Is there an argument that God, as a self-proving entity, is necessary for logic?
score:8
I think you're referring to The Transcendental Argument for the Existence of God (TAG). It was first formulated by Immanuel Kant, but has been refined, disputed and defended over the years.
The argument
One formulation of the argument is,
Prove A: The Christian God exists.
Step 1 ~A: (Assume the opposite of what we are trying to prove): The Christian God does not exist.
Step 2 (~A--> B): If God does not exist, then there is no intelligible experience since God is the precondition of intelligibility
Step 3 (~B): There is intelligible experience (Contradiction!)
Step 4 (~ ~A): It is not the case that God does not exist (Modus Tollens on 2 and 3)
Step 5 (A): --> God does exist (Law of negation.)Source: Reformed Apologist (blog)
The finer details of whether this argument actually is valid, of course, need a more thorough explanation. The argument isn't fundamentally based on inductive nor deductive, but transcendental reasoning. Kant describes transcendental as follows:
I entitle transcendental all knowledge which is occupied not so much with objects as with the mode of our knowledge of objects insofar as this mode of knowledge is to be possible a priori.
Thus to properly examine and understand the argument, I suspect a more in-depth studying is required. I'm not a philosopher and don't claim to understand TAG, so I'll just point you elsewhere:
Further reading
Butler, Michael R. The Transcendental Argument for God's Existence.
Upvote:0
Indeed, for logic and any other knowledge to exist, there should be directly experienced thing that does not need proving. Yet it is not evident that this thing should necessary have properties, which are attributed by Christians to God.
As metaphysics tells us via Anthropic principle, it is existence of self that is needed for logic and any experimental facts to exist. In other words, for the universe to exist there should be an observer, for logic to exist, the observer should be conscious.
It is possible to compare the properties of the self and Christian God.
Christian God creates the Universe consciously.
The self while necessary for Universe to exist, has limited abilities to affect it consciously.
Christian God is almighty
The self is not almighty definitely. It has limited abilities to affect the things in the universe (freedom of will) though. However, such ability guarantees that the Universe is neither deterministic nor random (free will is incompatible with both determinism and randomness, see Peter van Inwagen).
Christian god does not obey physical laws
The self also does not obey the usual physical laws. Even more, there can be no universally valid physical theory, that is theory that correctly describes a system that contains the self (see Thomas Breuer). Yet this disobedience has own limits: on practice it is usually manifested by the existence of principally non-measurable parameters (subjective decoherence, see Breuer).
Christian God is immortal.
It is unknown whether the self is immortal. Either case, death of the self means disappearance of the universe. There are suggested quite plausible mechanisms through which the self may be immortal.
Upvote:1
that in order for logic to be valid, one could not have circular arguments...
Bad Logic does not prove that logic does not exist. At the very least all it proves is that bad logic exist.
but since you can't prove your premises, all arguments had to be unfounded or circular unless you introduced God as some sort of self-proving entity.
This is a very broad generalization. Why can't the theist prove their arguments. Kalaam Cosmological argument seems like good proof to me. It is a in depth discussion, but to think Christian notion of God is circular would need quiet a bit of explaining. (to say the least)
(e.g. why it is okay for God to effectively be a circular argument but not for anything else to be)
It would not be good for it to be circular, but where has the Christian God committed circular logic? The skeptic needs some argument to support that view because I'm not aware of any argument for God's existence that is circular.
Does this argument have a name, and is it (or at least a summary) written somewhere?
Not that I'm aware of. It is the first time I have heard of someone thinking the notion of a God commits circular logic.
I'm not quiet sure how to answer this objection because the OP makes some assertions but does not back it up with something substantial to support the claim
I suspect that some strawmanning of arguments are to blame for this
More post
- 📝 What does the Catholic Church require for a parent's name to appear on the child's baptism certificate?
- 📝 Do any Protestant denominations recognize Latter Day Saints as Christians?
- 📝 What did Luther have against Zwingli?
- 📝 How do Protestants counteract the Witnesses stance on Blood Transfusions?
- 📝 Identifying a Saint on a Greek Orthodox icon?
- 📝 Saint Quotes on Holy Obedience to Overcome Satan
- 📝 Why does God have a chosen people?
- 📝 For Jehovah's Witnesses, what are the ingredients to the bread and the wine?
- 📝 Are there any modern churches that subscribe to the Donatist heresy?
- 📝 What is the take of Catholic Church on the dream of Pilate's wife?
- 📝 What is the history of the "Jews for Jesus" movement?
- 📝 Are things commonly blessed by priests at certain times of the year appropriate to bring to a priest for a special blessing?
- 📝 How do those who hold to a view of open communion practice church discipline?
- 📝 How are Christians expected to live up to the standards of following Christ?
- 📝 What is the LDS (Mormon) view of the necessity of Jesus death and resurrection?
- 📝 Is it cruel that God punishes us with eternal hell?
- 📝 According to Roman Catholic teaching, did people who died in Old Testament times spend time in Purgatory?
- 📝 Did any early church fathers view the Creation account in Genesis as being allegorical?
- 📝 CS Lewis said time would probably continue in Heaven...But how?
- 📝 If miracles stopped after the Apostles, then why are there admonitions to pray over people?
- 📝 How common are manifestations of charismatic gifts among saints venerated in Orthodox and/or Catholic Churches?
- 📝 Was tithing 10% required or encouraged by the early church?
- 📝 How do Christians justify worshiping someone who kills naive children/innocent beings?
- 📝 What happened to Joseph, Jesus' father?
- 📝 Should protestants not make the sign of the Cross?
- 📝 Why did Paul say "I am pure from the blood of all men"?
- 📝 A female demon name starting with the letter "S"
- 📝 What resurrection are they talking about? Matthew 22:28
- 📝 What do Catholics believe about Yom kippur and judgment?
- 📝 Is it possible for a spirit to eat fish?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Is there an argument that God, as a self-proving entity, is necessary for logic?
- 📝 What evidence is there that God as father was a common concept for Jesus's first century Jewish audience?
- 📝 Are there any denominations that give official advice on how to win atheists for Christ who are very strong in philosophy, logic and skepticism?
- 📝 Is there a name for the belief that God is not omniscient, but rather is "learning" how to deal with humanity?
- 📝 Why is it not that a state divorce is actually an argument AGAINST a church annulment petition rather than a necessary condition for such petition?
- 📝 Is there a Biblical basis for not believing that Global Warming is occurring?
- 📝 Are there Old Testament Scriptures that mention salvation for the Gentiles?
- 📝 Are there theological explanations for why God allowed ambiguity to exist in Scripture?
- 📝 What is the argument and Biblical basis that it is possible to know God from nature?
- 📝 What evidence is there to support the position that the Bible is truly the Word of God to mankind?
- 📝 Is there a biblical basis for God calling one to place one's career above their other duties?
- 📝 Is there any biblical justification for referring to God as Mother?
- 📝 Is there any evidence for the claim that the Catholic church suppressed translation of Scripture?
- 📝 What is the biblical argument for eating meat, or that vegetarianism is possible but not commanded?
- 📝 What is the basis for believing that the wrath of God is not an accommodation?
- 📝 What is the basis for the idea that the Song of Solomon is about the relationship between God and the church?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the belief that God likes or feels affection toward us?
- 📝 Is there a name for the belief that some individuals would always freely reject salvation no matter the world in which they are created?
- 📝 Is there a recognised soteriology that combines selective election for some and general election for everyone else?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the Athanasian Creed's statement that believing in the Trinity is necessary for salvation?
- 📝 What is the basis for the Swedenborgian view that the most common concept of God in Christianity (the Trinity) is a belief in three gods?
- 📝 What is the biblical basis for the belief that God loves individuals?
- 📝 Is there historical evidence for an atheist argument about the New Testament?
- 📝 Is there a doctrine or Biblical justification that explains why God chose the number 7 to be so significant?
- 📝 Is there any tradition that argues for prophetical succession under the Old Testament just like some argue for Apostolic succession?
- 📝 Is there Biblical support for the concept that 'Whenever a man lies with a woman...a transcendental relation is set up between them'?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for believing that God punishes Christians for disobedience?
- 📝 What is the Biblical basis for the belief that there are humans in heaven now?
- 📝 Is there a term for a theological principle that if a New Testament text is unclear about something, that point is not important for salvation?
- 📝 On what basis was Jesus’ death sufficient for redemption according Non-Trinitarians who maintain that Jesus was not eternal God as God the Father is?