How do Jehovah's Witnesses explain Thomas's exclamation, "My Lord and my God"?
score:6
If you look up the apostle Thomas in the Watchtower Online Library at JW.org, you can find three links that address the topic of John 20:28: a section on Jesus Christ from their book Insight, a section on Jesus Christ from their book Reasoning, and an Awake! magazine article called "Those Who Are Called 'Gods.'" I'll quote from all three sources in this answer.
Insight indicates that there are two permissible explanations of the passage:
Some scholars have viewed this expression as an exclamation of astonishment spoken to Jesus but actually directed to God, his Father. However, others claim the original Greek requires that the words be viewed as being directed to Jesus. Even if this is so, the expression "My Lord and my God" would still have to harmonize with the rest of the inspired Scriptures.
The first explanation is neither elaborated upon nor mentioned anywhere else, but it's consistent with hogarth45's anecdotal answer. The Governing Body of Jehovah's Witnesses seems to favor the latter explanation, that Thomas is calling Jesus "my God" in a way that doesn't jeopardize their beliefs about Jesus and God. They point out parallels between this use of the word "god" and other Biblical uses where they also don't believe Jehovah is the referent:
- Insight mentions that in many cases of appearances of angels, the Bible "spoke of that angelic messenger as though he were Jehovah God" because "the angelic messenger was acting for Jehovah as his representative." Note, however, that Nicene Christians often interpret these same passages as instances of pre-incarnate appearances of Jesus.
- They point out that earlier in John, Jesus approvingly quoted Psalm 82, which calls "powerful men" gods, and "Christ occupies a position far higher than such men."
- Citing John 1:1 (NWT), they say that Jesus is "divine" or "godlike" or "a god." JWs even believe that, in Isaiah 9:6, "Mighty God" is a title appropriately given to Jesus, while noting carefully that it is not "Almighty God." He is even referred to as "the only-begotten god" in John 1:18.
All three sources also note that the context (John 20) includes two other significant mentions of the relationship between Jesus and God which, they say, demonstrate that he is not the Almighty God. Reasoning gives the most extensive treatment:
Shortly before Jesus' death, Thomas had heard Jesus' prayer in which he addressed his Father as "the only true God." (John 17:3, RS) After Jesus' resurrection Jesus had sent a message to his apostles, including Thomas, in which he had said: "I am ascending ... to my God and your God." (John 20:17, RS) After recording what Thomas said when he actually saw and touched the resurrected Christ, the apostle John stated: "These are written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in his name." (John 20:31, RS) So, if anyone has concluded from Thomas' exclamation that Jesus is himself "the only true God" or that Jesus is a Trinitarian "God the Son," he needs to look again at what Jesus himself said (vs. 17) and at the conclusion that is clearly stated by the apostle John (vs. 31).
Upvote:1
The answer that I have been given was that Thomas looked to Jesus and stated "My Lord" and then to heaven and said "My God" as a praise to Jeohovah for his miracle.
I know this answer doesn't have an "official stance of the WatchTower" feel to it, but nine times out of ten, this will be the answer they give you on your doorstep.
I have looked, with no luck, for a Bible commentary for the NWT Bible. So if anyone knows of one, I would appreciate a link.
Upvote:2
A few possibilities from least to most likely-
1- Thomas could have simply been making an improper exclamation. Apostles have been shown to make mistakes.
2- Given how he said "my lord and my God" rather than "my lord and God," Granville Sharp's rule would imply that he was very specifically not applying bith names to the same individual, but speaking as though he were addressing two individually.
3- This appears to be a greek idiom. Similar to how one should be baptized "by water and by spirit" the better translation qould be to treat the 2nd term as an adverb modifying the first i.e. "spiritual water." Therefore this could be translated something like "my heavenly lord!"
But yes, this scripture is difficult to clearly match the context of other scriptures. This one doesn't have a clear cut answer. But we're confident that the potentially mistranslated words of a doubtful man outweighs the words of Jesus at John 17:3. If there is disagreement there, I wouldn't assume Jesus to be wrong.
Upvote:2
This is the official explanation as written in the Watchtower Society's book "Insight on the Scriptures" Vol. 2, pages 55-6 (published in 1988). A bold-type heading reads, "What did Thomas mean when he said to Jesus, 'My Lord and my God'"?
"On the occasion of Jesus' appearance to Thomas and the other apostles, which had removed Thomas' doubts of Jesus' resurrection, the now convinced Thomas exclaimed to Jesus: "My Lord and my God!! [literally, "The Lord of me and the God (ho Theos') of me!"]." (Joh 20:24-29) Some scholars have viewed this expression as an exclamation of astonishment spoken to Jesus but actually directed to God, his Father. However, others claim the original Greek requires that the words be viewed as being directed to Jesus. Even if this is so, the expression "My Lord and my God" would still have to harmonize with the rest of the inspired Scriptures. Since the record shows that Jesus had previously sent his disciples the message, "I am ascending to my Father and your Father and to my God and your God," there is no reason for believing that Thomas thought Jesus was the Almighty God. (Joh 20:17) John himself, after recounting Thomas' encounter with the resurrected Jesus, says of this and similar accounts: "But these have been written down that you may believe that, because of believing, you may have life by means of his name." - Joh 20:30, 31
So, Thomas may have addressed Jesus as "my God" in the sense of Jesus' being "a god" though not the Almighty God, not "the only true God," to whom Thomas had often heard Jesus pray. (Joh 17:1-3)"
I interrupt the quotation here to make a point. There is a suggestion that Thomas "may have" used that form of address because he thought Jesus was "a god" but not the Almighty God. They go on to give a second suggestion. I resume quoting:
"Or he may have addressed Jesus as "my God" in a way similar to expressions made by his forefathers, recorded in the Hebrew Scriptures, with which Thomas was familiar... [various scriptures listed where a messenger of Jehovah was addressed as if he were Jehovah God] Thomas may therefore have spoken to Jesus as "my God" in this sense, acknowledging or confessing Jesus as the representative and spokesman of the true God. Whatever the case, it is certain that Thomas' words do not contradict the clear statement he himself had heard Jesus make, namely, "The Father is greater than I am." - Joh 14:28"
It is interesting that two suggestions are offered but no clear statement is made as to what the writer of the article goes by. Perhaps the readers (it is hoped) will combine both suggestions. The writer of the article is clearly going by the New World Translation, which only ascribes partial deity to Christ.
More post
- 📝 What was Adolf von Harnack's case that Priscilla wrote Hebrews?
- 📝 According to the Catholic Church, what did Jesus mean by saying that the least in the kingdom of heaven in greater than John the Baptist?
- 📝 Will World end on Oct 7,2015?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for the concept of 'balance' between 'two extremes'?
- 📝 Which manuscript was the LDS Book of Moses translated from?
- 📝 Do LDS believe in Original Sin after all?
- 📝 When did the practice of bringing non-believers to church originate?
- 📝 Are there any denominations opposed to organ transplant donation or receipt?
- 📝 What are vows? Are they relevant even today?
- 📝 Required readings for courses on the Gospels at the Westminster Theological Seminary
- 📝 Did Justin Martyr have a personal interaction with Jesus Christ?
- 📝 What is so appealing about Christianity?
- 📝 Did Jews ever worship other gods during the Second Temple Period?
- 📝 Where did Augustine say that the same fire that tortures the damned purifies the elect?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for Universal salvation?
- 📝 Can I be rebaptized now that I have truly found God?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the belief that God loves individuals?
- 📝 How do Catholics respond to claims that Christianity was paganised by the Roman Empire?
- 📝 How does the doctrine of British Baptists compare with their American cousins?
- 📝 How do Christians who think animals have only existed for <7,000 years on Earth reconcile their views with Pleistocene saber-toothed tigers?
- 📝 Is Leviticus 18:22 condemnation of h*m*sexuality only for idolatrous rituals?
- 📝 Was Jesus resurrected after or {within} three days of his death?
- 📝 Asking for help or saying thanks?
- 📝 God Telling Hagar to Return and then to Leave
- 📝 How does the Tree of Life fit in Evolutionary Creationism
- 📝 How do Calvinists interpret "Your word is a lamp to my feet And a light to my path" and "He shall direct your paths"?
- 📝 How does Catholicism deal with the apparent paradox/conflict between "love thy neighbour" and "you will be rewarded"
- 📝 Why did God want a Tabernacle built by Moses?
- 📝 What are arguments for the divine inspiration of the longer ending of Mark (Mark 16:9-20)?
- 📝 Does a Christian have enemies outside of the world, the flesh, and the devil?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses explain Thomas's exclamation, "My Lord and my God"?
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses explain John 8:58-59 in a way that accords with their doctrine?
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses explain the dramatic changes in their eschatology?
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses explain Paul's apparent equating of Yahweh and Jesus in Romans 10?
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses explain Paul's apparent equating of Yahweh and Jesus in Ephesians 4?
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses explain Mark 1:1–3?
- 📝 How do Biblical Unitarians contextually explain Thomas' exclamation at John 20:28?
- 📝 How do Jehovah Witnesses explain differences between NWT and Hebrew/Latin/Greek in Zechariah 12:10 and Acts 20:28?
- 📝 How do Jehovah’s Witnesses explain the unique wording of Colossians 1:15-17 in the NWT?
- 📝 How do Jehovah Witnesses explain the anger of Caiphas?
- 📝 How does the Catholic church explain Matthew 19:9, which seems to allow divorce in case of sexual misconduct?
- 📝 How do Jehovah Witnesses support scripturely the idea that humans will live on earth after death?
- 📝 How do Trinitarians explain verses where Jesus claims to have a God?
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses respond to the charge that they are false prophets (because their end-of-the-world predictions didn't come true)?
- 📝 How do Calvinists explain God's wanting no one to perish and electing some to judgement?
- 📝 How do Trinitarians explain John 17:3?
- 📝 How do Old-Earth Creationists explain Romans 5:12-19?
- 📝 How do local flood proponents explain God's promises to never do it again?
- 📝 How do "once saved, always saved" advocates explain the Parable of the Sower?
- 📝 How do the proponents of the idea that salvation once received cannot be lost explain Hebrews 6:4-6 and 10:26-29?
- 📝 How do creationists explain the genetic diversity of animals after Noah's Ark?
- 📝 How do theistic evolutionists explain moral reasoning?
- 📝 How many witnesses are there who physically saw and/or touched the golden plates from which the Book of Mormon was reportedly translated?
- 📝 How do young earth creationists explain the evidence for ice ages?
- 📝 How do Christians explain commonalities between their religion, other major faiths and obscure isolated tribal belief systems?
- 📝 How would a Catholic explain the absence of the mass in the Epistle to the Hebrews?
- 📝 How do monothelites explain Jesus' prayer in the garden of Gethsemane?
- 📝 Do Jehovah's Witnesses have membership fees or how are they funded?
- 📝 How do Calvinists explain Calvin's use of Baruch?
- 📝 How do opponents of Penal Substitution explain God's declaration that He "will not leave the guilty unpunished"?