Can a pope be a heretic?
score:3
What would happen if a pope were to be a formal heretic?
Formal heresy is obstinately denying Catholic truths, even after being warned.
If a pope were to define a "dogma" ex cathedra that contradicts Catholic teaching, this "dogma" would not be binding nor be protected by papal infallibility as defined at Vatican I. Definable Catholic dogmas must first be material dogmas (cf. Pope Pius XII's letter to all bishops regarding to the definability of the Dogma of the Assumption), i.e., truths connected to Revelation and believed by the Church in all times and space, either explicitly or implicitly. Even Popes are bound to Tradition.
Does the Pope lose his office?
The common opinion is yes, but when is another question:
There are two major camps among theologians regarding when. One (that of St. Robert Bellarmine and Suarez) says that he would immediately lose his office, even before being warned and given an opportunity to correct his error. The other (that of John of St. Thomas and Cajetan) says God would take the office away from him after the Church convicts him and declares him a heretic (or "vitandus" = "to be avoided").
If so, how is that formalised?
It is divine law that the Church must separate herself from heretics (cf. Gal. 1:8-9), so the Church has a duty to warn the pope, try him, and (if it comes to this) declare him a heretic and proceed to elect a valid pope.
Do the cardinals have the power to kick him out?
No, not even all the world's bishops have the power to depose a valid pope. To think that would be the heresy of Conciliarism, that Councils of bishops (sans the pope) have equal or greater authority than the pope.
See also my answer to the question "In Catholic understanding when there is more than one Pope, who decides which Pope is real and by what criteria?"
An excellent recent work that covers all these issues (whether a pope can be a heretic; whether he can be elected if he was previously a heretic; whether a pope loses his office by proclaiming heresy; who can declare him a heretic; when he loses his office; how is he deposed, considering he has no superior on earth; etc.; etc.) is:
- True or False Pope? by John Salza & Robert Siscoe (St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary Press, Aug. 2015)
Another good one is:
- Can the Pope Go Bad?: A Call for the Resumption of a Debate Not Taken Seriously Since the 17th Century by the Brazilian intellectual A. V. Xavier da Silveira (Catholic Research Institute, Sep. 1999)
Upvote:0
The question in the title is far broader than the question in the text.
To the question in the title "Can a pope be a heretic?", the answer is "Yes, except for the particular case addressed below.", and that hypothetical situation would not entail an automatic loss of office.
To the question in the text, rephrased as "What would happen if a pope defines a heretical doctrine on faith or morals by a definition which formally satisfies the requirements of infallibility (*) set by the Constitution "Pastor Aeternus" of Ecumenical Council Vatican I?" the answer is "That cannot really happen, and the only valid inference of it apparently happening is that the person in question was not really the pope at the moment of issuing the heretical definition."
(*) "we teach and define that it is a dogma divinely revealed: that the Roman Pontiff, when he speaks ex Cathedra, that is,
- when in exercise of the office of pastor and doctor of all Christians,
- by virtue of his supreme Apostolic authority,
- he defines a doctrine regarding faith or morals
- to be held by the universal Church,
by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, possesses that infallibility with which the divine Redeemer willed that his Church should be endowed for defining doctrine regarding faith or morals;" (bullet structure added for clarity)
More post
- 📝 Will there be ongoing co-creation (aka technological development) in heaven?
- 📝 Should Christians come out strongly against groups that do evil in Christ's name?
- 📝 Does Sola Scriptura entail Cessationism?
- 📝 List of old heresies condemned by the Catholic Church now present in Lutheranism and Calvinism
- 📝 What is the significance of the name, "The Word"?
- 📝 Why is Christianity so despised in the World?
- 📝 Whom or what did Azazel signify in the Old Testament?
- 📝 What does it mean to judge the fatherless?
- 📝 How do I have self confidence, self esteem and work hard if I am a true Christian?
- 📝 Are white lies sometime justified?
- 📝 How does Christianity define idolatry?
- 📝 What is the difference between the two creations of humans, according to those who believe they are in chronological order?
- 📝 What's the Biblical basis for "all Christians will be together in heaven some day"?
- 📝 An image of half a leg on a church wall?
- 📝 Do the measurements of the Ark have any important significance?
- 📝 According to Catholicism what does it mean for every relationship in heaven to be perfect and fulfilling?
- 📝 Is a Catholic canon a prebendary?
- 📝 "The Son of Man", Jesus' favorite designation of himself, in view of Numbers 23:19-20?
- 📝 What is an overview of arguments for and against the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus?
- 📝 Which lamb in the Old Testament is Jesus equated to?
- 📝 How many prophecies in the Old Testament are about Jesus?
- 📝 How to approach h*m*sexuality scandals in view of Canon Law and Church Tradition?
- 📝 Is brethren a currently used term for plural of brother (monks)?
- 📝 Is there a standard version of the Bible?
- 📝 What are the massive stables at Megeto?
- 📝 Does the Trinity share one mind or are there three separate minds?
- 📝 How can we defend our faith against the "Argument from Evil" or "Problem of Evil"?
- 📝 Who would Cain be worried about slaying him in Gen 4:14? Up till this point, all that are mentioned are Adam, Eve, Cain and Abel
- 📝 Does Nehemiah Gordon self-identify as a Christian?
- 📝 Why was Christ's sacrifice such a big cost?
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 How can a Pope be chosen from outside the conclave?
- 📝 Under Catholic dogma can someone publicly rebuke the Pope like Paul rebuked Peter?
- 📝 When and how can a pope revoke the decrees of an ecumenical council?
- 📝 Can a Pope elevate a non-heretical yet minority opinion to the level of dogma?
- 📝 Can a Patron Saint formally declared as such by a pope be replaced?
- 📝 Can a pope be a heretic?
- 📝 Can a pope name his successor?
- 📝 What are the duties of a Pope? Can a pope be "good" or "bad" in this perspective?
- 📝 Can the Pope speak ex cathedra about the return of Christ?
- 📝 Can Pope use his Interdict power to force changes in national laws regarding abortion?
- 📝 Can anyone explain Pope Paul VI's arguments in favor of Padre Pio?
- 📝 According to the Catholic Church, can one be a heretic and still obtain salvation?
- 📝 Can a lay person or a group of lay faithful petition the Pope (Vatican) to de-canonize a Saint in light of new findings?
- 📝 Can the Pope be excommunicated?
- 📝 Can there be free will in heaven?
- 📝 Can I believe in evolution and still be a Christian?
- 📝 If the Ten Commandments say “thou shalt not kill” how can a Christian fight in a war?
- 📝 How can the Son not know what the Father knows?
- 📝 How can the sun be created after day and night?
- 📝 How can we trust the Bible after it has been translated to another language?
- 📝 When does the Pope speak ex cathedra?
- 📝 How can one overcome lustful desires?
- 📝 Can somebody summarize the different "branches" of Christianity to me, and explain why they exist in the first place?
- 📝 Can man judge whether God is fair?
- 📝 How could Jacob wrestle with God if no one can see God and live?
- 📝 Does the pope get paid for being the pope?
- 📝 What Bible verses suggest that humans can become angels?
- 📝 Can a Christian choose to walk away from his or her salvation?
- 📝 What are some countries where you can be imprisoned for reading or owning a Bible?
- 📝 Can an atheist go to heaven?