism is the current cause of racial inequality?
- 📝 Was there a direct telephone line between Stalin and Hitler during the war?
- 📝 Has there been a war whose declared goal was a mere land grab without any attempts to ethically justify it?
- 📝 Has there ever been a war where 2 parties who were at war with each other cooperated on a strike against a third party?
- 📝 Has there ever been a society with impartial distribution of privilege and punishment where all members of the society have equal status.
- 📝 Why China was able to unify and not Europe?
- 📝 Has there ever been a truly multi-sided war?
- 📝 Has there ever been a non-rectangular banknote?
- 📝 Was murdering a slave illegal in American slavery, and if so, what punishments were given for it?
- 📝 Has there ever been a case when a traitorous military commander took command again for the side he betrayed?
- 📝 When did FDR announce he was running a 3rd time, and was there any outrage?
- 📝 Has there ever been an instance of an active nuclear power plant within or near a war zone?
- 📝 Has there ever been a peaceful overthrow of a dictator or monarch?
- 📝 Has there ever been a battle with only a single survivor?
- 📝 Has there been a naval battle where a boarding attempt backfired?
- 📝 Has there ever been a major migration from the New World to the Old World? If not, why?
- 📝 Has there been any "invasive plants warfare" in the past?
- 📝 Has there ever been anything like the oil boom we see today?