In Catholicism, why should Jesus have been murdered on the Cross instead of just dying of old age?
Upvote:1
Introduction
There are a number of ways to approach this question for example my answer to this question: How is the matter of why the Son of God needed to be sacrificed explained in the Roman Catholic Church? contains some essential points that will be common to all answers from a Catholic standpoint. Some of those points are:
1) God is free.
2) God does whatever he pleases in accordance with his nature.
3) God has infinite solutions to each of what to creatures are problems: “With men this is impossible, but with God all things are possible.”.
4) Faced with the "problem" of man's redemption, God could have chosen to act or not to act. Once he chose to act, he had infinite solutions to the "problem".
5) Once he decreed the work of redemption, he also decreed the manner by which the redemption would be wrought.
6) According to Church teaching grounded in scripture and explained by theology, redemption is by blood.
7) There is meaning behind and fittingness of the manner of redemption, in this case redemption by the blood of the God-made-man.
Answer
This answer takes from The Theology of the Precious Blood by Edwin Kaiser, C.PP.S. | Catholic Culture. The articles lays out some key points:
1) That God was not obliged to accept any atonement; God could have condoned the sin and demanded no atonement whatever; God might have been satisfied with partial atonement and granted partial condonation. In all of this God was free, nor would either His justice or His mercy have been impaired by His choice. But God decided that man should be shown mercy and be pardoned.
2) The very act of God assuming created nature [not necesarily human], God abasing himself, would have been more than sufficient to redeem because every act of God-made-creature has infinite value.
Therefore according to Catholic teaching and theology, Christ need not have been "violently murdered" and could have "simply died old age", and this could have been more than sufficient for the redemption.
Mary could have brought forth [the] male child, [and] her child [...] caught up [immediately] to God and to his throne without undergoing any pain and suffering and still this would have been more than sufficient for the redemption.
In my other answer I have also stated from Church teaching that since redemption is by blood, a small drop from Jesus as when he was circumcised would have been more than sufficient for the redemption.
Endnote
There is a paragraph in the article that ends:
We insist on this point because some have misunderstood the whole Catholic doctrine of Redemption as though it were based on a cruel and vindictive concept of divine justice. (my emphasis)
I thought perhaps this is what may have prompted the OP's question. I would encourage the OP to read the entire article but I would also add that whichever was the things of God are looked at, man is always faced with a mystery.
Further Reading
More post
- 📝 Christian significance of Tolkien and C. S. Lewis putting "heaven" across the sea?
- 📝 Is there a moral goodness in In vitro fertilization?
- 📝 How much authority does a father have over his wife and children?
- 📝 Why did God deliver his message through Jesus instead of a flesh-and-blood prophet?
- 📝 Paintings of the Holy Family with a young St. Joseph?
- 📝 How do Protestants interpret Ezekiel 18:20-32?
- 📝 What were the circumstances behind the loss of the "True Cross?"
- 📝 Are the Old Testament prohibitions on incest applicable to Christians?
- 📝 Why do Christian missionaries start schools?
- 📝 According to Catholic doctrine, is every woman that has an abortion automatically going to hell?
- 📝 Would a JW be disfellowshipped if they join a military (and are unrepentant about it)?
- 📝 Was the wine in The Last Supper fermented?
- 📝 How do we know the events described in the bible are true?
- 📝 What did the Dominicans have against the immaculate conception?
- 📝 According to Catholicism, why are all sins against the 6th and 9th Commandments grave matter ex toto genere suo?
- 📝 How is Tamar Viewed in Judeo-Christian tradition?
- 📝 What are the common arguments against theistic evolution?
- 📝 Looking for a passage about God forbidding that a census be taken
- 📝 what is the background situation of Paul's vow ? (Acts 18:18)
- 📝 Has Numbers 19:11-12 been considered when discussing why Jesus rose on the third day?
- 📝 How did Matthew conclude that Isaiah 7:14 refers to Jesus?
- 📝 Who's talking to John in Revelation 22?
- 📝 If John wrote the 4th Gospel, why did he not name himself or his brother?
- 📝 What is the scriptural basis for clerical celibacy?
- 📝 How should we interpret Leviticus 18, 19?
- 📝 Why do (some) Anglican vicars use 'sing-songy' voices?
- 📝 Under what conditions can a re-married Catholic couple receive the sacrament of the eucharist?
- 📝 (Jehovah's Witnesses) What reason(s) is there to actually love God?
- 📝 How do Jehovah's Witnesses interpret verses like Isaiah 9:6 which call the messiah 'God'?
- 📝 What is the special significance of prayers said in a hushed voice by the celebrant during the Holy Mass of Catholic Church?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 In Catholicism, why should Jesus have been murdered on the Cross instead of just dying of old age?
- 📝 What is the basis for arguing that Paul should have been selected as the 12th apostle instead of Matthias?
- 📝 Why did Jesus raise people from the dead, when they would have been in heaven?
- 📝 Why is the Crucifixion said to have been between 30-33 AD, if Jesus was born between 4-6 B.C. and lived to be 33 years old?
- 📝 Immortal soul concept: why does Bible say Jesus was resurrected after 3 days, as he should never have been really dead?
- 📝 Why is Jesus named the Prince of Peace instead of the King of Peace?
- 📝 Why did Jesus have to leave for the Holy Spirit to come?
- 📝 Why did Jesus physically throw out the money changers instead of winning the argument with reason?
- 📝 Why does Jesus have to be fully God and fully man? Is it not sufficient to be the son of God and fully man?
- 📝 Why didn't God send Jesus during Noah's time instead of The Flood?
- 📝 Why are the men of Genesis so old? Were the dating systems just different? Are all of these old ages supposed to have symbolic meaning?
- 📝 What does the Bible say about this question- Why do Jesus and God have two seats in heaven when they are the same God?
- 📝 For those who deny the Immaculate Conception, why did Jesus not have original sin?
- 📝 How did the early Christians and Apostles Get into the temple? Shouldn't they have been stoned by the Jews for preaching Jesus as God?
- 📝 If Anger is one of the Seven Deadly Sins, how could Jesus have been angry yet still be sinless? (Catholicism)
- 📝 Has Numbers 19:11-12 been considered when discussing why Jesus rose on the third day?
- 📝 Why did Joseph and Mary take one day's time to realize that Jesus had been left behind at the Temple?
- 📝 Why do we have to make the Sign of the Cross physically?
- 📝 Could Jesus have been born in September instead of December?
- 📝 Why did Jesus not clearly state the Old Testament canon, instead of letting others to take account for that?
- 📝 Why does the Holy Spirit not take the form of a human being just like Jesus did?
- 📝 Was Jesus having the beatific vision when He said: "My God, My God, why have you forsaken Me?"
- 📝 Who found whom? After Jesus FINDS Philip, why does Philip tell Nathanael "We have FOUND the One..."?
- 📝 Why do Christians pray to Jesus instead of to God the Father directly, and isn't it risky?
- 📝 According to Catholic doctrine, why did Jesus Christ have to die to save mankind if only the physical body is involved in death?
- 📝 Why do Jehovah Witnesses think that the cross doesn't have hands?
- 📝 Why Jesus died on the cross and not by any other mean?
- 📝 What have been the justifications by organised Christian groups on why around 500 witnesses are convincing when Legion can control thousands?
- 📝 Why did Jesus not want to be known as the Messiah?
- 📝 Has any prominent theologian ever explained why Jesus let a thief be in charge of the money?