Is Buddhism hell falsely claimed on wikipedia?
score:2
In the mind ...
Buddhist hell only exists in one's mind
Here's an interesting story:
To me that story implies that:
- Heaven and hell can be experienced (or seen) now (or just a moment away)
- They exist as a consequence of (as result of) speech (by the monk) and action (by the soldier)
- They manifest in real life (including "physically") and not "only in one's mind"
Some people do have a view that the world can seem like hell, depending on your state of mind. If hell were defined as "continuous suffering", according to that definition some people might see the current world as a state of woe.
... but not 'only' in the mind
But even if "hell" does exist in (or is perceived or experienced by) one's present mind (as illustrated above), it might be a mistake to assume that it only exists in the mind.
The suttas do describe hell realms -- for example Devaduta Sutta (MN 130) was referenced in the Wikipedia article. I see nothing in that text which shows that the Buddha must have been talking metaphorically.
Theoretically I see three possibilities:
- The Buddha was speaking metaphorically (e.g. to persuade people to behave well)
- The Buddha was speaking literally (there is literally a realm like that)
- Something else
In any case, that sutta certainly appears to be referring to a state which may happen in the future, and is not just a state which is "only in one's mind" (in the present) -- it says,
I — by means of the divine eye, purified & surpassing the human — see beings passing away & re-appearing ...
... Or how these beings — who were endowed with bad conduct of body, speech & mind, who reviled noble ones, held wrong views and undertook actions under the influence of wrong views — with the break-up of the body, after death, have re-appeared in a plane of deprivation, a bad destination, a lower realm, hell.'
In summary
In summary you might find it useful to think of "hell" as something which "exists in one's mind", and which is taught to be a realm experienced "with the break-up of the body, after death", or seen "with the divine eye".
By analogy, if you see a photograph of something then it does "exist in the photograph": but it would be odd to say that it exists only in the photograph (the thing photographed may also still exist in real life).
In Wikipedia
FYI according to Wikipedia the Narakas are also described in Hinduism.
Within Buddhism (the article you referenced in the OP),
There are several schemes for enumerating these Narakas and describing their torments. The Abhidharma-kosa (Treasure House of Higher Knowledge) is the root text that describes the most common scheme, the Eight Cold Narakas and Eight Hot Narakas.
You're asking whether Wikipedia is wrong and why no-one changes it: but it doesn't seem to be "wrong" i.e. it is reporting or summarizing what's written in Buddhist literature.
The emphasis or people's interpretation of the Wikipedia article may be wrong, but so far as I know its content is more or less OK for an article that's titled "Naraka (Buddhism)".
Upvote:2
There are instances where painful mental states or experiances are called hell. [Patala Sutta] E.g. If I do something that might ripen in being born in hell you also get the hellish feeling here and now, [Maha Dukkha-k,khandha Sutta, Cūla Dukkha-k,khandha Sutta] and in case you are born in the human world similar pains will be experienced. [Maha Kamma,vibhaṅga Sutta, Cūla Kamma Vibhaṅga Sutta]
A more vivid description of hell is found in Bala Pandita Sutta, (Yama) Deva,dūta Sutta and Deva,dūta Sutta. Neyy’attha Nīt’attha Sutta mentions that the Buddha uses direct and indirect languages. Though these destinations may exist some of the descriptions maybe parables so you can draw an analogy of what is there to a concept that you might be familiar with as Arana Vibhanga Sutta mentions that when teaching Dhamma you should use common and familiar language giving allowance to the audience or region they are from. This does not mean that the destination are only exist in the mind or they are parables to experiences in this world.
Also the Wikipedia articles seams mix and match from multiple schools. Also it would be an idea to keep these descriptions as per the wording of the Buddha and let the reader infer its meaning.
With regard to the descriptions in the Suttas many of the experiences in hell will not have a description in common language as language is developed to describe what we come across in this world. What is mentioned would most likely give the best idea of the suffering involved in these worlds.
More post
- 📝 What was the motivation behind Devadattas initial kindness?
- 📝 What is laughing wisdom and swift wisdom?
- 📝 Is there a way to wipe out ones Karma?
- 📝 Are practical solutions to everyday suffering that contradict Buddhism Upaya or avidya?
- 📝 What does Diamond Way Buddhism say about obstacles at times of becoming more conscious?
- 📝 Can't notice the breath
- 📝 What is the difference between an arhat, bodhisattva and a buddha?
- 📝 A limit of right speech
- 📝 What happens to consciousness/awareness when entering Paranirvana?
- 📝 What did the Buddha say about music?
- 📝 Does doing an ordinary day-to-day job account for good karma?
- 📝 Are there pictures/paintings of Nirvana?
- 📝 Can one take rebirth as an insect?
- 📝 Attention to the breath: sensations at the nostrils vs sensations at the abdomen, as they relate to serenity and insight
- 📝 Is there an absolute and known hierarchy in the Dharma?
- 📝 Does anybody knows origin and reference Buddha teaches a bossy & angry the seven kinds of wifes
- 📝 What does "self" mean?
- 📝 Sankharas, once eliminated. Do they have a chance of coming back?
- 📝 What's is the Buddhist view on persistence or grit?
- 📝 Doubt while Meditating regarding Breath
- 📝 Timing of meditation
- 📝 Alms and questions
- 📝 Have any notable Buddhists commented on Krishnamurti's teachings?
- 📝 Are absences empty / conceptual constructions, according to all Buddhists?
- 📝 What is the Buddhist Perspective on Lucid Dreaming?
- 📝 Is space impermanent?
- 📝 What is the meaning in the Buddha walking seven steps?
- 📝 How does Buddhism explains rebirth and law of Karma?
- 📝 Are there studies about the difference between meditating in the morning versus in the evening?
- 📝 Call of duty during a Dharmic war : a Buddhist perspective
Source: stackoverflow.com
Search Posts
Related post
- 📝 Is Buddhism hell falsely claimed on wikipedia?
- 📝 Heaven and Hell in Buddhism
- 📝 Has anyone ever in the history of Buddhism claimed that the phenomenal aspect of the storehouse consciousness is also permanent?
- 📝 Introductory books to Buddhism
- 📝 How to explain what Buddhism is?
- 📝 Role of belief in Buddhism
- 📝 Disenchanted with Buddhism
- 📝 Why is Buddhism not Nihilism?
- 📝 Does Zen Buddhism have canonical texts?
- 📝 Are Vajrayana and Tibetan Buddhism the same thing?
- 📝 Am I following Buddhism as a sort of Escapism?
- 📝 What teachings do all schools of Buddhism share?
- 📝 Is Buddhism just Hinduism stripped for export?
- 📝 Polyamory in Buddhism
- 📝 Does studying mathematics or science lead to a practitioner of Buddhism acquiring wrong philosophical views and mental afflictions?
- 📝 Is Buddhism a religion or a philosophy?
- 📝 Is Buddhism "opposed" to striving, or working towards a goal that you really want
- 📝 Confession in Buddhism
- 📝 How to combine Buddhism with being a parent?
- 📝 Can I practice Buddhism without meditating?
- 📝 What are the differences/similarities in the concept of faith as used in Buddhism and Christianity?
- 📝 What's Buddhism view on choice, choicelesness and causality?
- 📝 Do Buddhism and Atheism contradict each other?
- 📝 Is practicing Buddhism to be happy a wrong view?
- 📝 Can Buddhism be viewed as a threat to the capitalist way of life?
- 📝 I don't like people but I like buddhism
- 📝 Secular Buddhism and Suicide
- 📝 Learning materials for Dependent Origination (Paṭiccasamuppāda) in Theravada Buddhism
- 📝 What does Buddhism literature and tradition say about transgender folks?
- 📝 Did Buddhism oppose Vedic religion?